Macroeconomics › Section K · The aggregate demand and aggregate supply model › Topic K.6
Keynes' law and Say's law
The short-run aggregate supply curve has a flat end, a steep end and a middle. Where aggregate demand crosses it tells you whether Keynes' law or Say's law is the better guide, and which policy questions matter most for the economy right now.
Both laws in one diagram
In "Macroeconomic views of demand and supply", Keynes' law said that demand creates its own supply, and Say's law said that supply creates its own demand. The AD/AS model can hold both views at once, because the short-run aggregate supply (SRAS) curve is not a straight line. It is nearly flat far below potential GDP, slopes upward in the middle and becomes nearly vertical around and just beyond potential. Economists divide it into three zones, named after the views that fit them best: the Keynesian zone, the intermediate zone and the neoclassical zone. The long-run aggregate supply (LRAS) line stays vertical at potential throughout.
The Keynesian zone
The Keynesian zone is the flat left-hand part of SRAS, where output is far below potential. The economy is in recession, with high cyclical unemployment and many idle machines. Firms can raise output without bidding up wages or materials, so prices hardly move. If AD shifts right here, output rises by nearly the full shift; if AD shifts left, output falls. Demand largely decides output, which is Keynes' law in action. Inflation is not the pressing worry in this zone; unemployment is.
The neoclassical zone
The neoclassical zone is the near-vertical right-hand part of SRAS, at or near potential GDP. Cyclical unemployment is low, though structural unemployment may remain. Because labour and capital are almost fully used, shifts in AD barely change output. They mainly change the price level, so extra spending turns into inflationary pressure. Output is decided by the economy's capacity, which is Say's law in action, and the only way to raise real GDP for long is for aggregate supply itself to shift right, through higher productivity, more workers or more capital.
The intermediate zone
Between the two extremes lies the upward-sloping intermediate zone. Here an AD shift changes both output and the price level by noticeable amounts. A rightward shift moves output closer to potential, lowering unemployment, but raises the price level. A leftward shift raises unemployment but eases price pressure. So in this zone unemployment and inflation tend to move in opposite directions, and policymakers face a genuine trade-off between them. That trade-off is the subject of "The Phillips curve" in the next section.
Worked example: one AD shift in three zones
A hypothetical, simplified SRAS is drawn in three straight pieces: flat at \(P = 100\) up to output 600; then \(Y = 8P - 200\) up to output 1000; then vertical at potential, 1000. AD is \(Y = A - 2P\), and a stimulus raises \(A\) by 40. 1. Keynesian zone, \(A = 750\): \(Y = 750 - 200 = 550\) at \(P = 100\). After the shift, \(Y = 590\) and \(P\) stays 100: all output. 2. Intermediate zone, \(A = 1100\): \(1100 - 2P = 8P - 200\) gives \(P = 130\), \(Y = 840\). After: \(1140 - 2P = 8P - 200\) gives \(P = 134\), \(Y = 872\): some of each. 3. Neoclassical zone, \(A = 1400\): \(1400 - 2P = 1000\) gives \(P = 200\). After: \(P = 220\) and \(Y\) stays 1000: all prices.
Using the zones as a diagnosis
The zones work as a quick diagnostic. First work out which zone the economy is in, using unemployment, how fully factories are used and how fast prices and wages are rising. That tells you which problem is most urgent and what a shift in AD would mostly do. Economists disagree about where economies usually sit. Hard-line Keynesians think economies spend much of their time in the Keynesian zone and treat the neoclassical zone as a theoretical case. Hard-line neoclassical economists think the reverse. The next two sections, starting with "Aggregate demand in Keynesian analysis" and "Building blocks of neoclassical analysis", examine each view.
Worked example: diagnosing two economies
Two hypothetical economies are considering a large tax cut. Country P has 11% unemployment, factories using about two-thirds of their capacity and almost no change in prices. Country Q has unemployment below its natural rate, firms struggling to hire and wages rising quickly. 1. Country P's idle workers and machines and stable prices place it in the Keynesian zone. 2. There, a tax cut shifts AD right and mostly raises output and jobs. 3. Country Q's stretched capacity and rising wages place it in the neoclassical zone. 4. There, the same tax cut mostly raises the price level. 5. Country Q would raise output more by policies that shift aggregate supply.
Self-correction: how fast?
The two views also differ on what happens if policy does nothing. In the model, output below potential means many unemployed workers, which eventually pushes wages and other input prices down. SRAS then shifts right until output returns to potential. Output above potential works the other way: rising wages shift SRAS left. Neoclassical economists expect this adjustment to work reasonably well. Keynesians argue that wages and prices are sticky, so the return can take years, which is the case for active policy; Keynes' line "In the long run we are all dead" makes the point.
The 2020 recession: supply or demand?
The pandemic recession of 2020 shows that real shocks can hit both sides. On the supply side, illness, lockdowns and safety fears kept many people from working, shifting SRAS left. On the demand side, people stopped travelling and eating out, and firms postponed investment, shifting AD left. The US unemployment rate reached 14.8% in April 2020 (first reported as 14.7%), the highest since the data series began in 1948, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Most economists see the recession as a mix of both shocks. Later, large policy support revived demand while supply was still constrained, which contributed to the inflation of 2021 to 2022.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating the three zones as three separate curves: they are parts of one SRAS curve. Second, mixing up the ends: the flat Keynesian zone is far below potential, and the steep neoclassical zone is close to it. Third, expecting AD stimulus to raise output much in the neoclassical zone; there it mostly raises the price level. Fourth, assuming self-correction is either instant or impossible: in the model it happens, and the debate is about speed. Fifth, labelling every recession purely a supply or purely a demand event.
Key takeaways
The SRAS curve has three zones. In the flat Keynesian zone, far below potential, AD shifts change mainly output: Keynes' law fits. In the near-vertical neoclassical zone, close to potential, AD shifts change mainly the price level, and only supply shifts raise output: Say's law fits. In the intermediate zone, AD shifts change both, so unemployment and inflation move in opposite directions. Identifying the zone is a diagnosis that guides policy. Economists agree that the economy eventually self-corrects but disagree on how quickly.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Keynesian, intermediate, neoclassical
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
The AD curve crosses the flat part of SRAS, far below potential. AD then shifts right. What happens?
Question 2 of 5
Which law does the near-vertical neoclassical zone of SRAS illustrate, and why?
Question 3 of 5
SRAS in its intermediate zone is Y = 8P − 200 and AD is Y = 1200 − 2P. What is equilibrium?
Question 4 of 5
An economy has low unemployment, firms struggling to hire and wages rising fast. Which policy would raise real GDP most for the long term?
Question 5 of 5
According to the reading, what is the main disagreement about self-correction?
