English Composition › Section T · Portfolio reflection › Topic T.3

Editing focus: pronouns

A reflective essay is full of I, me, my, she, they and it, which makes it a natural place to edit pronouns. Clear pronouns point to one obvious noun, agree with it and take the right form for their job in the sentence.

Why pronouns need editing

A pronoun is a word that stands in for a noun or noun phrase. It is one of the eight traditional parts of speech, with nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs, prepositions, conjunctions and interjections. Without pronouns, prose stalls: "When Dana finished Dana's draft, Dana sent Dana's draft to Dana's tutor." With them it moves: "When Dana finished her draft, she sent it to her tutor." A portfolio reflection uses pronouns constantly, for yourself, your classmates and your assignments, so it is a good place to practise editing them.

Antecedents and agreement

The antecedent is the noun, or another pronoun, that a pronoun replaces. It usually comes first, in the same sentence or an earlier one. A pronoun must agree with its antecedent in number, singular or plural, and in gender where gender applies: "The essays had their strengths"; "My tutor said she liked the ending"; "The draft lost its focus." When a person's gender is unknown or irrelevant, or they use they, singular they is standard in current style guides, as the topic on inclusive writing explained. It takes a plural verb: "Sam says they are ready."

Clear reference

Each pronoun should point to one obvious antecedent. In "When Ana gave Mia her notes, she thanked her," readers cannot tell who thanked whom. Rewrite: "Mia thanked Ana for lending her notes." Watch vague pronouns with no antecedent at all, such as "They say revision is hard": who are they? Watch, too, the demonstrative pronouns this, that, these and those. "I cut two paragraphs and moved the thesis. This made the essay clearer" leaves this hanging. Adding a noun fixes it: "This restructuring made the essay clearer." Followed by a noun, a demonstrative works as an adjective.

Case: subject, object, possessive

Case is the form a pronoun takes for its job in the sentence. Subjective pronouns do the job of subjects: I, he, she, we, they, who, plus you and it. Objective pronouns serve as objects of verbs or prepositions: me, him, her, us, them, whom, plus you and it, which do not change. Possessive pronouns show ownership: my and mine, our and ours, your and yours, his, her and hers, its, their and theirs, whose. Personal possessive pronouns never take an apostrophe. It's always means it is or it has, so test by expanding it: "The class shared it is results" makes no sense, so the correct form is its.

Compounds: I or me?

Case errors cluster in compounds, where a pronoun is joined to another noun with and or or. The rule does not change: subjects take I, objects take me. "Leo and I revised the proposal" is right because I is part of the subject. "The tutor met with Leo and me" is right because me is an object of the preposition with. The quick test is to remove the other person: you would say "I revised" and "met with me", never "me revised" or "met with I". The same logic gives "between you and me" and "The award went to us students."

Who or whom?

Who is subjective and whom is objective. To choose, answer the question with he or him. "Who wrote this?" He wrote this, so who. "To whom did you send it?" You sent it to him, so whom. In longer sentences, look at the pronoun's role in its own clause, not the whole sentence. In "Give feedback to whoever asks for it," whoever is the subject of asks, so it stays subjective even after the preposition to. In "the classmate whom I trust most," I trust him, so whom. Casual speech often uses who for both; formal writing keeps the distinction.

Reflexive pronouns

Reflexive pronouns end in -self or -selves: myself, yourself, himself, herself, itself, ourselves, yourselves and themselves. Use one when the subject and the object refer to one person or thing, as in "I surprised myself," or for emphasis, as in "I built the website myself." Do not use a reflexive as a polite-sounding substitute for I or me. "Send comments to Ray or myself" should be "Send comments to Ray or me," because no one is acting on themselves. Hisself and theirselves are nonstandard; write himself and themselves.

Indefinite pronouns

Indefinite pronouns refer to people or things that are not specified. Some are always singular: each, either, neither, one, and compounds built on -body, -one or -thing, such as everyone, somebody, anything and nothing. Some are always plural: both, few, many and several. A few depend on what they refer to: all, any, more, most, none and some. "Some of the essay is strong" refers to part of one essay, but "Some of the essays are strong" refers to several. For "Everyone revised ___ draft," singular their is now widely accepted; in very formal writing you can rephrase: "All students revised their drafts."

Worked example: editing a reflection

Draft: "Me and Jo revised our proposals together. Jo's had a clear thesis, but it's conclusion was weak. When Jo met our tutor, she was pleased. The tutor praised Jo and myself." Analysis: 1. "Me and Jo" is the subject, so it needs I; drop Jo to test: "I revised." Putting the other person first is courtesy: "Jo and I." 2. "It's conclusion" means "it is conclusion", so the possessive its is needed. 3. "She was pleased" could mean Jo or the tutor; name the person: "the tutor was pleased." 4. "Jo and myself" is an object and nobody acts on themselves, so write "Jo and me." Revised: "Jo and I revised our proposals together. Jo's had a clear thesis, but its conclusion was weak. When Jo met our tutor, the tutor was pleased. The tutor praised Jo and me."

Worked example: four quick decisions

1. "___ should I thank in my letter?" Answer with him: I should thank him, so Whom. 2. "Neither of my early drafts ___ a counterargument." Neither is singular, so has. 3. "The reviewer gave ___ comments to Kai and me." A single reviewer of unknown gender takes their under current style guides; if you know the reviewer uses she, write her. 4. "These are mine; ___ are on the desk." A possessive pronoun takes no apostrophe, so theirs, not their's. In each case the method is the same: find the antecedent or the pronoun's job in its clause, then choose the form that matches.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, "me and Jo" as a subject or "Jo and I" as an object: test by dropping the other person. Second, it's for its, or apostrophes in hers, ours and theirs. Third, a pronoun that could point to two people. Fourth, a vague this or they with no clear antecedent. Fifth, myself used in place of I or me. Sixth, a plural verb with a singular indefinite pronoun, as in "each of the drafts have". Seventh, who where formal writing needs whom.

Key takeaways

Pronouns replace nouns and must agree with their antecedents in number and, where relevant, gender; singular they is standard when gender is unknown or a person uses it. Every pronoun needs one clear antecedent. Case matches the job: subjective for subjects, objective for objects, possessive for ownership, with no apostrophes. Test compounds by removing the other person, and choose who or whom by answering with he or him. Use reflexives only when subject and object match. Learn which indefinite pronouns are singular, plural or variable.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Pronoun

A word that stands in for a noun or noun phrase

One of the eight parts of speech.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which sentence uses pronoun case correctly?

Question 2 of 5

Which sentence is correct?

Question 3 of 5

Choose the correct word: "Give the checklist to ___ needs it."

Question 4 of 5

Which sentence has an unclear pronoun reference?

Question 5 of 5

Which sentence follows the agreement rules in the reading?

← Previous topicNext topic →