Macroeconomics › Section G · Economic growth › Topic G.3

The components of economic growth

Growth in output per worker has three main ingredients: more and better equipment, more skilled workers, and better ideas about how to produce. Growth accounting asks how much each one contributes, and its answer is surprising.

Three ingredients

The previous topic, "Labor productivity and growth", introduced the aggregate production function, which links an economy's inputs to its output. Per worker, it says that output depends on three things: physical capital per worker, human capital per worker, and technology. This topic looks at each ingredient, at how economists estimate the share of growth each explains, and at the conditions that encourage all three. Physical and human capital both come from investment, giving up something today for more output later; technology behaves differently, and that difference matters a great deal.

Physical capital

Physical capital is the stock of produced goods used to make other goods: machines, factories, offices, computers, software, vehicles, and public infrastructure such as roads, ports, power grids and water systems. It can raise productivity in two ways. The quantity can rise, as when a delivery firm buys more vans of the same kind. The quality can rise, as when it replaces old vans with ones that carry more and break down less. Building capital takes investment, which must be financed by saving. Capital also wears out, so part of each year's investment just replaces what has depreciated before the stock can grow.

Human capital

Human capital is the knowledge, skills, experience and health that make workers productive. It grows through schooling, apprenticeships, on-the-job training and better health care. Like physical capital, it requires investment now for a return later: a student gives up years of earnings, and a firm pays for training, expecting higher output afterwards. Research in many countries finds that each extra year of schooling is associated with noticeably higher earnings, which is one sign of its productivity. Human capital also helps people use new equipment and invent better methods, so it reinforces the other two ingredients.

Technology in the broad sense

To economists, technology means every improvement in how inputs are turned into output. It includes new products, such as vaccines or smartphones, and new processes, such as drought-resistant seeds. It also includes new ways of organising work: the moving assembly line, just-in-time stock control, container shipping, or online marketplaces that match buyers and sellers. Better management and better institutions count too. Technology is unusual because an idea, once discovered, can be used by many people at the same time without being used up. A new machine serves one worker; a better method can serve millions.

Capital deepening

Capital deepening is a rise in the amount of capital per worker. It applies to both kinds of capital. Physical capital deepening means each worker has more or better equipment; human capital deepening means the average worker is better educated or trained. Because the aggregate production function is written per worker, deepening is what raises output per worker. If the capital stock grows only as fast as the workforce, capital per worker is unchanged and there is no deepening: the economy is simply equipping new workers as well as the old ones.

Worked example: capital per worker

Over five years, a hypothetical economy's physical capital stock rises from $2.0 trillion to $2.3 trillion, while employment rises from 40 million to 42 million. 1. Capital per worker at the start: \(2.0 \times 10^{12} \div (40 \times 10^{6}) = 50{,}000\) dollars. 2. At the end: \(2.3 \times 10^{12} \div (42 \times 10^{6}) \approx 54{,}760\) dollars. 3. Capital deepening: \(54{,}760 \div 50{,}000 - 1 \approx 9.5\%\). 4. Check: the capital stock grew 15% but the workforce grew 5%, so capital per worker grew by roughly the difference, about 10%. Had employment risen 15% as well, there would have been no deepening.

Growth accounting

Growth accounting, developed in the 1950s, splits the growth of output per worker into parts. A common form weights each input's growth by its share of income:

g_y = \alpha\, g_k + (1 - \alpha)\, g_h + g_A

Here \(g_y\) is growth of output per worker, \(g_k\) of physical capital per worker, and \(g_h\) of human capital per worker. The weight \(\alpha\) is capital's share of income, often about 0.3 in rich economies. Economists can measure the first three rates roughly. The part left over, \(g_A\), cannot be measured directly, so it is calculated as a residual and attributed to technology. It is often called total factor productivity growth, or the Solow residual, after Robert Solow.

Worked example: finding the residual

In a hypothetical economy, output per worker grows 2.4% a year, physical capital per worker 3.0%, and human capital per worker 0.5%. Capital's share is \(\alpha = 0.3\). 1. Physical capital contributes \(0.3 \times 3.0 = 0.9\) percentage points. 2. Human capital contributes \(0.7 \times 0.5 = 0.35\) points. 3. The residual is \(2.4 - 0.9 - 0.35 = 1.15\) points. 4. Share from technology: \(1.15 \div 2.4 \approx 48\%\). 5. Check: \(0.9 + 0.35 + 1.15 = 2.4\). Notice that capital per worker grew faster than output, yet it explains under two-fifths of the growth, because each point of capital growth adds only 0.3 points of output.

What growth accounting finds

Studies of the US economy usually reach three conclusions. First, technology is the largest single source of growth: in a famous 1957 study, Solow attributed roughly seven-eighths of the rise in US output per hour from 1909 to 1949 to technical change, and later studies still credit measured capital with half or less. Second, human capital matters at least as much as machines. Western Europe lost vast amounts of physical capital in the Second World War, yet its skilled workers and know-how lifted output above pre-war levels by the early 1950s. Third, the ingredients work together: educated workers create new ideas, new ideas need new equipment, and new equipment needs training.

A healthy climate for growth

The ingredients grow fastest where people expect to keep the rewards. Competitive markets give workers a reason to gain skills and firms a reason to invest and adopt better methods, while secure property and enforceable contracts protect those gains. Governments also play a large part. They fund schooling, build infrastructure, support basic research, and grant patents so inventors can profit from new ideas. Openness to trade spreads technology across borders. Some countries, such as Mauritius, have used special economic zones with low trade barriers to attract investment. The topic "Policies to improve living standards" returns to these choices.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing capital growth with capital deepening: if workers grow as fast as capital, capital per worker does not change. Second, forgetting the weight \(\alpha\) in growth accounting: 3% growth in capital per worker adds about 0.9 points, not 3 points. Third, treating the residual as precisely measured technology. It is whatever the measured inputs fail to explain, so measurement errors end up in it too. Fourth, counting only machines as capital: skills and health are capital as well. Fifth, thinking technology means only gadgets, when new ways of organising work count too.

Key takeaways

Output per worker grows through physical capital, human capital and technology. Physical and human capital require investment now for output later, and capital deepening is a rise in capital per worker. Technology covers products, processes and ways of organising, and ideas can be shared without being used up. Growth accounting weights input growth by income shares, \(g_y = \alpha g_k + (1 - \alpha) g_h + g_A\), and calls the unexplained part total factor productivity growth. In the US, that residual is usually the largest source of growth. Markets, secure property and supportive public policy create the climate in which all three ingredients grow.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Physical capital

Produced goods used in production, including infrastructure

Raised by more quantity or better quality.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An economy's capital stock grows 6% while its number of workers grows 6%. What happens to capital per worker?

Question 2 of 5

Output per worker grows 3.0%, physical capital per worker 2.0%, human capital per worker 1.0%, and capital's share is 0.3. What is the growth accounting residual?

Question 3 of 5

Why do economists describe the growth accounting residual as a measure of technology with some caution?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is an example of technology in the broad sense economists use?

Question 5 of 5

After the Second World War destroyed much of Western Europe's physical capital, output was back above pre-war levels by the early 1950s. What lesson do economists usually draw?

← Previous topicNext topic →