English Composition › Section U · Handbook: grammar, style, and documentation › Topic U.3

Fragments, run-ons, and other sentence errors

A handful of sentence errors cause most of the stumbles readers meet: fragments, comma splices, run-ons and stray modifiers. Each has a reliable test and a small set of fixes, so you can find and repair them quickly when you proofread.

Errors that trip readers

When a sentence stops short, runs two sentences together or attaches a description to the wrong word, readers must stop and rebuild it, and the writer loses credibility. This topic covers four common problems: fragments, comma splices, run-on sentences and misplaced or dangling modifiers. A fifth, the mixed construction, had its own editing-focus topic earlier in the course. Everything here depends on the difference between independent and dependent clauses, explained in the topic on sentence structure.

What a fragment is missing

A fragment begins with a capital and ends with a full stop but cannot stand alone. It lacks a subject, lacks a complete verb, or is a dependent clause on its own. Missing a subject: "Packed the van before dawn." Missing a complete verb: "The volunteers sorting donations." An -ing word on its own cannot be the main verb; it needs a helper such as were. A dependent clause alone: "Because the road was flooded." A phrase alone: "For example, the costs of fuel and insurance." Many fragments are afterthoughts cut off from the sentence before them.

Fixing fragments

There are two standard repairs. Attach the fragment to the sentence it depends on. Incorrect: "We drove the long way round. Because the road was flooded." Correct: "We drove the long way round because the road was flooded." Or supply what is missing, so the fragment becomes a sentence. Incorrect: "Running costs rose sharply. Things like fuel and insurance." Correct: "Running costs rose sharply. Fuel and insurance cost the most." Fiction and advertising use fragments on purpose for pace: "The power went out at nine. Then silence." In academic writing, use them rarely, and only where the choice is plainly deliberate.

Worked example: repairing fragments

Draft: "The new bike lanes have changed the town centre. Especially on market days. Cyclists now outnumber cars on the high street. Because bike parking is free. The council planning a second route." 1. "Especially on market days" is a phrase with no subject or verb; attach it to the sentence it qualifies: "...the town centre, especially on market days." 2. "Because bike parking is free" is a dependent clause; attach it to the sentence it explains: "...on the high street because bike parking is free." 3. "The council planning" lacks a complete verb; add one: "The council is planning a second route." Revision: "The new bike lanes have changed the town centre, especially on market days. Cyclists now outnumber cars on the high street because bike parking is free. The council is planning a second route."

Comma splices and run-ons

Both errors join two independent clauses without the right link. A comma splice joins them with a comma alone: "The ferry was cancelled, we drove around the bay." A run-on sentence, also called a fused sentence, joins them with no punctuation at all: "The ferry was cancelled we drove around the bay." Some handbooks use run-on for both errors; the cure is the same. Length has nothing to do with it: a forty-word sentence with correctly joined clauses is not a run-on, and a seven-word sentence can be one. To test, find every clause that could stand alone, then check what joins them.

Five ways to repair them

Choose the repair that shows how the two ideas relate. 1. A full stop: "The ferry was cancelled. We drove around the bay." 2. A semicolon, for closely related ideas: "The ferry was cancelled; we drove around the bay." 3. A comma plus one of the FANBOYS: "The ferry was cancelled, so we drove around the bay." 4. A semicolon and a conjunctive adverb, with a comma after it: "The ferry was cancelled; therefore, we drove around the bay." 5. Subordination, turning one clause into a dependent clause: "Because the ferry was cancelled, we drove around the bay." Options 3 to 5 also name the relationship, here cause.

Misplaced modifiers

A modifier is a word or phrase that describes another part of the sentence. Readers attach it to whatever sits nearest, so a misplaced modifier, one next to the wrong word, misleads. Incorrect: "The museum displays a coat in its main hall that belonged to a sea captain." The hall did not belong to the captain. Correct: "In its main hall, the museum displays a coat that belonged to a sea captain." Limiting words such as only, almost, just and nearly change meaning with position. "The team almost won every match" suggests it came close each time but won none; "The team won almost every match" clearly means it lost only a few. Put each limiting word directly before the word it limits.

Dangling modifiers

A dangling modifier, usually an opening phrase, has nothing in the sentence it can sensibly describe, because readers assume it describes the subject that follows. Incorrect: "Walking to class, the rain started." The rain was not walking. Incorrect: "After reading the report, the decision seemed obvious." The decision did not read anything. Fix the error in one of two ways. Make the right doer the subject: "After reading the report, I found the decision obvious." Or turn the phrase into a full clause with its own subject: "After I read the report, the decision seemed obvious."

Worked example: four repairs

1. "Our survey closed on Friday, responses had doubled." A comma splice. Subordination shows the time link: "By the time our survey closed on Friday, responses had doubled." 2. "The bridge reopened traffic returned to normal." A run-on. Add a conjunction to show sequence: "The bridge reopened, and traffic returned to normal." 3. "Covered in mud, my mother made me hose down the dog." A misplaced modifier, not a dangling one, because the dog it describes is in the sentence: it sits next to my mother, so it seems to describe her. Move it: "My mother made me hose down the dog, which was covered in mud." 4. "I nearly read the whole chapter." If the writer read most of it, nearly is misplaced: "I read nearly the whole chapter."

A proofreading routine

These errors hide in your own drafts because you know what you meant. Read the paragraph backwards, last sentence first, so each sentence must stand on its own; fragments become obvious. Stop at every comma between two clauses and ask whether a conjunction is there. Stop at every opening phrase and ask who is doing its action. Check each only, almost and just. Then read aloud. Keep a list of the errors you make most often and search for them in every draft.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, fixing a comma splice with a stronger-looking comma word: "The ferry was cancelled, however, we drove" is still a splice. Second, assuming any long sentence is a run-on. Third, treating an -ing word as a complete verb. Fourth, giving a clause beginning with because or although its own full stop. Fifth, fixing a dangling modifier with a comma instead of naming the doer. Sixth, scattering intentional fragments through academic prose, where readers take them for mistakes.

Key takeaways

A fragment lacks a subject or a complete verb, or is a dependent clause or phrase standing alone; attach it or complete it. A comma splice joins independent clauses with a comma alone, and a run-on joins them with nothing; repair either with a full stop, a semicolon, a comma and a coordinating conjunction, a semicolon and a conjunctive adverb, or subordination. Length does not make a run-on. Place each modifier, including only and almost, next to what it describes, and give every opening phrase a subject it can describe. Proofread backwards and aloud.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sentence fragment

Words punctuated as a sentence that cannot stand alone

Missing a subject or verb, or a dependent clause alone.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these is a sentence fragment?

Question 2 of 5

Which sentence is a run-on (fused) sentence, with no punctuation between its clauses?

Question 3 of 5

Which revision correctly fixes the comma splice "The printer jammed, I finished the report by hand"?

Question 4 of 5

Which sentence contains a dangling modifier?

Question 5 of 5

A coach wants to say the team lost only one or two matches all season. Which sentence says this most clearly?

← Previous topicNext topic →