Macroeconomics › Section E · Elasticity › Topic E.3

Elasticity and pricing

Elasticity stops being a formula the moment someone sets a price: it explains why bumper harvests can leave farmers poorer, how far firms can pass costs on, why oil prices spike and settle, how airlines sort their passengers - and, most surprisingly, why writing 'sellers pay this tax' on a law changes nothing about who really does.

The puzzles elasticity answers

Three facts look bizarre without elasticity. A record harvest can leave grain farmers poorer. A 10% fare rise can fill a transit authority's budget - while emptying some riders' pockets. And a tax legally written on producers can be paid, in effect, mostly by consumers. What unites them: the question in each case is not which way price and quantity move - the laws of demand and supply settle that - but by how much. This topic puts that measure to work, ending with the question behind every tax debate: who really bears it?

The farm paradox

Staple crops like wheat have inelastic demand: people buy nearly the same bread whatever the price. So when an excellent harvest shifts supply sharply right, price must fall a long way before buyers take much more - and because quantity rises proportionally less than price falls, total revenue drops. The farmer's reward for growing more is a lower income. This is not a curiosity: it is one reason many governments have historically supported farm prices, and why 'fantastic weather' can be bad news in the grain belt. The revenue test is the whole explanation - no psychology needed.

Can firms pass costs on to consumers?

When a café's costs rise, can it simply raise prices? Elasticity decides. The more inelastic demand is, the larger the share of the cost passed on: customers grumble and pay. With elastic demand, a price rise loses so many customers that the firm absorbs much of the cost itself. Coffee chains facing a bean-price surge pass on part of it, and how much depends on how elastic their customers are (and on what rivals do). Pass-through is an elasticity statement disguised as a pricing decision.

Oil: spikes and slow cures

Oil markets show elasticity's clock. In the short run, demand is inelastic - commutes continue - and supply is inelastic too - new wells take years. Two inelastic curves mean small disruptions cause large price spikes, as the oil shocks of the 1970s and 2022 demonstrated. But elasticities are not constants: as years pass, drivers trade toward efficient cars, homes and industry switch fuels, and new wells come online. Demand and supply both grow more elastic, the price premium erodes, and the market adjusts. So a short-run spike overstates how far prices stay high in the long run.

Sin taxes: revenue and behaviour

Taxes on cigarettes and alcohol sit on deliberately inelastic demand, and that is the design. Revenue is reliable - quantity falls little - and consumption does fall, modestly, which serves the policy's health aim. The behaviour change is not evenly spread: studies suggest young smokers respond more to price than long-committed adults, so a given price rise cuts youth smoking by a larger percentage. Note the dual goal and its tension: the more successful the tax is at cutting use, the less revenue it eventually raises - an elasticity trade-off every legislator inherits.

Price discrimination: sorting by elasticity

Firms that can tell their customers apart - or make them reveal themselves - charge each group what its elasticity allows. Student and senior discounts: those groups are price-sensitive (elastic), so a lower price fills otherwise empty seats. Early-bird fares and advance purchase discounts: flexible travellers self-identify as elastic. Airlines charging walk-up prices: business travellers with inelastic demand pay them. The pattern is one rule: the fewer alternatives and the more urgency, the higher the price charged. Separating markets is what makes it work - if the groups can resell to each other, the sorting collapses.

Worked example: transit fares and spillovers

A transit authority faces the revenue test with a twist: ridership has spillovers. Suppose a metro carries 800,000 riders a day at $1.50 and the demand elasticity is about 0.4. As a quick approximation, quantity falls by elasticity times the price change: a 10% fare rise cuts ridership by about 4%, roughly 32,000 riders, while raising daily revenue from $1.2 million to about $1.27 million. Inelastic demand means higher fares fund the system; but each lost rider may be back on the roads, adding congestion, or be a low-income commuter with no alternative. Fare policy is a value-laden use of an elasticity estimate - the number advises, it does not decide.

Tax incidence: who really bears a tax

When a tax is written on sellers, is it sellers who pay? Almost never all of them. A tax drives a wedge: buyers pay one price, sellers receive that price minus the tax, and the traded quantity falls. Where the wedge lands is decided by elasticities, not by the law's wording: the side of the market with fewer options - the more inelastic side - bears the larger share, because it can less easily escape by trading less. That is tax incidence. This is why cigarette taxes fall largely on smokers (inelastic demand), while a tax on some easily-substituted product gets absorbed more by sellers.

Worked example: a tax on honey

Return to the honey market: \(Q_d = 120 - 10P\), \(Q_s = 20 + 10P\), equilibrium $5 and 70 jars. A tax of $2 per jar is legally levied on sellers, so sellers now receive \(P - 2\) when buyers pay \(P\): supply becomes \(Q_s = 20 + 10(P - 2) = 10P\). 1. New equilibrium: \(120 - 10P = 10P\), so \(P = 6\), \(Q = 60\). 2. Buyers now pay $6 (up $1); sellers keep \(6 - 2 = 4\) (down $1). 3. The burden splits 50/50, $1 each, even though the law said sellers pay. 4. Tax revenue: \(2 \times 60 = 120\) dollars; the 10 jars no longer traded create a deadweight loss of \(\frac{1}{2} \times 2 \times 10 = 10\) dollars. 5. Note the slopes are symmetric here; with more inelastic demand, buyers would bear more than half.

Estimating elasticities

Where do the numbers come from? Economists estimate elasticities statistically, separating the price effect from everything else moving quantities at the same time - incomes, weather, rival prices - a hard identification problem that modern methods attack. Online retailers do the opposite: randomised price experiments show different shoppers different prices and watch responses directly, measuring elasticity in days. Both routes deliver the same product: a local number with an uncertainty band, not a law of nature.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the legal taxpayer bears the tax - incidence follows elasticities, not legislation. Second, treating an elasticity as global: it is local, valid near the observed prices, and shaky for large swings or brand-new products. Third, forgetting the sin-tax paradox: the better the tax works, the less it collects in the long run. Fourth, calling every price difference 'discrimination' without the mechanism: it only works when markets can be separated and resale prevented. Fifth, reading the farm paradox as farmers' bad luck: it is a demand property - inelastic - and under elastic demand the same harvest would raise revenue.

Key takeaways

Elasticity turns the revenue test into policy. Inelastic staple demand makes bumper harvests cut farm revenue. Firms pass costs through only as far as demand allows; inelastic short-run oil markets spike prices that long-run adjustment erodes. Sin taxes ride inelastic demand for reliable revenue while modestly cutting use - youth most of all. Price discrimination sorts customers by elasticity: discounts for the elastic, walk-up prices for the urgent. Transit fare rises fund systems but push riders onto roads. And tax incidence: a tax wedge lands on whichever side is more inelastic, regardless of who legally pays - the honey example split a $2 tax 50/50 between buyers and sellers purely by the curves' symmetry. Elasticity estimates are local, uncertain and indispensable.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Farm paradox

A bumper harvest lowers total farm revenue because staple demand is inelastic

Price falls more than quantity rises.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why can a record wheat harvest leave grain farmers with lower total revenue?

Question 2 of 5

Why did small oil supply disruptions in the 1970s and 2022 produce large price spikes?

Question 3 of 5

In the honey market (Qd = 120 - 10P, Qs = 20 + 10P, equilibrium $5), a $2 tax on sellers shifts supply so buyers pay $6 and sellers keep $4. What does this show?

Question 4 of 5

According to the incidence rule, a cigarette tax is borne mostly by whom?

Question 5 of 5

A metro with 800,000 daily riders at $1.50 and elasticity about 0.4 raises fares 10%. What happens?

← Previous topicNext topic →