English Composition › Section U · Handbook: grammar, style, and documentation › Topic U.5
Point of view
Every piece of writing speaks from somewhere: from inside the writer's experience, directly to the reader, or from a step back. Choosing first, second or third person to suit the genre, and holding that choice steady, is a quick way to make writing sound controlled and credible.
Point of view and grammatical person
Point of view is the position from which a piece of writing is told. In storytelling it decides what a narrator can know, as the earlier topic on characterisation and point of view showed with first-person, third-person limited and omniscient narration. In essays, reports and other nonfiction, point of view comes down to grammatical person: whether the writing speaks as I or we, addresses you, or talks about he, she, it and they. The right choice depends mainly on genre and purpose, and the most common error is not the choice itself but an unplanned switch partway through.
The three persons
First person puts the writer in the text: I, me, my, mine, and the plural we, us, our, ours. Second person addresses the reader: you, your, yours, used for one reader or many. Third person refers to people and things outside the conversation: he, she, it and they with their other forms (him, her, them), the formal one, and every ordinary noun, such as the researchers, voters or the city. Most sentences in academic writing are in the third person simply because their subjects are nouns: "Rising rents have pushed families out of the centre." A pronoun search, for I, we and you, quickly shows which person a draft actually uses.
First person
First person suits writing in which the writer's own experience is the subject: literacy narratives, memoirs, profiles told through the writer's visit, reflections and personal essays. It is honest and direct. In academic writing its use is growing. APA 7 advises writers to use I or we to describe their own actions, such as "I interviewed 12 nurses", rather than calling themselves "the author". MLA style does not forbid it either, but many instructors prefer third person in literary and textual analysis, so check the assignment. Two habits weaken first person in arguments: cluttering claims with I think or I believe, and a vague we that never says who we are.
Second person
Second person speaks to the reader directly. It is right for instructions ("Save your file before you close the program"), for letters, speeches and guides that address an audience, and for textbooks such as this course. Instructions often use commands, where you is understood: "Add one cup of flour." A story told in second person, which makes the reader a character, is a rare narrative choice discussed in the earlier topic. In most academic writing, though, second person is out of place. Writers slip into it by accident, using you to mean people in general, which can sound as if the reader personally is being accused or advised.
Third person
Third person is the customary point of view for research papers, reports, analyses and arguments. It keeps attention on the subject and the evidence rather than on the writer, which suits writing whose authority rests on sources and reasoning. Third person is not automatically objective: word choice and selection of evidence still reveal a stance. Nor does it require clumsy substitutes. The pronoun one ("One must consider the cost") is grammatical but quickly sounds stiff; a specific noun usually works better: "Planners must consider the cost." When people in general are meant, name the group: students, drivers, patients, voters.
Worked example: removing an accidental you
Draft: "The city should make buses free for students. Teenagers depend on public transport, and when fares rise, you start skipping after-school activities. A monthly pass costs $40, which is a lot when you work a part-time job. Free fares would help you stay involved." 1. The first sentence sets the point of view: third person, about students. 2. In sentence two, you suddenly means teenagers, an unplanned shift; change it to they. 3. In sentence three, you works a part-time job; name the group: "many students". 4. In sentence four, you becomes them. Revision: "...when fares rise, they start skipping after-school activities. A monthly pass costs $40, a large sum for students working part-time. Free fares would help them stay involved." The argument now speaks consistently about its subject.
Matching point of view to genre
Genre is the best guide. A literacy narrative, memoir or reflection: first person, since the writer's experience is the subject. A profile: usually third person for the subject, with first person for the writer's visit if the profile includes it. A how-to guide or set of instructions: second person and commands. A research paper, report or argument: mainly third person, with first person for the writer's own methods where the style guide allows it. A literary analysis: usually third person, writing about the text and its author. When an assignment is unclear, ask, or follow the models your instructor provides.
Keeping point of view consistent
Once you choose a point of view, hold it unless there is a reason to change. Common unplanned shifts run from third person to you ("Voters often feel ignored, and you stop paying attention"), from one to you ("One should vote, even if you dislike every candidate"), and from I to you in personal writing ("I walked in, and you could smell the paint"). Each version can be repaired by choosing one person and following it through: "Voters often feel ignored, and they stop paying attention." A deliberate shift is fine: a reflection may turn to address the reader in its final line. Matching each pronoun to its noun in number belongs to the later topic on pronouns.
Worked example: one fact, three points of view
Content: a student learned that drafting by hand before typing helped her write. Reflection (first person): "I used to stare at a blank screen for an hour. This term I began drafting by hand, and the first page came in ten minutes." Guide for new students (second person): "If a blank screen stalls you, draft your first page by hand, then type it up." Report (third person, fictional survey): "In a writing-centre survey, several students said that drafting by hand helped them start." Analysis: 1. The reflection makes the writer's experience the subject. 2. The guide addresses a reader who may act on the advice. 3. The report steps back and treats the experience as evidence. 4. Each choice fits its genre; mixing them in one piece would not.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, sliding into a generic you in an academic essay. Second, shifting between one and you, or I and you, in the same sentence. Third, avoiding I so strictly that sentences become awkward ("this writer believes") where the style guide allows first person. Fourth, using a vague we without saying who is included. Fifth, overusing one, which makes prose sound stiff. Sixth, assuming third person makes writing neutral when the word choice is still loaded. Seventh, confusing ordinary direct address with second-person narration.
Key takeaways
In nonfiction, point of view means grammatical person. First person (I, we) suits personal genres and, where allowed, your own methods; APA 7 prefers I or we to "the author". Second person (you) suits instructions, guides and direct address, but not most academic prose. Third person (he, she, it, they, one and nouns) is the norm for research papers, reports, analyses and arguments. Choose by genre, replace generic you with a specific noun, and keep the choice consistent unless a shift is deliberate.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The position from which a piece of writing is told
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which set contains only second-person pronouns?
Question 2 of 5
Which sentence contains an unplanned shift in point of view?
Question 3 of 5
Which piece would most naturally be written in the first person?
Question 4 of 5
Which is the best revision of "When you study climate data, you see a clear warming trend" for a research paper?
Question 5 of 5
Following APA 7, how should a student describe her own survey method?
