Intro to Business › Section J · Operations management › Topic J.7

Trends in operations management

For decades the goal of operations was simple: lowest cost, leanest stock, longest supply lines if they were cheaper. A run of shocks, new technology and pressure to cut emissions have widened that goal. Operations managers now weigh cost against resilience, speed, skills and sustainability.

The forces reshaping operations

Five trends stand out. First, supply chains have proved fragile, so firms are paying for resilience as well as efficiency. Second, production is moving closer to customers in some industries, through reshoring and nearshoring. Third, connected machines and artificial intelligence are turning factories and warehouses into data systems. Fourth, many manufacturers struggle to find workers with the technical skills that automated plants need. Fifth, customers, investors and regulators expect firms to measure and cut their environmental impact. These trends interact: automation can make reshoring affordable, and shorter supply lines can cut both risk and emissions. Each card below takes one in turn, with tools for weighing the trade-offs.

From just-in-time to just-in-case

Lean, just-in-time supply, covered in the topic Quality and continuous improvement, works brilliantly when deliveries are reliable. Recent years showed what happens when they are not. The COVID-19 pandemic closed factories and ports from 2020, a shortage of semiconductors from 2020 to 2022 halted car production around the world, and in March 2021 the container ship Ever Given blocked the Suez Canal for six days. Many firms responded by holding more safety stock of critical parts, qualifying second suppliers in different regions, and mapping their suppliers' own suppliers to find hidden single points of failure. The shift is sometimes summed up as moving from just-in-time to just-in-case.

Worked example: is a buffer worth it?

A medical-device maker relies on one overseas supplier for a sensor. It estimates a 10% chance each year of a disruption that would halt production and cost 300,000 dollars in lost contribution. Holding 2,000 extra sensors as a buffer would prevent that loss, at a holding cost of 5 dollars per sensor per year. 1. Expected annual loss without the buffer: \(0.10 \times 300{,}000 = 30{,}000\) dollars. 2. Annual cost of the buffer: \(2{,}000 \times 5 = 10{,}000\) dollars. 3. The buffer costs less than the expected loss it prevents, so on this estimate it is worth holding. 4. Sensitivity: if the chance of disruption were only 3%, the expected loss would be 9,000 dollars and the buffer would not pay. 5. Check: the answer hinges on the probability estimate.

Reshoring and nearshoring

Offshoring moved production to lower-wage countries far from customers. Reshoring brings it back to the home country, and nearshoring moves it to a nearby country, such as a US firm producing in Mexico or a German firm in Poland. Friend-shoring favours countries seen as politically reliable. The case rests on total landed cost: the full cost of getting a unit to where it is needed, not just the factory price. That includes freight, tariffs and duties, insurance, the cost of carrying inventory during long shipping times, and the risk of delays. A higher factory price nearby can still be cheaper overall, and it also brings faster response to changes in demand.

Worked example: comparing landed cost

A retailer buys 50,000 lamps a year. An offshore supplier quotes 20.00 dollars a lamp, with freight of 2.50 dollars, an assumed tariff of 10% of the price, and 1.20 dollars of inventory-carrying cost for the long transit. A nearshore supplier quotes 22.50 dollars, with freight of 0.80 dollars, no tariff and carrying cost of 0.30 dollars. 1. Offshore: \(20.00 + 2.50 + 2.00 + 1.20 = 25.70\) dollars. 2. Nearshore: \(22.50 + 0.80 + 0 + 0.30 = 23.60\) dollars. 3. Saving per lamp nearshore: 2.10 dollars. 4. Annual saving: \(2.10 \times 50{,}000 = 105{,}000\) dollars. 5. Check: on factory price alone the offshore supplier looked 2.50 dollars cheaper, the opposite conclusion.

Industry 4.0 and data-driven operations

The term Industry 4.0, popularised by a German government initiative presented at the Hannover trade fair in 2011, describes factories in which machines, products and systems exchange data constantly. Sensors, cloud computing and artificial intelligence, covered in the topic Technology on the factory floor, let managers see output, quality and equipment health in real time and adjust schedules automatically. Business process management (BPM) applies the same thinking beyond the factory: firms map, automate and monitor processes such as order handling that cross departments and partner firms. AI is increasingly used for demand forecasting, inventory planning and routing deliveries. The benefits depend on clean data and on cybersecurity, since connected plants can be attacked.

Skills and the workforce

Automated plants need fewer people for manual handling but more people who can program robots, maintain sensors, analyse data and solve problems on the line. Many manufacturers report difficulty finding such workers, especially as experienced staff retire. Firms respond by training their existing workforce, offering apprenticeships, and partnering with community colleges, technical schools and local economic development agencies. Automation does not simply remove jobs; it changes their content, often raising the skill and pay required. Section H's topic Training and development describes how firms build these skills, and the topic Trends in employee motivation shows why training also helps retain people.

Sustainable operations

Operations decisions drive most of a firm's environmental footprint. The Greenhouse Gas Protocol, widely used for corporate reporting, sorts emissions into three scopes: Scope 1, direct emissions from sources the firm owns, such as its boilers and vehicles; Scope 2, emissions from the electricity and heat it buys; and Scope 3, all other emissions in its value chain, from suppliers' factories to customers using and disposing of products. For many manufacturers and retailers, Scope 3 is the largest. Firms cut their footprint through energy efficiency, renewable power, lower-carbon transport and circular design: making products that can be repaired, remanufactured or recycled. ISO 14001 certifies the management system behind such efforts.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, comparing suppliers on factory price instead of total landed cost. Second, assuming lean and resilience are opposites; firms keep lean methods but add targeted buffers for critical parts. Third, judging a buffer without an estimate of how likely and how costly a disruption is. Fourth, confusing reshoring, moving back home, with nearshoring, moving to a nearby country. Fifth, assigning purchased electricity to Scope 1 instead of Scope 2, or forgetting that suppliers' emissions are Scope 3. Sixth, assuming automation needs fewer skills; it usually needs different and higher ones.

Key takeaways

Shocks from 2020 to 2022, including the pandemic, the chip shortage and the Suez blockage in 2021, pushed firms from just-in-time towards just-in-case, with buffers judged by expected loss. Reshoring and nearshoring rest on total landed cost, not factory price. Industry 4.0 (2011) and BPM use connected data and AI to run operations. Automation shifts demand towards technical skills, so firms invest in training. Sustainable operations track Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions and use circular design.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Just-in-case

Holding targeted buffers and backup suppliers for resilience

A response to 2020-2022 disruptions.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An offshore part costs 10.00 dollars, plus 1.50 freight, a 20% tariff on the price and 0.50 carrying cost. A nearshore part costs 12.00, plus 0.60 freight, no tariff and 0.20 carrying cost. Which is cheaper per unit on total landed cost?

Question 2 of 5

A firm faces a 5% annual chance of a disruption costing 400,000 dollars. A buffer of 3,000 parts at 4 dollars each per year would prevent it. On expected value, should it hold the buffer?

Question 3 of 5

A US toy company moves production from Asia to a plant just across the border in Mexico. Which term fits best?

Question 4 of 5

A retailer's emissions from the electricity that powers its stores fall into which scope?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about automation and the workforce reflects the reading?

← Previous topicNext topic →