Intro to Business › Section G · Organizational structure › Topic G.7

Trends in organizational structure

Technology and global competition keep pushing organisations to rethink how they are built. This topic covers the main trends: reengineering processes from scratch, virtual corporations and virtual teams, outsourcing and the gig economy, and structuring firms after global mergers.

Structures under pressure

The structures in this section were mostly designed for organisations whose people shared buildings and did most of their own work. Three forces have loosened those assumptions. Digital technology lets people and firms coordinate across any distance. Global competition rewards firms that are fast and lean. And specialised partners can now do many tasks, from payroll to manufacturing, more cheaply or better than a firm can itself. The trends below are the main responses, and each has costs as well as benefits.

Reengineering

Reengineering is the fundamental redesign of business processes and structures to achieve dramatic improvements in cost, quality, service and speed. Michael Hammer popularised the idea in a 1990 Harvard Business Review article, and with James Champy in the 1993 book Reengineering the Corporation. Its spirit is "starting over": top managers ask how they would run the business if they were founding it today, then discard rules and assumptions that no longer hold, rather than automating old procedures. It focuses on whole processes, such as fulfilling an order, instead of departments. Many 1990s projects were criticised as cover for job cuts that ignored the human side of change.

Worked example: reengineering an approval

A firm's purchase approvals pass through five people in four departments. A typical request takes 6 working days from start to finish, yet the actual work on it adds up to only 3 hours. 1. Elapsed time in working hours, at 8 hours a day: \(6 \times 8 = 48\) hours. 2. Share spent on real work: \(3 \div 48 = 6.25\%\); the rest is waiting between desks. 3. Redesign: one trained case worker handles each request from start to finish, using approval limits set in software, and only large purchases go to a manager. 4. New elapsed time: 1 day. 5. Reduction: \((6 - 1) \div 6 \approx 83\%\). The gain comes from removing hand-offs, not from working faster.

The virtual corporation

A virtual corporation is a web of separate firms, such as suppliers, customers and sometimes even competitors, that use technology to pool their skills, split costs and reach markets together. Partners come together quickly to exploit an opportunity and may separate when it passes. Key features are often listed as technology, which lets distant firms work as one; opportunism, since alliances are less permanent and formal than traditional partnerships; excellence, as each partner contributes only its core competencies, its key strengths; trust, because each partner depends on the others; and no borders, since the organisation's boundaries become blurred. In its purest form, a virtual corporation has no central office, no organisation chart and no hierarchy.

Virtual corporations in practice

Few firms are purely virtual, but many use parts of the model. A common example is contract manufacturing. A brand-name electronics company may design products and manage marketing itself while independent manufacturers, often in other countries, own and run the factories that build them. The benefits are speed, flexibility and lower fixed costs, since the brand need not own factories. The risks are dependence on partners, weaker control over quality and working conditions, exposure to disruptions anywhere in the network, and the danger that a partner learns enough to become a competitor.

Virtual teams

Technology also enables virtual teams, whose members work in different places, often different countries and time zones, and collaborate mainly online. Geography no longer limits who can be on a team, so managers can pick the best mix of skills wherever people live, while saving on travel and relocation. The spread of remote and hybrid work since 2020, described with dated figures in the topic Trends in management and leadership, has made virtual teamwork routine in many office jobs. The challenges are keeping members focused, motivated and communicating well without daily contact. Clear goals, agreed communication routines and, where practical, an early face-to-face meeting help.

Outsourcing

Outsourcing means contracting an outside firm to perform work that the organisation could do itself. Payroll has long been outsourced; today firms also outsource customer service, IT, cybersecurity, manufacturing, logistics, marketing and parts of finance or research. The two classic reasons are to cut costs and to let the firm concentrate on its core strengths. Done well, it works as a strategic partnership: managers identify the specific problem, consider all solutions, decide whether outsourcing really is the best answer, agree a clear framework with the vendor, keep in regular contact to build trust and stay flexible. Poorly managed outsourcing can damage quality and reputation.

Worked example: outsource payroll?

A firm with 150 employees pays one payroll specialist 68,000 dollars a year in salary and benefits, plus 9,000 dollars a year for software. A vendor offers to run payroll for 35 dollars per employee per month. 1. In-house cost: \(68{,}000 + 9{,}000 = 77{,}000\) dollars. 2. Vendor cost: \(35 \times 150 \times 12 = 63{,}000\) dollars. 3. Saving: \(77{,}000 - 63{,}000 = 14{,}000\) dollars, about 18.2% of the in-house cost. 4. Non-cost questions: how will employee data be protected, what happens if the vendor makes errors, and what becomes of the specialist? 5. The figures favour outsourcing, but the decision also depends on these risks.

The gig economy

A related trend is the use of independent workers, freelancers and contractors hired for specific projects or tasks, often through online platforms. This is often called the gig economy. For firms, it adds flexibility and avoids some fixed costs; for workers, it can offer independence and extra income, but usually without the benefits and security of employment. Definitions vary, but one official benchmark: the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in November 2024 that in July 2023 independent contractors made up 7.4% of total US employment on their sole or main job. Whether a worker is legally an employee or a contractor depends on detailed rules, so firms need qualified legal advice.

Structuring after global mergers

When large firms merge, especially across borders, managers face hard structural questions. Should decisions be centralised or decentralised? Should the new firm be organised around products or regions? Whose systems, titles and reporting lines survive? Combining cultures is often harder than combining charts, since staff of the acquired firm may feel conquered. Successful integration plans usually address cultural differences openly, set up a clear leadership structure quickly, create strong two-way communication at every level and redefine the combined firm's vision, mission and values, drawing on the change models in the topic The informal organization and culture.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing reengineering with automation: reengineering redesigns the process, while automating a bad process just makes the waste faster. Second, thinking a virtual corporation is simply a firm whose staff work from home; it is a network of independent companies. Third, comparing only the headline costs of outsourcing and ignoring control, quality and data risks. Fourth, quoting gig-economy or remote-work figures without a date and source. Fifth, assuming a merger is complete once the new organisation chart is drawn; culture and informal networks take far longer to combine.

Key takeaways

Reengineering, popularised by Hammer and Champy in the early 1990s, redesigns whole processes from scratch for dramatic gains, often by removing hand-offs. A virtual corporation is a technology-linked network of independent firms, each contributing core competencies; contract manufacturing is a common partial form. Virtual teams work across locations and need clear goals and communication routines. Outsourcing contracts out work to cut costs or focus on core strengths and should be managed as a partnership. In July 2023, independent contractors were 7.4% of US employment (BLS). Global mergers must combine structures and, harder still, cultures.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Reengineering

Fundamental redesign of processes for dramatic gains

"Starting over".

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A loan application takes 10 working days (8 hours each) to approve, but only 4 hours of actual work are done on it. What share of the elapsed time is real work?

Question 2 of 5

A firm pays 50,000 dollars a year to run payroll in-house for 120 employees. A vendor charges 30 dollars per employee per month. What is the annual saving from outsourcing?

Question 3 of 5

Which best describes a virtual corporation?

Question 4 of 5

What is the central idea of reengineering?

Question 5 of 5

According to the BLS, what share of total US employment did independent contractors make up in July 2023?

← Previous topicNext topic →