Intro to Business › Section H · Human resources and labor relations › Topic H.8
Managing grievances and conflicts
Even the best-run workplaces have disagreements. What matters is whether there are fair, predictable ways to settle them before they turn into lost trust, lawsuits or strikes.
Two kinds of dispute
Conflict between employers and employees comes in two broad kinds. A rights dispute is about what an existing agreement or policy means: was this worker entitled to that overtime shift, or was that warning justified under the contract? An interest dispute is about what a new agreement should say: how big the next raise should be, or how much employees should pay towards health insurance. Rights disputes are usually settled through a grievance procedure that ends, if necessary, in arbitration. Interest disputes arise when a contract expires and a new one has not been agreed, and they can lead to strikes, lockouts and other forms of economic pressure.
The grievance procedure
In a unionised workplace, a grievance is a formal claim, brought by a worker or by the union itself, that management has failed to follow the labour agreement. Most contracts set out a step-by-step procedure with time limits for each step. 1. The employee, often with the shop steward, raises the complaint with the immediate supervisor, sometimes informally. 2. If that fails, the grievance is written down and discussed by union officials and a higher manager, such as the department or plant manager. 3. If it is still unresolved, senior representatives of both sides, such as the local union president and the company's labour relations director, meet. 4. A grievance that survives every step can go to arbitration.
Arbitration
In arbitration, a neutral outsider, one person or a small panel, decides the dispute. The two sides usually pick the arbitrator together, often from lists supplied by bodies such as the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service, and commonly share the fee. At a hearing that resembles a simplified trial, each side presents evidence and witnesses and argues how the contract applies. The arbitrator then issues a written decision called an award, which is final and binding on both sides. Because almost every US labour contract ends its grievance procedure in arbitration, disputes over the contract's meaning rarely lead to strikes while it is in force.
Worked example: a grievance step by step
A food-processing plant's contract says weekend overtime is offered in order of seniority. A supervisor gives a Saturday shift to a newer employee, call him Dev, instead of Rosa, who has eight more years of service. 1. Rosa and her steward raise it with the supervisor, who says Dev was the only person trained on the packing line. 2. The written grievance goes to the plant manager, who points out that the contract says nothing about training. 3. Senior representatives cannot agree, so the union takes it to arbitration. 4. The arbitrator reads the overtime clause, finds no training exception, and awards Rosa the pay she would have earned. 5. Check: the award turns on the contract's wording, not on which side argued more forcefully; management can propose a training exception at the next negotiation.
Mediation and other help
Mediation is different from arbitration. A mediator is a neutral person who helps the two sides communicate, clarifies the real issues and suggests possible compromises, but has no power to impose a settlement; any agreement belongs to the parties. In the US, the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service, created by the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947, offers mediators for contract negotiations in many industries. Mediation suits interest disputes, where both sides want to keep control of the final terms. A memory aid: a mediator helps you decide, while an arbitrator decides for you.
Pressure tactics used by unions
When a contract has expired and bargaining stalls, a union may apply economic pressure. A strike is a collective refusal to work, and a union may target a plant that supplies parts to other sites so the effect spreads. Picketing means workers gathering or marching near the workplace with signs to publicise their side and discourage customers or deliveries. A boycott urges customers and the public not to buy from the employer; US law largely restricts secondary boycotts aimed at other firms that deal with the employer. A corporate campaign seeks to raise the dispute with shareholders, lenders, customers or the media. Strikes impose costs on workers too, because striking employees receive no wages.
Pressure tactics used by employers
Employers have tools of their own. In a lockout the employer refuses to let employees work until a contract is agreed, which lets it choose the timing of a stoppage. US law generally allows employers to hire replacement workers, even permanent ones, during a strike over economic issues such as pay. Firms in some industries have arranged mutual-aid pacts, under which other companies help cover part of the income lost to a strike. An employer may also shift production to other plants, at home or abroad. Each tactic has costs, from lost output and customers to damaged relations with the workforce.
Worked example: what a strike costs both sides
At a factory, call it Ashford Components, 800 workers earning 28 dollars an hour for 40 hours a week strike for 4 weeks. The two sides were 1 percentage point apart on the annual raise. 1. Wages lost by workers: \(800 \times 28 \times 40 \times 4 = 3584000\) dollars. 2. The union pays strike benefits of 300 dollars a week per worker: \(800 \times 300 \times 4 = 960000\) dollars, so workers' net loss is about 2,624,000 dollars. 3. The company estimates lost profit on missed orders of 1.2 million dollars a week, or 4.8 million dollars in total. 4. The disputed point is worth \(0.01 \times 800 \times 28 \times 2080 = 465920\) dollars a year. 5. Check: both sides lose far more in a month than the yearly gap, one reason most negotiations settle without a stoppage.
Conflict in non-union workplaces
About nine in ten US workers have no union, so employers use other systems. Open-door policies let employees take problems to higher managers; HR investigations handle complaints such as harassment; some firms use peer review panels of employees and managers, or an ombudsperson who helps staff confidentially. Many employers ask new hires to agree to arbitrate employment disputes instead of going to court. Supporters say this is faster and cheaper; critics say employees have little real choice and lose the public record of a lawsuit. A 2022 federal law lets employees choose to take sexual harassment and sexual assault claims to court despite such agreements. Real disputes need a qualified professional.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up mediation and arbitration: a mediator suggests, an arbitrator decides, and the award is binding. Second, calling every complaint a grievance; in a unionised workplace a grievance claims that the contract has been broken. Third, thinking strikes are the normal way to settle grievances, when grievances during a contract usually end in arbitration and strikes arise mainly when contracts expire. Fourth, confusing a lockout, started by the employer, with a strike, started by employees. Fifth, counting only one side's costs when judging whether a stoppage is worth it.
Key takeaways
Rights disputes concern what an agreement means; interest disputes concern what a new agreement should say. A grievance is a formal complaint that the contract has been broken, handled in timed steps from the supervisor up to arbitration, where a neutral arbitrator's award is final and binding. Mediators help the sides agree but cannot impose terms. Union pressure tactics include strikes, picketing, boycotts and corporate campaigns; employer tactics include lockouts, replacement workers, mutual-aid pacts and shifting production. Stoppages are costly for both sides. Non-union firms use open doors, investigations, peer review, ombudspersons and arbitration agreements.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A disagreement over what an existing agreement means
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A union says management broke the contract by giving a promotion to a junior worker when the contract requires seniority to decide. What is the union filing?
Question 2 of 5
What is the main difference between mediation and arbitration?
Question 3 of 5
500 workers earning 25 dollars an hour for a 40-hour week strike for 3 weeks with no strike pay. How much in wages do they lose in total?
Question 4 of 5
During stalled negotiations, a company closes its gates and tells unionised employees they cannot return to work until they accept a new contract. What tactic is this?
Question 5 of 5
Striking workers march outside a supermarket's entrance with signs explaining their side and asking shoppers to stay away. What is this called?
