English Composition › Section E · The profile › Topic E.2

Finding the angle on your subject

A strong profile is built, not found: you define a quality you admire, pick a subject that shows it, research that subject three ways, and then choose the angle your evidence supports best.

The assignment: profiling an admirable trait

A classic profile assignment asks you to show how someone or something near you, on campus or in your community, displays a quality you admire: courage, patience, generosity, humour. The subject can be a person, a group, a place or an event. You will research it in three ways, interviews, field observation and secondary sources, then choose an angle, draft, and revise after peer review. The process is recursive: you may gather one more interview while drafting or reorder paragraphs after feedback. Keep the angle in view throughout, because irrelevant material makes a profile sag.

Defining the trait

Start with the trait, because your definition will steer every later choice. Set a timer for five minutes and list qualities you admire, thinking of real people and what you admire in them. Choose one. Then explore it: jot words you link with it, or note moments when you or others showed it. From those notes, write a personal definition. For example: "Patience is the willingness to let something grow at its own speed, even when hurrying would be easier." Expect it to change as you research; the final version may even appear in the profile.

Choosing a subject

List possible subjects: staff, coaches, alumni, student groups, buildings, public art, local businesses, yearly events. Do a quick online search on the few that intrigue you most, perhaps on the campus or town website. This search only narrows options; deeper research comes later. Then weigh two questions. Which subject best fits your definition of the trait? Which genuinely interests you? Curiosity matters, because it will carry you through hours of research. An archivist or librarian can suggest subjects you would never find alone, and an instructor or writing-centre tutor can help you decide between two.

Planning a research calendar

Profiles need three kinds of research, and the slowest part is waiting for other people, so plan backwards from your draft date. Interviews: send requests as soon as you choose a subject; one or two good interviews usually suffice. Field observation: if your subject is a person, ask when you may watch them at work; if it is a place, decide when to visit and get any permission you need. Allow 30 to 60 minutes for notes. Secondary research: book several sessions to find credible published material, and ask a research librarian if you get stuck.

Worked example: an interview request email

Model email: "Subject: Interview request for a profile of the Eastside Community Garden. Dear Professor Okafor, I am a first-year student in Professor Lin's writing class, and I am writing a profile of the Eastside Community Garden that focuses on patience. Could I interview you for about 15 minutes, in person or by video call, in the next week? If so, please reply with two or three times that suit you. Thank you for considering my request. Best regards, Maya Chen" Analysis: 1. The subject line states the point, like an essay title. 2. The salutation uses her title. 3. The first sentence shows Maya's connection and purpose. 4. The request is specific and small. 5. Next steps are clear. 6. The closing is polite and professional.

Interviews, field notes and secondary sources

Primary research is material you collect yourself. Interviewing your subject, or someone with credible knowledge of it, is primary; a published interview with your subject is secondary. Prepare open questions, such as how they would define your trait, and follow up on things your early research turned up. Record only with permission. Field observation produces thick description: sounds, smells, textures, gestures, clothing, setting. For secondary research, use credible sources, and read about related topics too, such as the cause your subject serves. Cite interviews and field notes as well as published sources.

Synthesising your research

To synthesise is to put the findings together so patterns appear. A three-column table helps: each source by type (interview, field observation with place and date, secondary source); what it provides (quotations, anecdotes, facts, background, context); and the possible angles it suggests. Your general angle is already set, since it is the trait. What you need now is a personal insight within it, something about the trait that might surprise readers. A web diagram, with the trait in the centre and possible insights branching out, makes the options visible side by side.

Worked example: from notes to thesis

Subject: Marcus Hill, an invented campus shuttle driver of 22 years. Trait: patience. 1. List the evidence. Interview: he knows regular riders by name. Field notes: he held the bus for a student running through the rain. Campus paper, 2015: the university cut his evening route. A colleague: he spent three years collecting rider signatures until the route returned. 2. List the insights: patience as attention, as kindness, as persistence. 3. Test them: persistence draws on three sources and overturns the usual idea of patience as passive waiting. 4. Draft the thesis: "Marcus Hill's patience shows in more than waiting for late riders; it shows most in a three-year campaign to win back a route the university had cut."

Drafting the profile

Choose a structure that fits: chronological, spatial, topical, or a mix. The introduction should hook readers and give the background they need to appreciate your angle, with the thesis at or near its end. Each body paragraph should advance the angle by blending several kinds of material from more than one source: an anecdote, a quotation, a fact, a description of the setting. Mix narrative with reporting so readers both see and learn, and keep the tone suited to your angle. The conclusion can restate the main point and explain why it matters to readers now.

Reviewing, peer feedback and revision

Read your draft three times. First, revise: judge the big picture, content and arrangement. Second, edit: sentence variety, word choice and consistent verb tenses. Third, proofread: spelling, punctuation and formatting in the required style, such as MLA. In peer review, read the whole draft first, and be clear and kind: name specific strengths, then specific changes. When you receive feedback, give most weight to points that several readers make, and deal with revision comments about content, structure and angle before editing comments. You remain the author, so you may decline a suggestion after considering it honestly.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, sending interview requests too late, so the draft is due before anyone replies. Second, treating a published interview as primary research. Third, stopping at the trait: "she is brave" is the general angle, not yet an insight. Fourth, building each body paragraph from a single source, which turns the profile into a string of summaries. Fifth, fixing commas while a reviewer's comment that the angle is unclear goes unanswered. Sixth, picking a subject only because it is convenient, then running out of curiosity halfway through.

Key takeaways

Define an admirable trait in your own words, then choose a subject that fits it and interests you. Plan a research calendar for interviews, field observation and secondary research, and request interviews early with a clear, professional email. Synthesise your findings in a table to find a personal insight within the trait, and state that angle in a thesis near the end of the introduction. Build each body paragraph from several sources, then revise, edit and proofread, acting first on the big-picture feedback that reviewers share.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Admirable trait

The quality your profile shows the subject displaying

Define it in your own words first.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these counts as primary research for a profile of a college coach?

Question 2 of 5

Which subject line best suits an email requesting an interview for a profile?

Question 3 of 5

After synthesising research, a writer's general angle is "courage". What is the best next step?

Question 4 of 5

Where does the thesis of a profile usually belong?

Question 5 of 5

Two peer reviewers say a draft's angle is unclear; a third points out a missing comma. What should the writer do first?

← Previous topicNext topic →