English Composition › Section U · Handbook: grammar, style, and documentation › Topic U.7

Pronouns

Pronouns are the smallest words doing some of the hardest work in a sentence. When each one points to a clear noun, agrees with it and takes the right form, readers never notice them; when one slips, the meaning slips with it.

Small words, big jobs

A pronoun stands in for a noun so that a paragraph need not repeat the same name: I, you, she, they, it, who, this, everyone and many more. The noun a pronoun points back to is its antecedent. In "Maya cut her essay because it was too long", her points to Maya and it points to essay. Editing pronouns means checking three things: that each one has a clear antecedent, that it agrees with that antecedent, and that it takes the right case for its job in the sentence.

Clear reference

A pronoun should point to one obvious antecedent. Sometimes two nouns could both be the antecedent. Unclear: "When Lena met her sister at the station, she was exhausted." Revised: "Lena was exhausted when she met her sister at the station." Sometimes the only candidate is tucked inside a possessive. Unclear: "In Patel's report, he argues that bus fares should fall." Careful editors treat he as lacking an antecedent, because Patel's acts as a describing word for report. Revised: "In his report, Patel argues that bus fares should fall." Repeating the noun or rebuilding the sentence usually fixes both problems.

Vague this, which and it; indefinite they and you

As the sentence-structure topic showed, a bare "this" leaves readers asking "this what?". That, which and it do the same when they point at a whole idea. Unclear: "The council raised fares and cut weekend routes, which upset commuters." The fares, the cuts or both? Revised: "The council raised fares and cut weekend routes, and the cuts upset commuters." They, it and you also need real antecedents. Unclear: "At the clinic, they told me to wait." Revised: "At the clinic, the receptionist told me to wait." In formal writing, keep you for the reader you are actually addressing.

Agreement in number

A pronoun agrees with its antecedent: singular with singular, plural with plural. Antecedents joined by and are usually plural: "Omar and Bea finished their poster." With or or nor, the pronoun agrees with the nearer antecedent: "Neither the coach nor the players changed their plans." Putting the plural antecedent second avoids an awkward result. Indefinite pronouns fall into the groups from the subject-verb agreement topic: both, few, many and several are plural; all, any, most, none and some depend on their noun; and each, either, neither and words ending in -one, -body or -thing are grammatically singular, which raises the question in the next card.

Singular they

Without an accepted gender-neutral singular pronoun, formal writers once used he for everyone ("Everyone has his own opinion") or the clumsy he or she. Today APA 7 and MLA both accept singular they, for a person whose gender is unknown or irrelevant and for anyone who uses they as their pronoun. Correct: "Each nurse updates their own charts." Correct: "Sam said they were running late." Singular they keeps its plural verb forms: they are, not they is. If it could confuse readers, for instance where they already refers to a group nearby, make the antecedent plural ("Nurses update their own charts") or remove the pronoun ("Each nurse updates the charts").

Collective nouns

A collective noun such as team, jury, class, family or orchestra names a group. When the group acts as one unit, the usual case, American usage treats it as singular: "The jury delivered its verdict." When the members act separately, a plural pronoun is possible, but adding members is usually cleaner: "The jury members went back to their homes." Stay consistent within the sentence: "The orchestra tunes its instruments" or "The orchestra members tune their instruments", not a singular verb with a plural pronoun, as in "The orchestra tunes their instruments".

Pronoun case

Case is the form a pronoun takes for its job. Subjective pronouns act as subjects: I, we, you, he, she, it, they, who. Objective pronouns act as objects of verbs and prepositions: me, us, you, him, her, it, them, whom. Possessive pronouns show ownership: my, mine, your, his, her, its, our, their, whose and so on. Most case errors hide in compounds, so delete the other noun and listen. "Ana and me presented" becomes "me presented", so write "Ana and I presented". "The prize went to Ana and I" becomes "went to I", so write "to Ana and me". The same test explains "between you and me".

Who or whom, than or as, we or us

Who is subjective and whom objective. Answer the clause with he or him: "the candidate (who/whom) voters trust" becomes "voters trust him", so whom. Words such as I think in the middle do not change the clause: "the singer who I think will win" (she will win). After than or as, finish the comparison silently: "Jun reads more than I" means "than I read", while "Jun likes Ruth more than me" means "more than he likes me". With a noun after we or us, drop the noun: "We volunteers set up the hall" and "The mayor thanked us volunteers". Before a gerund, an -ing word used as a noun, formal writing uses the possessive: "She objected to my leaving early."

Worked example: editing for reference

Draft: "When Theo emailed his manager about the schedule, he said it was unfair. Every employee should be able to plan their week, but they keep changing shifts. This is why the team has lost three of their best workers." Revision: "Theo emailed his manager to say that the schedule was unfair. Every employee should be able to plan their week, but managers keep changing shifts. These sudden changes are why the team has lost three of its best workers." Analysis: 1. He could mean Theo or the manager, so the sentence is rebuilt around Theo. 2. Their week is correct singular they. 3. They had no antecedent, so managers replaces it. 4. This becomes a noun phrase. 5. Has and their clashed, so its matches the singular team.

Worked example: choosing the case

1. "The coach asked Dev and (I/me) to lead warm-ups." Delete Dev: "asked me". The pronoun is an object, so me. 2. "Give the keys to (whoever/whomever) arrives first." The pronoun is the subject of arrives; the whole clause, not the pronoun, is the object of to. So whoever. 3. "Nobody was more surprised than (she/her)." Finish the comparison: "than she was", so she. 4. "The neighbours complained about (them/their) practising at night." Practising is a gerund, so formal writing uses the possessive: their.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, a pronoun with two possible antecedents, or one hidden inside a possessive. Second, this, which or it pointing at a whole idea. Third, they or you with nobody in particular behind them. Fourth, a collective noun treated as singular and plural in one sentence. Fifth, choosing I or me by sound in a compound; delete the other noun and test again. Sixth, using myself to sound formal, as in "Contact Priya or myself"; myself belongs only where the subject acts on itself ("I taught myself") or for emphasis. Seventh, writing it's, who's or they're where the possessive its, whose or their is meant.

Key takeaways

Every pronoun needs one clear antecedent; if it lacks one, repeat the noun or rebuild the sentence. Pronouns agree in number: and usually makes a plural, and with or or nor the nearer antecedent decides. APA 7 and MLA accept singular they, with plural verb forms. A collective noun acting as one unit takes its. Choose case by job: subjective for subjects, objective for objects, possessive for ownership and before gerunds. Test compounds by deleting the other noun, who and whom with he and him, and comparisons by finishing them.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Antecedent

The noun a pronoun refers back to

In "Maya cut her essay", Maya is the antecedent of her.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which sentence uses pronoun case correctly?

Question 2 of 5

In formal writing, which word completes the sentence? "The student ___ the panel selected will speak first."

Question 3 of 5

The jury reaches one shared decision. In American usage, which sentence handles the collective noun correctly?

Question 4 of 5

The draft reads: "The council cut bus routes and closed two libraries. This angered residents." Which revision fixes the vague pronoun?

Question 5 of 5

Which revision of "Every applicant must submit his or her portfolio by Friday" uses a pronoun that APA 7 and MLA accept for a person of unknown gender?

← Previous topicNext topic →