English Composition › Section J · The position argument › Topic J.3
Editing focus: paragraphs that work
Readers experience an argument one paragraph at a time. A paragraph that makes one clear point, develops it fully and connects it to its neighbours does more to persuade than any single clever sentence.
Paragraphs as building blocks
Each body paragraph of an argument usually develops one main point in support of the thesis. When you move to a new point, start a new paragraph; the indentation or line break tells readers a step in the reasoning is complete. Two problems follow from ignoring this. A crowded paragraph that juggles three ideas leaves readers unsure which one matters. A repetitive paragraph that restates one idea without adding evidence or explanation wastes space and patience. While editing, ask of every paragraph: what single point does this make, and how does it serve the thesis?
Topic sentences that make claims
A topic sentence states the paragraph's main point and links it to the thesis. It is often the first sentence, which lets a hurried reader follow the argument by reading only the openings. "Later start times also make teenage drivers safer" tells readers exactly what the paragraph will prove. A topic sentence should be a claim, not a bare fact ("Many students drive to school"), an announcement ("This paragraph is about driving") or a quotation from a source. The source can come in as evidence; the claim should be yours.
Developing a paragraph: PEEL
After the topic sentence, a developed paragraph supplies evidence, explains it and connects it to the larger argument. One memorable pattern is PEEL: point, evidence, explanation, link. The point is the topic sentence. The evidence is a fact, example, statistic or quotation. The explanation shows how that evidence proves the point, and it is where your thinking becomes visible; it often needs two or three sentences. The link ties the paragraph back to the thesis or leads into the next. A paragraph that stops after the evidence leaves readers to do the reasoning for you.
Unity: every sentence earns its place
A unified paragraph keeps every sentence focused on its main idea. To test unity, read the topic sentence, then ask of each later sentence whether it supports, explains or illustrates that point. Interesting detours fail the test even when they are true. In a paragraph arguing that a bus route saves commuters time, a sentence about the colour of the new buses does not belong, however vivid. Cut such sentences, or move them to a paragraph where they do serve the point. Unity is easiest to judge after drafting, when you can see the whole paragraph at once.
Coherence: sentences that flow
A coherent paragraph moves logically from sentence to sentence, so readers never wonder why one follows another. Several tools create coherence. Repeating key terms keeps the subject in view. Pronouns such as this and these, used where their reference is clear, point back to the previous idea. A consistent order, whether by time, by importance or from general to specific, gives the paragraph a shape. Transitional words and phrases name the relationship between ideas. Unity and coherence work together: unity decides what belongs in the paragraph, coherence decides how it fits together.
Transitions within and between paragraphs
Transitions show how ideas relate. Common groups include addition (also, in addition, furthermore), contrast (however, on the other hand, yet), cause and effect (therefore, as a result, consequently), example (for example, specifically), sequence (first, next, finally), concession (although, admittedly, even so) and summary (in short, overall). Between paragraphs, the opening sentence does this job: "Another reason..." or "Even if cost were no obstacle..." tells readers how the new point relates to the last. Choose transitions for their meaning, not their sound: a therefore that does not follow misleads more than no transition at all.
How long is a paragraph?
There is no fixed length. Academic paragraphs often run from about 100 to 250 words, enough room for a claim, evidence and real explanation. A very short paragraph may be underdeveloped, a claim with nothing behind it. A very long one may contain two ideas and need splitting where the focus shifts. Online and workplace writing uses shorter paragraphs because readers scan screens, and a single-sentence paragraph can be used now and then for emphasis. Judge length by function: does the paragraph fully develop one point?
Introductions and conclusions
An introduction draws readers in, gives the context they need and states the thesis. The hook might be a striking fact, a question, a brief anecdote or a problem. Avoid sweeping openers such as "Since the dawn of time", which promise nothing specific. Many writers draft the introduction last, once they know what the essay argues. A conclusion should do more than repeat the introduction. It can draw the main points together, explain why the argument matters, suggest next steps or return to an opening image with new meaning. It should not introduce major new evidence, which belongs in a body paragraph.
Worked example: building a PEEL paragraph
Thesis (fictional): the school should install water-bottle refill stations. 1. Point: "Refill stations would cut the school's plastic waste." A claim that serves the thesis. 2. Evidence: "At a neighbouring school, the caretaker's records show disposable bottles in the bins fell from about 300 a week to about 90 within a term of installing two stations." Specific and sourced. 3. Explanation: "Students bought fewer bottles once free, cold water was easy to reach, so the change came from convenience, not from lectures about recycling." This shows why the evidence supports the point. 4. Link: "Less waste is only one benefit; the stations also save families money." It closes the point and opens the next.
Worked example: adding transitions
Draft: "Cyclists on Station Road ride in traffic. A protected lane would separate them. Accidents have risen. The council has the money in its transport budget." Revision: "At present, cyclists on Station Road must ride in traffic. A protected lane would separate them from cars and, as a result, make the route safer. This matters because accidents on the road have risen. Furthermore, the council already has the money in its transport budget." Analysis: 1. At present sets the time frame. 2. As a result marks cause and effect. 3. This matters because ties the accident figure to the claim. 4. Furthermore adds a separate reason. The ideas are unchanged, but their relationships are now visible.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, opening with a fact or a quotation instead of a claim. Second, stopping after the evidence without explaining it. Third, letting a paragraph drift into a second idea. Fourth, using transitions mechanically, or choosing one whose meaning does not fit, such as however between two ideas that agree. Fifth, writing an introduction that never reaches a thesis, or a conclusion that merely repeats the introduction. Sixth, adding major new evidence in the conclusion, where readers have no chance to weigh it.
Key takeaways
Each body paragraph develops one main idea, introduced by a topic sentence that makes a claim linked to the thesis. Develop it with evidence, explanation and a link, the PEEL pattern. Unity keeps every sentence on that idea; coherence makes the sentences flow through key terms, clear pronouns, logical order and well-chosen transitions. Transitions within and between paragraphs name the relationship between ideas. Judge length by function. Introductions hook, give context and state the thesis; conclusions draw the argument together and explain its significance without adding major new evidence.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Develops one main point in support of the thesis
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which is the strongest topic sentence for a paragraph in an essay arguing that the school needs more counsellors?
Question 2 of 5
A paragraph opens with a claim, gives a statistic from a study, then ends: "This shows the policy must change." Which PEEL element is weakest?
Question 3 of 5
"The plan would cost $40,000 a year. ___, it would save about $55,000 a year in repairs." Which transition fits best?
Question 4 of 5
A paragraph argues that a new bus route saves commuters time. Which sentence breaks its unity?
Question 5 of 5
Which is the best approach for the conclusion of a position argument?
