Differential Equations › Section C · Second order differential equations › Topic C.5

Reduction of order

Equations with variable coefficients rarely have a neat characteristic equation, but if you already know one solution, a second one can always be built from it. The method turns a second order problem into a first order one, which the earlier techniques can solve.

When one solution is known

The characteristic equation works only for constant coefficients. For an equation such as \(t^2y'' - 3ty' + 4y = 0\) there is no such shortcut, but sometimes one solution can be found by inspection or by trying a power of \(t\). Here \(y_1 = t^2\) works: \(t^2(2) - 3t(2t) + 4t^2 = 0\). The general solution still needs a second solution that is not a constant multiple of the first. Reduction of order finds it, and the topic "Repeated roots" has already used the idea once, when \(y = v(t)e^{rt}\) produced \(te^{rt}\).

The idea

Given a solution \(y_1\) of \(a_2(t)y'' + a_1(t)y' + a_0(t)y = 0\), look for a second one of the form

y_2 = v(t)\,y_1(t)

where \(v\) is an unknown function. A constant \(v\) would only give a multiple of \(y_1\), so we need \(v\) to vary. Differentiate with the product rule, \(y_2' = v'y_1 + vy_1'\) and \(y_2'' = v''y_1 + 2v'y_1' + vy_1''\), and substitute. Every term containing \(v\) itself, undifferentiated, collects into \(v\) times the left side of the equation applied to \(y_1\). That is zero, because \(y_1\) is a solution. What remains involves only \(v''\) and \(v'\).

Why the order drops

Since only \(v''\) and \(v'\) survive, set \(w = v'\). The equation becomes first order in \(w\):

a_2y_1\,w' + (2a_2y_1' + a_1y_1)\,w = 0

This is both separable and linear, so the methods of the topics "Separable equations" and "Linear equations and integrating factors" solve it. Integrating \(w\) then gives \(v\), and \(y_2 = vy_1\). Constants of integration can be dropped at the end, because any nonzero multiple of \(y_2\), or \(y_2\) plus a multiple of \(y_1\), would do just as well. The method needs \(y_1 \ne 0\) on the interval being studied, because \(y_1\) ends up in a denominator.

Worked example: a power solution

Find a second solution of \(t^2y'' - 3ty' + 4y = 0\), \(t > 0\), given \(y_1 = t^2\). 1. Set \(y = vt^2\): \(y' = v't^2 + 2tv\) and \(y'' = v''t^2 + 4tv' + 2v\). 2. Substitute:

t^4v'' + 4t^3v' + 2t^2v - 3t^3v' - 6t^2v + 4t^2v = 0

3. The \(v\) terms cancel, leaving \(t^4v'' + t^3v' = 0\). 4. With \(w = v'\): \(w' = -\frac{w}{t}\), which separates to give \(w = \frac{1}{t}\) (constant 1). 5. Integrate: \(v = \ln t\). 6. So \(y_2 = t^2\ln t\), giving \(y = c_1t^2 + c_2t^2\ln t\). 7. Check: \(y_2' = 2t\ln t + t\) and \(y_2'' = 2\ln t + 3\), so the left side is

t^2(2\ln t + 3) - 3t(2t\ln t + t) + 4t^2\ln t = 0

A ready-made formula

If the equation is first divided by \(a_2(t)\) to put it in standard form \(y'' + p(t)y' + q(t)y = 0\), the first order equation for \(w\) can be solved once and for all:

v' = \frac{e^{-\int p(t)\,dt}}{y_1^2}

For the previous example, \(p = -\frac{3}{t}\), so \(e^{-\int p\,dt} = e^{3\ln t} = t^3\), and \(v' = \frac{t^3}{t^4} = \frac{1}{t}\), as before. The formula saves algebra, but you must divide by the leading coefficient first, and the substitution route is a useful check because it shows the cancellation actually happening.

Worked example: an exponential start

Find a second solution of \(ty'' - (t + 1)y' + y = 0\), \(t > 0\), given \(y_1 = e^t\). 1. Check \(y_1\): \(te^t - (t + 1)e^t + e^t = 0\). 2. Standard form: \(p = -\frac{t + 1}{t} = -1 - \frac{1}{t}\). 3. Then \(-\int p\,dt = t + \ln t\), so \(e^{-\int p\,dt} = te^t\). 4. Formula: \(v' = \frac{te^t}{e^{2t}} = te^{-t}\). 5. Integrate by parts: \(v = -(t + 1)e^{-t}\). 6. So \(y_2 = vy_1 = -(t + 1)\); drop the sign and take \(y_2 = t + 1\). 7. Check: \(y_2'' = 0\) and \(y_2' = 1\), so the left side is \(0 - (t + 1) + (t + 1) = 0\). The general solution is \(y = c_1e^t + c_2(t + 1)\).

Where it fits

Reduction of order is the tool that justified the repeated root case, and the same idea accounts for the \(t^r\ln t\) solutions met later in the topic "Euler (Cauchy-Euler) equations", of which the first worked example here is an instance. It also has limits. You need one solution to begin with, and the integrals for \(w\) and \(v\) may have no elementary form. Finding \(y_1\) is often the hard part: good first guesses for variable coefficient equations are powers \(t^m\), exponentials \(e^{mt}\) and simple polynomials such as \(t + 1\), each checked by substitution.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using the formula without dividing by the leading coefficient, so that the wrong \(p(t)\) goes into the exponential. Second, dropping the minus sign: the formula uses \(e^{-\int p\,dt}\), not \(e^{\int p\,dt}\). Third, forgetting to divide by \(y_1^2\). Fourth, stopping at \(v\) or \(v'\) instead of multiplying by \(y_1\) to get \(y_2\). Fifth, keeping a constant term in \(v\) and then believing the answer is new: \(v = \ln t + 5\) only adds \(5y_1\) to \(y_2\).

Key takeaways

If \(y_1\) solves a linear homogeneous second order equation, try \(y_2 = v(t)y_1\). The \(v\) terms cancel because \(y_1\) is a solution, leaving a first order equation in \(w = v'\). In standard form, \(v' = e^{-\int p\,dt}/y_1^2\). Integrate to get \(v\), then multiply by \(y_1\). Work on an interval where \(y_1 \ne 0\), and always check \(y_2\) by substitution.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Reduction of order

Build a second solution from a known one

Works for variable coefficients.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

y₁ = t solves t²y″ − ty′ + y = 0 for t > 0. What second solution does reduction of order give?

Question 2 of 5

After substituting y = vy₁, why do all terms containing v itself, undifferentiated, disappear?

Question 3 of 5

y₁ = t solves y″ − (2/t)y′ + (2/t²)y = 0 for t > 0. Using v′ = e^(−∫p dt)/y₁², what is v′?

Question 4 of 5

y₁ = e^t solves (t − 1)y″ − ty′ + y = 0 for t > 1. Which function is a second, independent solution?

Question 5 of 5

Why must y₁ be nonzero on the interval where reduction of order is used?

← Previous topicNext topic →