Macroeconomics › Section I · Inflation › Topic I.5
Indexing and its limits
If inflation hurts mainly because some payments fail to keep up, one fix is obvious: tie those payments to a price index. Indexing protects tens of millions of Americans, from retirees to bondholders, but it is always partial, it works with a lag, and it can make inflation harder to stop.
What indexing means
A payment is indexed when it adjusts automatically with a measure of inflation, usually a price index such as the CPI. Instead of agreeing on a fixed number of dollars, the two sides in effect agree on a real amount, and the dollar figure moves with the index. Because inflation does most of its damage when one side of a deal is fixed in dollars while prices move, as the previous topic showed, indexing removes much of that harm for whoever is covered. The questions are who is covered, which index is used, and how quickly the adjustment arrives.
Indexing in private contracts
In the 1970s and 1980s many union wage contracts included a cost-of-living adjustment, or COLA, that raised pay automatically with the CPI. Some were written as the inflation rate plus a fixed amount: with a COLA of inflation plus 2%, inflation of 3.7% brings a 5.7% raise. Such clauses became much rarer once inflation fell. Long-term supply deals and commercial leases often contain escalator clauses that raise prices with an index. These protect sellers if inflation turns out higher than expected and buyers if it turns out lower, because both are locked into a real price.
Adjustable-rate loans
An adjustable-rate mortgage, or ARM, has an interest rate that resets periodically to a market benchmark plus a fixed margin. Since the old LIBOR benchmark was retired in 2023, most new US ARMs use a rate called SOFR. The benchmark is a market interest rate, not a price index, but market rates tend to rise when inflation rises, so the lender is largely protected from losing out to unexpected inflation. That is why ARMs often start at a lower rate than fixed-rate loans: the lender needs less compensation for inflation risk. The risk does not disappear, though. It passes to the borrower, whose payments rise when rates do.
Social Security and its COLA
Under amendments passed in 1972, Social Security benefits have risen automatically each year since 1975. The COLA equals the percentage rise in the CPI-W, averaged over July, August and September, compared with the same three months a year earlier. It takes effect with benefits paid in January. The COLA was 2.8% for 2026 and, as the Social Security Administration announced in October 2026, 3.6% for 2027. The maximum earnings subject to Social Security tax are indexed too, but to average wages rather than prices: $184,500 in 2026, rising to $192,300 in 2027 according to the agency's announcement.
Worked example: calculating the 2027 COLA
BLS figures for the CPI-W were 316.349, 317.306 and 318.139 for July to September 2025, and 327.104, 328.481 and 330.654 for July to September 2026. 1. Average for 2025:
2. Average for 2026:
3. Percentage rise: \(328.746 \div 317.265 - 1 \approx 3.6\%\), matching the announced COLA. 4. A retiree receiving $2,000 a month would get \(2{,}000 \times 1.036 = 2{,}072\) dollars a month from January 2027. 5. Notice the lag: prices rose through 2026, but the higher benefit arrives only in 2027.
Indexing in the tax system
Before the 1980s, US income tax brackets were fixed in dollars, so inflation pushed people into higher brackets even when their real income had not risen. A 1981 tax law indexed the brackets, the standard deduction and personal exemptions to the CPI from 1985. Since 2018 the brackets have been indexed to the chained CPI-U, which allows for substitution and usually rises slightly more slowly, so bracket thresholds grow a little more slowly than under the older index. Some figures are still not indexed: the income threshold above which a single filer's Social Security benefits become taxable has stayed at $25,000 since the 1980s, so inflation draws more retirees into that tax.
Inflation-protected bonds
The US Treasury first sold Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities, or TIPS, in 1997. A TIPS bond's principal is adjusted with the CPI-U, and it pays a fixed real interest rate every six months on the adjusted principal, so the interest payments rise with inflation too. At maturity the holder receives the adjusted principal or the original principal, whichever is larger, so deflation cannot eat into the original sum. Ordinary government bonds pay a fixed nominal rate, which once gave governments a temptation to inflate away their debts. Indexed bonds remove that temptation for the debt they cover and give savers a safe real return.
Worked example: TIPS against an ordinary bond
Suppose a one-year TIPS pays a real rate of 1.5% and an ordinary Treasury bond pays a nominal 4%, with interest paid once for simplicity. Inflation over the year is 3.7%. 1. TIPS principal: \(10{,}000 \times 1.037 = 10{,}370\) dollars. 2. TIPS interest: \(0.015 \times 10{,}370 \approx 155.55\) dollars. 3. TIPS total return: \(525.55 \div 10{,}000 \approx 5.3\%\). 4. The ordinary bond returns 4%. 5. The break-even inflation rate is about \(4\% - 1.5\% = 2.5\%\): above it the TIPS does better, below it the ordinary bond does. With 3.7% inflation, the TIPS wins. These rates are illustrative, not current market yields.
The limits of indexing
Indexing is never complete. Most private wages are not indexed, and the federal minimum wage has been $7.25 an hour since July 2009; using the CPI, it would need to be about $11.34 in September 2026 to buy what it did then, so its real value has fallen by about 36%, though many states now index their own minimum wages. Indexing also lags, as the COLA example showed, and the index may not match the person covered: retirees spend more on health care than the average CPI-W household. And a TIPS bond's yearly principal adjustment is taxed as income before it is paid.
Can indexing keep inflation going?
Some economists warn that widespread indexing makes inflation self-sustaining. If wages and contracts rise automatically with last year's inflation, then last year's inflation is built into this year's costs and prices, and slowing it becomes harder. Many economists argue that the extensive indexation in Brazil and Israel in the 1980s helped lock in very high inflation. Politically, once influential groups are protected, fewer people press for low inflation, while the unprotected, often less financially sophisticated households and small firms, bear more of the cost. Indexing treats symptoms; monetary and fiscal policy, in later topics, treat the cause.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming indexing makes inflation harmless: coverage is partial and adjustments lag. Second, thinking an adjustable-rate mortgage is indexed to the CPI: its rate follows a market benchmark such as SOFR. Third, believing the Social Security wage cap rises with prices: it follows average wages. Fourth, forgetting that the Social Security COLA uses the CPI-W, not the CPI-U. Fifth, assuming every dollar figure in the tax code is indexed: some, such as the benefit-tax thresholds, are not. Sixth, thinking TIPS always beat ordinary bonds: they win only when inflation exceeds the break-even rate.
Key takeaways
Indexing ties a payment to a price index so that it keeps its real value. Private examples include wage COLAs and escalator clauses; adjustable-rate loans track market rates rather than prices. Social Security benefits rise yearly with the CPI-W, by 2.8% for 2026 and 3.6% for 2027. Tax brackets have been indexed since 1985, now to the chained CPI-U, and TIPS have protected savers since 1997. Indexing is partial, lagged and imperfectly matched, and widespread indexing can entrench inflation and weaken opposition to it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Adjusts automatically with a price index
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A union contract gives a raise equal to CPI inflation plus 1.5%. Inflation turns out to be 4.2%. What is the raise?
Question 2 of 5
The CPI-W averages 250.0 over one July to September and 257.5 over the next. A retiree's benefit is $1,800 a month. What is the new monthly benefit after the COLA?
Question 3 of 5
A TIPS bond pays a real rate of 2%, and an ordinary Treasury bond of the same term pays 4.5%. Roughly what inflation rate would make the two equally good?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about an adjustable-rate mortgage is correct?
Question 5 of 5
Why do some economists worry that widespread indexing can make inflation harder to stop?
