Intro to Business › Section P · Financial management and securities markets › Topic P.7
Buying and selling securities, and market trends
A share bought on a phone app passes through brokers, exchanges and clearing systems in a fraction of a second. This topic follows how secondary trading works today, the indexes that summarise it, the laws and safeguards that police it, and the trends reshaping it.
Where trading happens now
Older textbooks split the secondary market into broker markets, with a trading floor, and dealer markets linked by telephone and computer. Today that line has mostly faded: nearly all US share trading is electronic. As of 2026 the SEC lists more than 20 registered national securities exchanges, many owned by a few groups such as Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), Nasdaq and Cboe. Alongside them, alternative trading systems match orders privately, including dark pools that do not display orders in advance, and wholesale market makers fill many small orders from retail investors. Over-the-counter (OTC) markets, such as those run by OTC Markets Group, handle smaller companies that are not listed on an exchange.
The NYSE and Nasdaq
The New York Stock Exchange traces its origin to the Buttonwood Agreement signed by brokers in 1792 and has been owned by ICE since 2013. Its floor still operates, with designated market makers responsible for orderly trading in assigned stocks, but most of its volume is executed electronically. Nasdaq began in 1971 as the first electronic quotation system for over-the-counter stocks, linking competing dealers, and became a registered national securities exchange in 2006. The two compete fiercely to win company listings. New entrants keep arriving: the SEC approved the Texas Stock Exchange as a national securities exchange on 30 September 2025.
How an order is filled
Every quoted stock has a bid, the highest price a buyer is offering, and an ask, the lowest price a seller will accept; the gap is the bid-ask spread. An investor places an order through a broker. A market order trades at once at the best available price, so the buyer pays the ask. A limit order sets a price limit, such as buy at no more than 42 dollars, and fills only if that price is available, so it may not fill at all. The broker routes the order to an exchange or other venue. Since 28 May 2024 most US securities trades settle one business day after the trade, called T+1, when cash and shares actually change hands.
Worked example: the cost of a spread
A stock is quoted at a bid of 41.95 dollars and an ask of 42.05 dollars. An investor places a market order to buy 200 shares and, a minute later, decides to sell them with a market order. 1. Buying at the ask: \(200 \times 42.05 = 8{,}410\) dollars. 2. Selling at the bid: \(200 \times 41.95 = 8{,}390\) dollars. 3. Loss from the round trip, even though the quote did not move: 20 dollars. 4. Spread as a percentage of the midpoint: \(0.10 \div 42.00 = 0.238\%\). 5. Interpretation: actively traded stocks have narrow spreads; thinly traded stocks have wider ones, so frequent trading costs money even when commissions are zero.
Market indexes
An index summarises the prices of a group of stocks. The Dow Jones Industrial Average follows 30 large US companies and is price-weighted: it adds share prices and divides by a divisor, so high-priced shares count most. The S&P 500 covers about 500 large US companies and is weighted by market value, using shares available to the public, so the biggest companies count most. The Nasdaq Composite includes nearly all common shares listed on Nasdaq. Indexes are used to describe how markets are moving and as benchmarks that funds try to match or beat.
Worked example: weighting changes the answer
A three-stock index holds A at 200 dollars with 10 million shares, B at 50 dollars with 100 million, and C at 20 dollars with 400 million. 1. Price-weighted level: \((200 + 50 + 20) \div 3 = 90\). 2. Market values: A 2 billion, B 5 billion, C 8 billion dollars, 15 billion in total. 3. If A rises 10% to 220 dollars, the price-weighted level becomes \(290 \div 3 = 96.67\), up 7.41%. 4. The value-weighted index rises by \(0.2 \div 15 = 1.33\%\), since A's value grows by 0.2 billion. 5. If instead C rises 10%, the price-weighted index gains only 0.74%, but the value-weighted index gains 5.33%. Conclusion: the same day can look very different depending on how an index is built.
Securities laws
Federal law sets the rules. The Securities Act of 1933 requires most public offerings to be registered with full disclosure. The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 created the SEC, gave it oversight of exchanges, brokers and dealers, required regular reports from larger public companies, and its anti-fraud rules are the basis for prohibiting insider trading, trading on material information not available to the public. The Investment Company Act and the Investment Advisers Act, both of 1940, regulate funds such as mutual funds and advisers. Later came tougher insider-trading penalties in 1988, Regulation FD in 2000, requiring companies to share material information with all investors at once, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 and the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010.
Self-regulation and safeguards
Exchanges and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) are self-regulatory organisations: under SEC oversight they write and enforce rules for their members, and FINRA supervises broker-dealers and runs qualification exams. The Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) protects customers if a member brokerage fails, up to 500,000 dollars per customer, including 250,000 for cash; it does not cover market losses. After the crash of 19 October 1987, when the Dow fell about 22.6% in a day, markets adopted circuit breakers. Today a fall in the S&P 500 of 7% or 13% before 3:25 p.m. halts all trading for 15 minutes, and a 20% fall halts it for the rest of the day.
Trends in finance and markets
The CFO's role has widened: since Sarbanes-Oxley, chief executives and CFOs personally certify their firms' financial reports, and CFOs act as strategic partners to business units and boards. Exchanges have consolidated into global groups. In October 2019 several large US brokerages cut online stock commissions to zero, and app-based trading has drawn in many new retail investors. The SEC's whistleblower programme, created under Dodd-Frank, pays awards of 10% to 30% of sanctions over 1 million dollars collected from enforcement actions. Settlement has sped up to T+1, and exchanges keep pressing for longer trading hours and new venues.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, picturing trading as mostly shouting on a floor; nearly all of it is electronic. Second, assuming a market order guarantees a price; it guarantees a quick trade, while a limit order guarantees the price but not the trade. Third, ignoring the spread because commissions are zero. Fourth, thinking SIPC protects against falling share prices; it covers a failed broker's missing assets only. Fifth, reading every index the same way: a price-weighted index such as the Dow reacts most to high-priced shares, not the largest companies.
Key takeaways
US secondary trading is electronic and spread across more than 20 exchanges plus alternative trading systems, wholesalers and OTC markets. Buyers pay the ask and sellers receive the bid; market orders trade at once, limit orders only at the set price, and trades settle T+1. The Dow is price-weighted; the S&P 500 is value-weighted. The 1933 and 1934 Acts, the 1940 Acts, Regulation FD, Sarbanes-Oxley and Dodd-Frank form the legal framework; FINRA, SIPC and circuit breakers add safeguards.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Electronic, across exchanges, alternative trading systems and OTC markets
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A stock is quoted at a bid of 25.10 dollars and an ask of 25.20 dollars. What does an investor pay for 100 shares with a market order to buy?
Question 2 of 5
What does a limit order to buy at no more than 30 dollars guarantee?
Question 3 of 5
In a price-weighted index of three stocks priced at 300, 60 and 30 dollars, which stock's 10% rise moves the index most?
Question 4 of 5
Which law created the Securities and Exchange Commission?
Question 5 of 5
A customer's brokerage firm fails and some of the customer's shares are missing. What does SIPC do?
