Intro to Business › Section D · Forms of business ownership › Topic D.4
Specialized forms: LLCs, cooperatives, and more
Between the sole proprietorship and the classic corporation sits a family of hybrid and special-purpose forms. The limited liability company has become the default choice for many new firms, while cooperatives, joint ventures and benefit corporations serve owners whose goals are not simply profit for investors.
Beyond the three classic forms
The previous topics showed a trade-off: sole proprietorships and partnerships are simple and taxed once but expose owners to unlimited liability, while corporations limit liability but cost more and, as C corporations, may be taxed twice. Lawmakers and business people have designed other forms to get different mixes of these features. This topic covers four: the limited liability company, the cooperative, the joint venture and the benefit corporation. Franchising, another special arrangement, has the next topic to itself. As before, these cards describe general US practice; choosing a form for a real business needs advice from a qualified professional.
The limited liability company
A limited liability company (LLC) is a state-registered entity whose owners, called members, have limited liability like shareholders but enjoy flexible management and taxation like partners. Members file articles of organization with the state and usually sign an operating agreement setting out ownership shares, profit splits, voting and exit rules. An LLC can be member-managed, run by its owners, or manager-managed, run by appointed managers. Wyoming created the first LLC statute in 1977, and the form spread after a 1988 IRS ruling allowed LLCs to be taxed as partnerships. Every state now permits them, and they need fewer formalities, such as annual shareholder meetings, than corporations.
How LLCs are taxed
Federal tax treatment follows default rules that the owners can change by election. A single-member LLC is by default disregarded for income tax: its profit appears on the owner's personal return much like a sole proprietorship's. A multi-member LLC is by default taxed as a partnership, with each member receiving a Schedule K-1. Either kind may instead elect to be taxed as a corporation, and an eligible LLC may then elect S corporation status. This flexibility, together with limited liability, explains the form's popularity. Like a corporation's shield, though, an LLC's protection can be lost if members mix personal and business money or commit fraud.
Worked example: choosing a form
Priya and Marco plan a small design studio. They want protection for their homes if a client sues, profits split 60:40 even though they invested equally, no shares sold to outsiders, and as little paperwork as possible. 1. Liability protection rules out a general partnership and a sole proprietorship. 2. An S corporation allows only one class of stock, so distributions must follow shareholdings; a 60:40 profit split would mean holding shares 60:40, and so 60:40 votes and value, despite equal investments. 3. A C corporation would add a second layer of tax on dividends and more formalities. 4. A multi-member LLC gives limited liability, partnership-style taxation by default and an operating agreement that can set a 60:40 split. 5. Conclusion: on these goals an LLC fits best, a judgement they would confirm with an accountant and attorney.
Cooperatives
A cooperative, or co-op, is a business owned and democratically controlled by the people who use it, its members, rather than by outside investors. Members usually have one vote each, whatever their stake. Surplus is returned to members as patronage refunds in proportion to how much business each did with the co-op, not in proportion to capital. Types include consumer co-ops such as food stores, producer or marketing co-ops through which farmers sell crops, purchasing co-ops through which independent retailers buy together, worker co-ops owned by employees, and credit unions, which are financial co-ops. Ace Hardware, founded in 1924, is owned by its independent retailer members.
Worked example: a patronage refund
A farm-supply cooperative has a surplus of 90,000 dollars to return to members. Members bought 600,000 dollars of supplies through it during the year, and one member, Ellen, bought 12,000 dollars' worth. 1. Find Ellen's share of patronage: 12,000 divided by 600,000 is 0.02, or 2%. 2. Her refund: 2% of 90,000 is 1,800 dollars. 3. Note what does not matter: how many membership shares Ellen owns, or how long she has been a member. 4. Check: if every member is refunded at the same 15 cents per dollar of purchases (90,000 divided by 600,000), Ellen's 12,000 dollars of purchases earn 0.15 times 12,000, or 1,800 dollars.
Cooperative principles
Modern cooperatives trace their roots to the Rochdale Pioneers, a group of workers in northern England who opened a co-operative store in 1844. The International Cooperative Alliance today lists seven principles: voluntary and open membership; democratic member control; member economic participation; autonomy and independence; education, training and information; cooperation among cooperatives; and concern for community. Co-ops let small producers or buyers gain the bargaining power of a large firm. Their limits are the other side of democracy: raising outside capital is harder, and decisions can be slower when every member votes.
Joint ventures
A joint venture is an arrangement in which two or more firms combine resources for a specific project or market, sharing control, costs, profits and risks. It may be a contract or a new jointly owned company, often set up as a corporation or LLC. Firms use joint ventures to share the cost of large projects, combine complementary skills or technology, and enter foreign markets where a local partner knows the customers and rules. For example, Sony and Ericsson combined their mobile-phone businesses in a 50:50 venture in 2001; Sony bought out Ericsson's half in 2012. Ventures often end like this, when the partners' goals drift apart.
Benefit corporations
A benefit corporation is a for-profit corporation whose charter commits it to create a general public benefit, so directors must weigh the interests of workers, communities and the environment alongside shareholders. Maryland passed the first benefit corporation law in 2010, and many states have followed. It is a legal form, chosen at incorporation. A certified B Corporation is different: a certification that the nonprofit B Lab grants to companies meeting its standards of social and environmental performance, whatever their legal form. The ideas behind both are discussed in "Managing a socially responsible business".
Common mistakes to avoid
First, calling an LLC a corporation: it is a separate form whose owners are members, not shareholders. Second, assuming an LLC is always taxed one way; defaults depend on the number of members and can be changed by election. Third, thinking co-op surplus is paid according to shares owned; patronage refunds follow how much each member used the co-op. Fourth, treating a joint venture as a merger; the partner firms stay independent. Fifth, confusing a benefit corporation, a legal form, with B Corp certification.
Key takeaways
An LLC combines limited liability for its members with flexible management and pass-through taxation by default: disregarded for one member, partnership for several, with a corporate election available. Cooperatives are owned and democratically run by their users and return surplus as patronage refunds, guided by seven principles traced to the Rochdale Pioneers of 1844. Joint ventures let independent firms share a specific project. Benefit corporations, first allowed in Maryland in 2010, write a public-benefit purpose into their charter; B Corp is a separate certification.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Limited liability company: limited liability plus flexible tax and management
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A cooperative returns a surplus of 150,000 dollars. A member's purchases were 9,000 dollars out of 450,000 dollars bought by all members. What is that member's patronage refund?
Question 2 of 5
How is a multi-member LLC taxed by default for US federal income tax?
Question 3 of 5
In a typical consumer cooperative, how is voting power usually distributed?
Question 4 of 5
Two independent car makers agree to share the cost of developing one battery plant and split its output. What arrangement is this?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement correctly distinguishes a benefit corporation from a certified B Corporation?
