Intro to Business › Section C · Competing in the global marketplace › Topic C.2
Why nations trade
Countries trade for the same reason people do: nobody is best placed to make everything. The idea of comparative advantage explains why trade can make both sides better off, and the debate over globalisation explains why not everyone feels the gain.
Could a country go it alone?
Imagine the United States banned all trade tomorrow. Coffee would almost vanish, because the mainland climate is wrong for growing it on any scale. Many metals used in batteries and electronics would become scarce. Goods that could still be made at home, such as clothing and toys, would cost far more. The same logic applies to you: an accountant could repair her own car, but she does better to spend the hour on accounts and pay a mechanic. Specialising in what you do well and trading for the rest is the basic reason for trade between people, between firms and between nations.
Absolute advantage
A country has an absolute advantage in a good when it can produce more of it from the same resources than another country can, or the same amount with fewer resources. Some absolute advantages come from nature: Chile's huge copper deposits, Brazil's climate for coffee, Saudi Arabia's oil. Others are built: skilled workers, modern machinery and technology. When each country has an absolute advantage in a different good, the case for trade is obvious. If one country makes coffee cheaply and the other makes jet engines, both gain by swapping. The harder question is what happens when one country is better at everything.
Comparative advantage
A country has a comparative advantage in a good when it can produce it at a lower opportunity cost than another country, that is, by giving up less of other goods. The economist David Ricardo set out the idea in 1817. It means that a country can be better at everything in absolute terms yet still gain by specialising, because it cannot have the lower opportunity cost in everything. Each country gains most by concentrating on the goods it gives up least to make and trading for the rest. These definitions match the macroeconomics course, where "Absolute and comparative advantage" develops the method in more detail.
Worked example: finding the advantages
In one day a worker in Larvia can make 10 tonnes of wheat or 5 machines; a worker in Montaro can make 6 tonnes of wheat or 1 machine. 1. Absolute advantage: Larvia makes more of both goods per worker, so it has the absolute advantage in both. 2. Opportunity cost of a machine: Larvia gives up \(10 \div 5 = 2\) tonnes of wheat; Montaro gives up \(6 \div 1 = 6\) tonnes. 3. Opportunity cost of a tonne of wheat: Larvia gives up 0.5 machine; Montaro only \(\frac{1}{6}\) machine. 4. Conclusion: Larvia has the comparative advantage in machines and Montaro in wheat. 5. Check: each country's two costs are reciprocals, \(2 \times 0.5 = 1\) and \(6 \times \frac{1}{6} = 1\).
Worked example: the gains from trade
Each country has 100 workers, split evenly at first. Larvia makes 500 tonnes of wheat and 250 machines; Montaro makes 300 tonnes and 50 machines. World output: 800 tonnes and 300 machines. 1. Larvia moves 20 workers into machines: 300 tonnes and 350 machines. 2. Montaro moves all 50 machine workers into wheat: 600 tonnes and no machines. 3. World output is now 900 tonnes and 350 machines, more of both. 4. They trade at 4 tonnes per machine, their terms of trade, a price between the two costs of 2 and 6: Larvia sends 60 machines for 240 tonnes. 5. Larvia ends with 540 tonnes and 290 machines; Montaro with 360 tonnes and 60 machines. Both have more of both goods than before.
Where advantage comes from, and why it moves
Comparative advantage rests on natural resources, the skills of the workforce, the stock of machinery, technology and the know-how that builds up in industrial clusters, such as Taiwan's chipmakers or northern Italy's machine-tool firms. Countries with plenty of labour relative to capital tend to export labour-intensive goods, while capital-rich countries export capital-intensive ones. None of this is fixed. South Korea moved from exporting wigs and textiles in the 1960s to exporting ships, cars and chips, as it invested in education and capital. For a business, this means that the best place to make or buy something can change within a manager's career.
Free trade and protectionism
Free trade is the policy of letting people and businesses buy and sell across borders without government restrictions. Comparative advantage is the main argument for it: specialisation raises total output, so trade makes more goods available at lower prices. The opposite policy is protectionism, which shields home industries from foreign competition with barriers such as tariffs and quotas. In practice every country sits somewhere between the two. The next topic, "Barriers to trade", describes the tools, and the macroeconomics topic "Protectionism as a hidden subsidy" measures their costs.
Why globalisation worries people
The gains from trade are spread across millions of buyers, but the losses fall on particular workers and towns. One well-known study, by Daron Acemoglu, David Autor and colleagues in 2016, estimated that rising imports from China cost the United States about 2 to 2.4 million jobs between 1999 and 2011, concentrated in manufacturing regions. Two terms are often confused. Outsourcing means paying another firm to do work you once did yourself, at home or abroad. Offshoring means moving work to another country, whether to an outside firm or to your own foreign plant. Call centres and software testing are common examples of both, and service jobs are now affected as well as factory work.
Why globalisation also helps
Trade lowers prices and widens choice, which matters most to households on low incomes, who spend a large share of their budget on traded goods such as food and clothing. Exporting firms tend to be more productive and pay higher wages than similar firms that only sell at home. Competition from abroad pushes firms to innovate, and ideas, technology and investment travel with trade, helping lower-income countries develop. Many economists therefore argue that the right response to the losses is not to block trade but to help displaced workers, through retraining, job search help and income support, so the gains are shared more widely.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing absolute with comparative advantage: being faster at a good does not by itself mean you should make it. Second, concluding that a country that is better at everything gains nothing from trade. Third, dividing the wrong way: with output per worker, the opportunity cost of X is the output of Y divided by the output of X. Fourth, choosing a trade price outside the range set by the two opportunity costs, where one side would lose. Fifth, using outsourcing and offshoring as if they meant the same thing. Sixth, assuming that because a country gains overall, every worker in it gains.
Key takeaways
Nations trade because specialisation lets everyone consume more. Absolute advantage means producing more from the same resources; comparative advantage means producing at a lower opportunity cost, and every country has a comparative advantage in something. Specialising by comparative advantage raises total output, and trade at a price between the two opportunity costs lets both sides gain. Advantage comes from resources, skills, capital and know-how, and it shifts over time. Free trade spreads gains widely, while losses fall on particular workers, which is why globalisation stays contested.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Concentrating on what you do best and trading for the rest
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In a day a worker in Pera makes 12 metres of cloth or 4 phones, and a worker in Quon makes 6 metres of cloth or 3 phones. Which statement is correct?
Question 2 of 5
Using the same Pera and Quon figures, at which price would both countries gain from trading phones for cloth?
Question 3 of 5
What does it mean for a country to have a comparative advantage in a good?
Question 4 of 5
A US bank closes its call centre in Ohio and opens its own call centre in the Philippines. How is this best described?
Question 5 of 5
Why does trade remain politically contested even when it raises a country's total output?
