English Composition › Section A · Reading and responding critically › Topic A.3
Writing a critical response
A critical response talks back to a text. It shows that you understand what the text says, explains how it works, and judges how well it does its job, with evidence a reader can check.
What a critical response is
Reading and writing are two sides of one skill: the more closely you read other writers, the more you learn about your own writing, and the reverse. A critical response puts both to work. It is a short essay, often one or two pages, that responds to a single text, such as an article, a speech, a post or an image. It briefly restates the text, analyses how it works and evaluates it. It might recommend the text or not, explain why it matters, or comment on its style and likely effect on readers.
Seeing from more than one side
Stand at the front of a building and you see its entrance; stand at the side and you see how deep it is. Neither view is wrong, but neither is complete. Texts are similar. Your first reading is shaped by your experience and culture, and other readers will notice things you missed. That is why many instructors ask you to share your response with classmates and then revise it. Combining perspectives rarely gives a perfect picture, but it gives a fuller one, and it often shows where a text could be misunderstood.
Getting started: map the situation
Prewriting is anything you do to get ideas moving before drafting: a list, an outline, a freewrite (writing nonstop about the text for a set time) or a concept map. A useful map for a critical response puts the text in the centre with six circles around it: the agents (originator and audience), then genre, purpose, stance, context and culture. Filling in each circle forces you to understand the text's rhetorical situation, and gaps or tensions in the map, such as a stance that may not suit the audience, often become points for your analysis.
Four ways to respond
A summary condenses a text to its main ideas, in your own words and without your opinion. A paraphrase restates one passage in your own words to make it clearer, often running roughly as long as the passage it restates. Analysis examines how the text was put together: its subject, tone, message and structure, and why the writer made those choices for this audience at this time. Evaluation judges whether the text achieves its purpose and how significant it is. You need the first two to understand a text and the last two to respond to it critically.
Reading to analyse
Analysis starts with marking the text for specific things: claims you agree or disagree with, convincing examples, consequences of believing the writer, links to other texts, recurring words or images, and the conclusions. Then ask how the parts work together. How does the opening prepare the reader? Why does a key word keep returning? What does the tone suggest about the writer's attitude to the audience? An analysis is never just a list of features. It explains what each choice does, which leads you towards an interpretation and then a judgement.
Evaluating an argument
An argument advances claims, statements that something is true or that an action should be taken, and supports them with reasoning and evidence. When you evaluate it, sort the support into three kinds. Facts can be verified. Inferences are conclusions drawn from evidence, which may be reasonable or overstretched. Opinions are personal beliefs. All three appear in real arguments, but the strongest rest on verifiable facts and well-drawn inferences. Watch for opinions dressed up as facts and for big inferences built on very few facts.
Evaluating other kinds of text
Criteria change with the genre. For an informational text, ask whether the facts are accurate, whether the conclusions follow from them, whether the writer has relevant expertise, whether the tone is objective and what information or perspectives are missing. For a story, poem or play, look for the theme through recurring language, images and ideas, and through how characters change, then judge how well the writer's choices convey it. Whatever the genre, your judgement needs support from the text itself, not just your reaction to it.
Structuring the response
The introduction names the author and the title, summarises the rhetorical situation in a sentence or two, and ends with your main statement of analysis or evaluation. Each body paragraph opens with a topic sentence giving one point of analysis or evaluation, then supports it with evidence from the text, quoted, paraphrased or summarised, and explains how that evidence supports the point. The conclusion pulls your judgements together and leaves readers with something to think about or an action to consider. Give the author's full name at first mention and the surname after that.
Worked example: an introduction
The text is an invented online column. Model introduction: "In 'Phones Down, Grades Up,' a column on the Riverside High news site, senior Dana Whitfield argues that students should lock their phones away for the whole school day. Writing for classmates and teachers weeks before the school board votes on the policy, Whitfield draws on her own experience and a staff survey. Her column is persuasive about the cost of distraction, but it overlooks students who rely on their phones for safety and translation, so its case for limits in class is stronger than its case for a total ban." Analysis: 1. Full name, title and source come first. 2. One sentence sketches audience, context and evidence. 3. The last sentence is an arguable, balanced evaluation that the body must prove.
Worked example: a body paragraph
Model paragraph: "Whitfield's most convincing evidence is the staff survey. She reports that 31 of the school's 40 teachers say phones interrupt their lessons every day, a figure readers can check. From this she infers that a ban would raise grades, a reasonable guess but an unproved one, since the column offers no grade data. Her description of phones as 'the worst thing to happen to school' is opinion presented as fact." Analysis: 1. The topic sentence states one point. 2. The evidence is summarised accurately. 3. Each piece of support is labelled as fact, inference or opinion. 4. The surname is used after the first mention, with present-tense verbs such as "reports" and "infers", as MLA style expects. 5. The point builds the thesis: the evidence supports limits more than a full ban.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, writing only a summary: retelling the text is a starting point, not a response. Second, a thesis that merely says the text is "good" or "interesting" without saying why. Third, judging the topic instead of the text, for example arguing about phones in general rather than about how well Whitfield argues. Fourth, quoting without explaining what the quotation shows. Fifth, treating an inference or an opinion as if it were a fact. Sixth, forgetting to credit the source: quotations, paraphrases and summaries all need a citation.
Key takeaways
A critical response restates a text briefly, analyses how it works and evaluates how well it achieves its purpose. Start by mapping the rhetorical situation and read with other perspectives in mind. Summary condenses, paraphrase clarifies a passage, analysis explains choices and their effects, and evaluation judges them. Sort an argument's support into facts, inferences and opinions. Introduce the author, title and situation, then state your judgement. Support each body point with cited evidence from the text, and explain what that evidence shows.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A short essay that restates, analyses and evaluates one text
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How does a paraphrase differ from a summary?
Question 2 of 5
Whitfield concludes from the staff survey that a phone ban would raise grades. In the model paragraph, what kind of support is this?
Question 3 of 5
Which set of elements belongs in the introduction of a critical response?
Question 4 of 5
A student summarises an article in his own words and does not cite it, reasoning that none of the words are copied. Why is he wrong?
Question 5 of 5
Which question moves a response from analysis to evaluation?
