Biology › Section J · Evolution › Topic J.2
Formation of new species
Speciation is how one species splits into two. It begins when populations stop exchanging genes and ends when they can no longer interbreed at all.
How one species becomes two
Evolution within a species changes traits; speciation creates diversity itself, turning one lineage into two that can no longer interbreed. Darwin chose a branching tree as the only illustration in On the Origin of Species because life diversifies by branching, not by climbing a ladder. Speciation follows two main routes: populations separated by geography that evolve apart, and populations in the same place that isolate reproductively without ever being separated. Both routes end the same way — the groups' gene pools stop mixing.
What counts as a species
The biological species concept defines a species as a group of organisms that, in nature, interbreed and produce fertile, viable offspring. Horses and donkeys can mate, but their offspring, mules, are sterile — so the two are separate species. Members of a species share a gene pool: the total collection of gene variants circulating among them. The concept has limits. It cannot be applied to fossils, which do not interbreed anymore, or to asexual organisms, which never do. For those, biologists define species by body structure, DNA, and ecology instead.
Speciation is a branching event
Speciation is the formation of two species from one original species. It is not an individual changing; it is a population splitting. The split becomes permanent only when the two groups acquire reproductive isolation: barriers that prevent them from exchanging genes. The test is reunion. If separated populations are brought back together and still interbreed freely, they are one species. If they can no longer produce fertile offspring together, speciation has occurred. The rest of this topic is about how those barriers arise.
Prezygotic barriers
A prezygotic barrier blocks reproduction before a zygote (a fertilised egg) ever forms. Temporal isolation: the groups breed at different times — two frog species can share a pond while one breeds from January to March and the other from March to May. Habitat isolation: they live or lay eggs in different places, so they never meet to mate. Behavioural isolation: courtship songs, calls, or dances of one group do nothing for the other. Mechanical isolation: reproductive structures do not fit — damselfly species whose organ shapes match only their own females, or a long trumpet-creeper flower that admits hummingbirds but shuts out bees. Gametic isolation: sperm and egg of different species simply cannot fuse.
Postzygotic barriers
When fertilisation between species does happen, a postzygotic barrier can still keep the lineages separate. Hybrid inviability: the hybrid embryo stops developing, because the two species' sets of developmental instructions conflict, so the offspring never survives. Hybrid sterility: the hybrid lives a normal life but cannot reproduce — the mule again. Either way, the hybrid passes on no genes, so the parent species' gene pools stay separate even though mating occurred. Occasional hybrids in nature therefore do not automatically merge two species.
Allopatric speciation
In allopatric speciation, a geographic barrier splits a population and each half evolves on its own. Biologists sort the splits into two categories. Dispersal: a few members move to a new area, such as a mainland insect blown to a remote island. Vicariance: the landscape itself divides a population — a river changes course, a canyon deepens, a new lake forms. The northern and Mexican spotted owls of western North America are an example: once one population, they now differ genetically and physically across their separate ranges. The farther apart two groups are, the more likely speciation becomes, because their environments differ more and migrants rarely make the crossing.
Worked example: Reading an allopatric split
A rodent population lives in a valley. Over many generations a new lake forms and cuts it in two. 1. Gene flow between the halves stops immediately — no migrants cross the water. 2. Each half now accumulates its own mutations and faces its own conditions, so natural selection and chance drift pull their gene pools apart. 3. After many generations the groups differ in genes, appearance, and mating behaviour. 4. Now the test: bring them together. If they no longer interbreed and produce fertile offspring, speciation is complete; if they still do, they remain one species. Notice the mechanism: the lake causes the split, but reproductive isolation is what makes the new species real.
Sympatric speciation
In sympatric speciation, a new species forms in the same geographic area as the parent species — no barrier required. The common route in plants is polyploidy: an error in cell division doubles the chromosome sets. An autopolyploid carries extra sets from its own species; an allopolyploid combines sets from two different species, and it can take two matings to build one. Cultivated wheat, cotton, and tobacco are all allopolyploids. Because more than half of plant species trace back to a polyploid ancestor, this is the fastest known route to a new species — a single plant can found one. In animals, sympatric splits can begin when part of a population starts exploiting a different food source or microhabitat, such as fish in the same lake specialising on different depths.
Worked example: Checking chromosome counts
A diploid plant species has 14 chromosomes (2n = 14). 1. Early in development, a cell division runs its chromosome-doubling step without splitting into two cells, so the seedling's body cells carry 28 chromosomes (4n). 2. As an adult, this tetraploid makes gametes with 14 and breeds with another tetraploid, producing fertile 4n offspring. 3. But cross it with the parent species: a gamete carrying 14 fuses with a normal gamete carrying 7, giving 21 (3n). 4. Check the answer: 21 is an odd number, so the chromosomes cannot pair evenly during meiosis — the triploid hybrid is sterile. 5. Conclusion: the tetraploid is a separate species the moment it arises, because it breeds with its own kind but produces only sterile offspring with its ancestors.
Adaptive radiation
Adaptive radiation is speciation in a burst: one ancestor reaches an environment full of empty niches, and its descendants rapidly split into many species, each fitted to a different way of life. The Hawaiian honeycreepers descend from one finch-like ancestor — thick bills for cracking seeds, long curved bills for sipping nectar, slender bills for spearing insects. Darwin's Galápagos finches repeat the same pattern on a smaller scale. Islands make radiation obvious: open water keeps populations apart, and competitors are few. The key ingredients are repeated speciation plus ecological difference — each new species eats or lives where the others do not.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, speciation happens to populations, not individuals — no single organism becomes a new species. Second, geographic separation alone is not speciation; it only starts the process, which is finished only when reproduction between the groups fails. Third, keep the barrier types straight: if a hybrid exists, the barrier was postzygotic, not prezygotic — temporal, habitat, behavioural, mechanical, and gametic barriers all act before fertilisation, while inviability and sterility act after it. Fourth, the biological species concept is not universal — fossils and asexual organisms need other definitions. Fifth, do not dismiss a polyploid plant as a mere variety: its sterile crosses with the parent species make it a new species immediately.
Key takeaways
A species is a group that interbreeds in nature and produces fertile offspring, sharing one gene pool. Speciation is a branching event: one species becomes two once reproductive isolation blocks gene exchange. Prezygotic barriers stop mating or fertilisation; postzygotic barriers make hybrids die or go sterile. Allopatric speciation starts with dispersal or vicariance across a geographic barrier; sympatric speciation in plants often starts with polyploidy, an instant species in one generation. Adaptive radiation is the burst version: one ancestor, many niches, many new species.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A species is a group that interbreeds in nature and produces fertile offspring
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two frog species share a pond, but one breeds from January to March and the other from March to May. What kind of barrier keeps them separate?
Question 2 of 5
A diploid plant with 14 chromosomes gives rise to a tetraploid with 28. Crossing the tetraploid back to the parent produces offspring with 21 chromosomes. Why is the tetraploid a separate species?
Question 3 of 5
A new lake forms and divides a rodent population in two. Over time the groups differ so much that they no longer interbreed. Which process and route describe this?
Question 4 of 5
A horse and a donkey can mate and produce a mule, but mules cannot reproduce. Which barrier does this show?
Question 5 of 5
Hawaiian honeycreeper birds descended from one finch-like ancestor now have thick seed-cracking bills, long nectar-sipping bills, and slender insect-spearing bills. What is this pattern called?
