Macroeconomics › Section T · International trade › Topic T.1

Absolute and comparative advantage

Countries trade for the same reason people do: nobody is best at making everything, and what you give up to make something matters more than how fast you make it. This topic turns that idea into numbers you can calculate.

Why countries trade

Look at the labels on what you own and you will find goods from dozens of countries. Since Adam Smith in the 1770s, economists have argued that trade lets every participating economy consume more than it could produce on its own. To see why, you need two ideas that are easy to mix up: absolute advantage and comparative advantage. The earlier topic on the production possibilities frontier introduced both; this topic develops them into a method.

Absolute advantage

A country has an absolute advantage in a good if it can produce more of that good than another country from the same resources, or the same amount with fewer resources. Absolute advantage often comes from geography and endowments: rich soil, a warm climate, a large oil field or a deep copper seam. It can also come from skilled workers, better machines and better technology. Adam Smith, writing in 1776, argued that if each country made the goods it was absolutely best at and traded for the rest, both would gain. That is true, but it is only part of the story.

Comparative advantage

A country has a comparative advantage in a good if it can produce it at a lower opportunity cost than another country, that is, by giving up less of other goods. David Ricardo set out this idea in 1817. The key question is not "who is fastest?" but "what does each producer sacrifice?" With two goods, opportunity cost is a ratio between them, so comparative advantage depends on relative productivity, not on size or speed. One consequence follows straight from the arithmetic: if a country's opportunity cost of good X is lower, its opportunity cost of good Y must be higher, so each country has a comparative advantage in something. The one exception is when both countries face identical opportunity costs: then neither has a comparative advantage and specialising gains nothing.

Worked example: hours per unit

Two countries each have 120 labour hours. In Aria a bolt of cloth takes 3 hours and a crate of tea takes 6 hours. In Borea cloth takes 4 hours and tea takes 2 hours. 1. Absolute advantage: Aria needs fewer hours for cloth (3 against 4), and Borea needs fewer for tea (2 against 6). 2. Opportunity cost of cloth: the 3 hours Aria spends on a bolt could make \(3 \div 6 = 0.5\) crate of tea; in Borea a bolt costs \(4 \div 2 = 2\) crates. 3. Opportunity cost of tea: Aria gives up 2 bolts per crate, Borea only 0.5. 4. Conclusion: Aria has the comparative advantage in cloth and Borea in tea. 5. Check: each country's two opportunity costs are reciprocals, \(0.5 \times 2 = 1\).

Two kinds of table

Data arrive in two forms, and mixing them up is the commonest error. An input table gives hours (or workers) needed per unit, as in the Aria example: there, a smaller number is better. An output table gives units produced per worker or per day. Suppose a worker in Cedar makes 8 chairs or 2 tables a day, and a worker in Delta makes 3 chairs or 3 tables. With output data, the opportunity cost of one table is chairs divided by tables: \(8 \div 2 = 4\) chairs in Cedar, \(3 \div 3 = 1\) chair in Delta. So Delta has the comparative advantage in tables and Cedar in chairs. With input data you divide the other way round, which is why you should always ask which kind of table you have.

Straight-line frontiers

With one input and fixed hours per unit, each country's production possibilities frontier is a straight line: Aria can make 40 bolts of cloth, or 20 crates of tea, or any mix on the line between. A straight line means the opportunity cost is constant, unlike the bowed-out frontier of the earlier topic, where resources were unequally suited to different jobs. Real economies face rising costs, but straight lines keep the arithmetic clean. The size of its slope is the opportunity cost of the good on the horizontal axis, measured in the good on the vertical axis.

Worked example: gains from trade

Before trade, suppose Aria splits its hours evenly, making 20 cloth and 10 tea, and Borea does the same, making 15 cloth and 30 tea. World output is 35 cloth and 40 tea. 1. Specialise: Aria puts all 120 hours into cloth (40 bolts) and Borea all 120 into tea (60 crates). World output rises to 40 cloth and 60 tea, more of both. 2. Trade at 1 cloth for 1 tea: Aria sends 18 cloth to Borea in exchange for 18 tea. 3. Aria now consumes 22 cloth and 18 tea, up from 20 and 10. Borea consumes 18 cloth and 42 tea, up from 15 and 30. 4. Check: Aria would need \(22 \times 3 + 18 \times 6 = 174\) hours to make its new bundle alone, more than its 120, so the bundle lies outside its frontier. That is the gain from trade.

The terms of trade

The terms of trade are the rate at which exports exchange for imports. For both sides to gain, the rate must lie between the two countries' opportunity costs. Aria will sell a bolt of cloth only if it receives more than 0.5 crate of tea, its own cost of making cloth. Borea will buy cloth only if it pays less than 2 crates, its own cost. Any price strictly between 0.5 and 2 crates per bolt benefits both; the 1-for-1 rate in the example is one such price. Where in that range the price settles decides how the gains are shared, not whether there are any. If the price of a country's exports rises relative to its imports, its terms of trade are said to improve.

Where comparative advantage comes from

Some sources are natural: climate, land, minerals and location. Others are built: an educated workforce, accumulated capital, infrastructure and institutions. A further source is relative abundance of inputs, an idea later developed by Eli Heckscher and Bertil Ohlin: countries with plenty of labour relative to capital tend to have a comparative advantage in labour-intensive goods, and capital-rich countries in capital-intensive ones. Know-how built up in a particular industry also counts, which means comparative advantage can shift over time as countries invest and learn.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing absolute with comparative advantage: being faster at a good does not by itself mean you should specialise in it. Second, dividing the wrong way: with an output table, the opportunity cost of X is (output of Y) ÷ (output of X); with an input table, it is (hours for X) ÷ (hours for Y). Third, claiming one country can have the comparative advantage in both goods, which the reciprocal rule makes impossible when opportunity costs differ. Fourth, choosing terms of trade outside the range set by the two opportunity costs, where one side would lose.

Key takeaways

Absolute advantage means producing more from the same resources; comparative advantage means producing at a lower opportunity cost. Opportunity cost comes from the ratio of hours or outputs, and the direction of division depends on the kind of table. Each country has a comparative advantage in something. Specialising by comparative advantage raises world output, and trade at terms between the two opportunity costs lets both countries consume beyond their own frontiers.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Absolute advantage

Producing more of a good from the same resources

Or the same output with fewer resources.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Fenland a basket takes 2 hours and a rug takes 8 hours. In Galt a basket takes 3 hours and a rug takes 6 hours. What is Fenland's opportunity cost of one rug?

Question 2 of 5

Using the same Fenland and Galt data, which country has the comparative advantage in rugs?

Question 3 of 5

Fenland's opportunity cost of a rug is 4 baskets and Galt's is 2 baskets. Which price would let both countries gain from trading rugs for baskets?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement correctly defines comparative advantage?

Question 5 of 5

After specialising and trading, a country consumes a bundle that lies outside its own production possibilities frontier. What does this show?

← Previous topicNext topic →