English Composition › Section H · The analytical report › Topic H.3

Editing focus: commas with essential and nonessential information

Two small commas can change which person, policy or product a sentence is about. Knowing when information is essential, and when it is extra, lets you punctuate reports so they say exactly what you mean.

Why this comma matters

Reports pack sentences with identifying details: which department, which study, which year. Some of those details are needed to pick out the thing you mean; others simply add information about something already identified. Commas tell the reader which is which. Compare "The employees who work night shifts will receive the bonus" with "The employees, who work night shifts, will receive the bonus." The first gives the bonus only to night-shift workers. The second gives it to all the employees and adds that they all work nights. Same words, different policy.

Essential and nonessential information

Essential information, also called restrictive, is needed to identify the noun it describes or to keep the sentence's core meaning. Without it, the sentence becomes too general or says something different. It takes no commas. Nonessential information, also called nonrestrictive, adds detail about a noun that readers can already identify. It may be interesting or useful, but removing it leaves the basic meaning intact. It is set off with commas: one before and one after if it falls mid-sentence, or one before if it ends the sentence. The commas work like handles: lift the information out, and the sentence still stands.

The removal test

To decide, read the sentence without the element in question. Ask two things. Does the sentence still point to the same person, thing or group? Is its central claim unchanged? If both answers are yes, the information is nonessential: use commas. If the sentence now points to a wider group or makes a different claim, the information is essential: no commas. In "The survey that we ran in April had a low response rate", removing "that we ran in April" leaves "The survey", which could be any survey, so the clause is essential. The test depends on context: what the reader already knows matters.

That, which and who

Relative clauses, beginning with who, whom, whose, which or that, are the most common source of trouble. In American academic writing, the usual pattern is that for essential clauses, with no commas, and which for nonessential clauses, with commas: "The policy that the board adopted in May..." versus "The new policy, which the board adopted in May,..." A that-clause is never set off with commas. Who works both ways, so only the meaning decides: "Students who live on campus pay a housing fee" (only those students) versus "Our two exchange students, who live on campus, arrived in August" (extra detail).

Proper nouns and unique things

When a noun is already fully identified, by a proper name or because only one exists, anything added about it is usually nonessential. "Lakeview Hospital, which opened in 1958, is expanding" needs commas, because the name has already identified the hospital. "The hospital that opened in 1958 is expanding" does not, because the clause is what identifies it. Likewise, "The mayor, who took office in January, opposes the plan" uses commas when the town has one mayor. A clause after "my mother" is nonessential for the same reason: you have only one.

Appositives and phrases

The same rule governs appositives, nouns that rename the noun beside them. "The economist Rosa Delgado spoke first" needs no commas, because many economists exist and the name identifies which one. "The keynote speaker, Rosa Delgado, spoke first" needs commas if the event had one keynote speaker. Context decides: "My cousin Lena" implies several cousins; "my cousin, Lena," implies only one. Phrases follow the rule too: "Visitors arriving after 9 p.m. must sign in" identifies which visitors, while "The visitors, arriving late and soaked, headed for the fire" adds description.

Worked example: punctuating a report paragraph

"The committee, which met four times in the spring, reviewed every proposal. Proposals that lacked a budget were returned. The strongest entry came from Dana Ruiz, a second-year engineering student. Her design, which costs less than $2,000, uses recycled panels. The judges who visited the site praised its durability." 1. "which met four times": the committee is already identified, so the clause is nonessential and takes two commas. 2. "that lacked a budget": identifies which proposals were returned, so no commas. 3. "a second-year engineering student": a nonessential appositive at the end of a sentence takes one comma before it. 4. "which costs less than $2,000": her design is identified, so commas. 5. "who visited the site": implies that only some judges visited, so no commas.

Worked example: one pair, two meanings

A: "Library users who have overdue books cannot reserve laptops." B: "Library users, who have overdue books, cannot reserve laptops." 1. Apply the removal test to A. "Library users cannot reserve laptops" bans every user, which is not what the writer means, so the clause is essential. 2. Sentence A therefore restricts the rule to users with overdue books: correct for this policy. 3. Sentence B treats the clause as extra, so it claims that all library users have overdue books and that none can reserve laptops. 4. The commas in B are not a style choice; they change the claim. 5. Before adding commas, ask what the sentence must say, then punctuate to match.

Dashes and parentheses

Commas are not the only way to set off nonessential information. A pair of dashes gives it more emphasis: "The new scheme (an experiment) failed" quietly sets it aside, while "The new scheme—an experiment from the start—failed" draws attention to it. Parentheses play the information down; commas are the neutral middle choice. Dashes are also useful when the nonessential element already contains commas, as in a list. Whichever pair you choose, use the same mark at both ends, and never use any of them around essential information.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, opening a nonessential element with a comma and forgetting the closing one: "The study, which ran for two years found..." Second, putting commas around a that-clause. Third, setting off an essential appositive, as in "The novelist, Rosa Delgado, spoke" when many novelists exist. Fourth, adding a comma between a subject and its verb because the subject is long: "Students who complete the survey, receive a voucher." Fifth, punctuating by where you would pause instead of by meaning.

Key takeaways

Essential (restrictive) information identifies the noun or keeps the core meaning, and takes no commas. Nonessential (nonrestrictive) information adds detail about a noun already identified, and is set off with commas, two in mid-sentence and one at the end. Use the removal test: if the sentence still means the same thing without the element, it is nonessential. In American academic writing, that introduces essential clauses and which nonessential ones; who can do either. Proper nouns usually make what follows nonessential. Commas here change meaning, so decide what the sentence must say before you punctuate.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Essential information

Needed to identify the noun or keep the core meaning; no commas

Also called restrictive.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which sentence is punctuated correctly?

Question 2 of 5

Why does "Students who miss three labs must repeat the course" have no commas?

Question 3 of 5

A writer types "My brother, Theo, starts college in September." What do the commas imply?

Question 4 of 5

In which sentence is the information that follows the first noun nonessential?

Question 5 of 5

Which sentence wrongly puts commas around essential information?

← Previous topicNext topic →