Macroeconomics › Section P · Exchange rates and international capital flows › Topic P.4

Exchange rate policies

Every country must decide how much to let the market set the value of its money. The choices run from a free float to giving up a national currency altogether, and each one trades exchange-rate stability against control over interest rates.

A spectrum of choices

Exchange-rate policies sit along a spectrum. At one end is a floating exchange rate, set entirely by the foreign exchange market. Next comes a soft peg, where the market usually sets the rate but the central bank steps in when it moves too far or too fast. Then a hard peg, where the central bank fixes the rate and defends it. At the far end is a merged currency, where a country uses another country's money or shares one with its neighbours. The US dollar, the euro and the yen float. In practice the categories blur, so a regime is judged by how it behaves.

Floating rates: freedom and volatility

A floating rate adjusts on its own. If a country has higher inflation, faster productivity growth or a sudden capital outflow, the exchange rate moves to reflect it, as any price would. The central bank keeps full control of interest rates and needs no large reserves. The cost is volatility: the previous topic showed how swings hurt exporters and banks. Milton Friedman argued in 1962 that floating need not mean unstable, because a rate that is free to move stays fairly steady when the policies and conditions behind it are steady.

How a peg is defended

To hold a rate the market would not choose, a central bank must itself make up any shortfall or surplus of its currency at that rate. If the peg is stronger than the market rate, there is excess supply, so the bank buys its own currency, paying with foreign exchange reserves, mainly dollars and euros. If the peg is weaker, there is excess demand, so it creates new currency and sells it, piling up reserves. It can also use interest rates: higher rates attract buyers and support the currency, while lower rates weaken it. Either way, the peg takes over tools that would otherwise serve domestic goals.

Worked example: the cost of a peg

Suppose, hypothetically, that demand for a country's crown is \(Q_d = 30 - 40p\) and supply is \(Q_s = 6 + 40p\), in billions of crowns a day, where \(p\) is dollars per crown. 1. Market rate: \(30 - 40p = 6 + 40p\), so \(p = 0.30\). 2. The government pegs at $0.35. Then \(Q_d = 16\) and \(Q_s = 20\), an excess supply of 4 billion crowns. 3. The central bank must buy 4 billion crowns a day, spending \(4 \times 0.35 = 1.4\) billion dollars of reserves. 4. At a weaker peg of $0.25, \(Q_d = 20\) and \(Q_s = 16\), so it must sell 4 billion new crowns a day, gaining $1.0 billion of reserves. 5. Check: a strong peg drains reserves; a weak one expands the money supply.

Soft pegs and their risks

A soft peg, often called a managed float, aims to smooth sharp moves without fixing the rate. The risk is that traders start guessing when the central bank will act, and their bets can create the very swings it wants to avoid. The Swiss National Bank capped the franc at 1.20 per euro from September 2011, then dropped the cap without warning in January 2015, and the franc jumped sharply that day. Since the 1990s many economists have argued for either a clear float or a firm fix rather than the middle.

Hard pegs and currency boards

A hard peg commits to one fixed rate. Saudi Arabia has held the riyal at 3.75 per dollar since 1986. Hong Kong has linked its dollar to the US dollar since 1983 and keeps it between 7.75 and 7.85 per US dollar. Hong Kong runs a currency board, backing its money with US dollar reserves, and Saudi Arabia also holds large reserves. A hard peg removes everyday uncertainty, but if the rate drifts far from where the market would put it, holding it can become impossible. Argentina fixed one peso to one dollar from 1991, then abandoned the peg in 2002 amid a deep crisis, and the peso lost most of its value.

Speculative attacks

A peg is only as strong as the reserves and political will behind it. If traders believe a currency is overvalued, they sell it to the central bank, which pays out reserves. Each loss of reserves makes devaluation look more likely, which brings more selling. If reserves run low or the high interest rates needed become too painful, the peg breaks. On 16 September 1992 the UK, facing heavy selling of the pound, left the European Exchange Rate Mechanism after raising interest rates sharply the same day. The Thai baht peg fell in July 1997, as the previous topic showed.

The impossible trinity

These cases reflect a general rule, the impossible trinity or trilemma. A country cannot have all three of a fixed exchange rate, free movement of capital and an independent monetary policy; it must choose two. Most large economies, including the US, keep free capital and independent policy, so they float. Hong Kong keeps a fixed rate and free capital, so its interest rates follow US rates. A country can keep a fixed rate and independent policy only by restricting capital flows, for example with capital controls or taxes on currency trades, known as Tobin taxes. Such controls are hard to enforce and can deter useful investment.

Worked example: the trilemma at work

A small country pegs its currency to the dollar and allows free capital flows. Its interest rate is 3%, the same as in the US. 1. The Federal Reserve raises US rates to 4%. 2. Investors can now earn more in the US, so they sell the small country's currency to buy dollars. 3. To stop the peg breaking, its central bank must raise its own rate to about 4% as well. 4. Suppose its economy is in a slump and needs lower rates. The peg forces the opposite. 5. Check the trinity: fixed rate and free capital were kept, so independent monetary policy was the one given up.

A merged currency

A merged currency removes exchange-rate risk completely. Ecuador has used the US dollar since 2000, and 21 European Union countries share the euro, launched in 1999 (notes and coins followed in 2002) and managed by the European Central Bank. The price is that a member cannot set its own interest rate or devalue to regain competitiveness. After 2010, Greece and other members with high debts and costs had to adjust through falling wages and prices instead, with years of very high unemployment. Ecuador has no say at all in Federal Reserve decisions.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking a peg is free: it uses up reserves or monetary policy, or both. Second, believing a country can have a fixed rate, free capital and independent monetary policy all at once. Third, assuming a soft peg always reduces volatility; rumours about intervention can add to it. Fourth, treating a hard peg as permanent; Argentina's broke in 2002. Fifth, expecting one regime to be best for all; economists disagree, and sound policies work under most of them.

Key takeaways

Regimes run from floating, through soft and hard pegs, to merged currencies. Floating rates absorb shocks and keep monetary policy free but are volatile. Pegs require a central bank to buy or sell its own currency, using reserves or interest rates, and can face speculative attacks, as the UK did in 1992. The impossible trinity says a country can have only two of a fixed rate, free capital and independent monetary policy. A merged currency ends exchange-rate risk but also national monetary policy.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Floating exchange rate

The market alone sets the rate

US dollar, euro, yen.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A country fixes its exchange rate and allows capital to move freely. According to the impossible trinity, what must it give up?

Question 2 of 5

Demand for a currency is Qd = 50 − 100p and supply is Qs = 10 + 100p, in billions, with p in dollars. The government pegs it at $0.25. What must the central bank do each day?

Question 3 of 5

Which of these is an example of a hard peg?

Question 4 of 5

Why can a central bank defending an overvalued peg eventually be forced to abandon it?

Question 5 of 5

What is the main economic cost to a country of joining a merged currency such as the euro?

← Previous topicNext topic →