Macroeconomics › Section L · The Keynesian perspective › Topic L.2

Building blocks of Keynesian analysis and the multiplier

Why can a whole economy sit in recession with idle factories and willing workers? Keynesian analysis answers with two building blocks, weak demand and sticky wages and prices, and adds a third idea, the multiplier, which explains why spending shocks grow as they spread.

Two building blocks

Keynesian economics rests on two claims. First, aggregate demand is not automatically high enough to buy everything the economy could produce at full employment, so a recession usually starts with a fall in spending rather than a loss of productive capacity. Second, wages and prices are sticky: they adjust only slowly when demand changes, so a fall in demand shows up as lost output and jobs rather than as quickly falling prices. Between 1929 and 1933 the United States had much the same factories, workers and technology, yet output collapsed. To Keynesians, that pattern points to missing demand, not missing supply, and it challenges Say's law, the idea that supply creates its own demand.

Why wages are sticky

Suppose demand falls and every employer would need to cut pay by 5% to keep all its staff. Keynes's coordination argument notes that many workers might accept such a cut if they knew everyone else's pay and prices were falling too, but a market economy has no mechanism to arrange a simultaneous, economy-wide cut. Each group resists going first, since a lone cut makes it worse off relative to others. Employers also hesitate to cut pay because it can damage morale and productivity, and many wages are fixed by contracts or by minimum-wage laws. So when demand drops, firms tend to cut hours and jobs instead of wages.

Why prices are sticky

Some economists working in a Keynesian spirit argue that prices of goods are sticky too. Changing a price is costly: managers must study the market and decide on the new price, then update labels, catalogues, websites and billing systems. Frequent changes can also annoy customers. Economists label such repricing expenses menu costs, after a restaurant that must reprint its menus. Each cost may be small, but together they mean many firms review prices only every few months. Prices still respond to supply and demand, but the economy-wide adjustment takes time.

A macroeconomic externality

In a single market, a fall in demand creates a surplus and pushes the price down. Across the whole economy, sticky wages and prices block that adjustment, so a fall in aggregate demand leaves many labour and goods markets in surplus at the old wages and prices: unemployment and unsold output. Keynesians call this a macroeconomic externality, a case where the economy-wide outcome differs from what each market would do alone. In the AD/AS model it appears as an aggregate supply curve that is flat below potential GDP. A leftward shift of AD then lowers real GDP while the price level barely moves.

Spending becomes income

The circular flow is the starting point for the multiplier. Households sell labour and other resources to firms and spend the income on firms' output, so one person's spending is another's income. Not all income is passed on. Leakages are saving, taxes and imports, which take money out of the domestic spending stream. Injections are investment, government purchases and exports, which add to it. When injections exceed leakages, national income grows; when leakages exceed injections, it shrinks. The share of each extra dollar of income that households spend is the marginal propensity to consume, MPC, and the share they save is the marginal propensity to save, MPS, so \(MPC + MPS = 1\).

The expenditure multiplier

An extra dollar of spending is income for someone, who spends a fraction MPC of it, which is income for someone else, and so on. The total change in GDP is the sum of every round:

\Delta Y = \Delta A\,(1 + MPC + MPC^2 + \cdots) = \frac{\Delta A}{1 - MPC}

where \(\Delta A\) is the initial change in autonomous spending. The simple multiplier is therefore \(\frac{1}{1 - MPC}\), or \(\frac{1}{MPS}\). With an MPC of 0.8 the multiplier is 5; with 0.5 it is 2. The multiplier works for any change in spending, from government or private, and it works downwards as well: when investment collapsed in the early 1930s, GDP fell by more than the investment itself.

Worked example: following the rounds

A city spends an extra $20 billion on a rail project, and households' MPC is 0.75. 1. Round one: the builders and their suppliers receive $20 billion of income. 2. Round two: they spend \(0.75 \times 20 = 15\) billion dollars. 3. Round three: the recipients spend \(0.75 \times 15 = 11.25\) billion dollars. 4. After five rounds the running total is about $61.0 billion, and each round is smaller. 5. Formula: the multiplier is \(\frac{1}{1 - 0.75} = 4\), so total GDP rises by \(4 \times 20 = 80\) billion dollars. 6. Check: the rounds approach $80 billion but never exceed it, as a shrinking geometric series should.

Adding taxes and imports

The simple multiplier assumes saving is the only leakage. In reality, part of each extra dollar of income goes in tax, and part of what remains is spent on imports. Let \(t\) be the tax rate on extra income, MPC the share of after-tax income spent, and \(m\) the share of extra income spent on imports. The fraction re-spent on domestic output each round is \(MPC(1 - t) - m\), so

\text{multiplier} = \frac{1}{1 - [MPC(1 - t) - m]}

Bigger leakages mean each round shrinks faster and the multiplier is smaller. That is why multipliers in real economies are well below the simple formula's values.

Worked example: closing a gap

An economy is $60 billion below potential GDP. Households spend 80% of after-tax income, the tax rate on extra income is 25%, and 10% of extra income goes on imports. 1. Share re-spent each round: \(0.8 \times 0.75 - 0.1 = 0.5\). 2. Multiplier: \(\frac{1}{1 - 0.5} = 2\). 3. Spending needed: \(\frac{60}{2} = 30\) billion dollars, not 60. 4. Check the rounds: $30 billion, then $15 billion, then $7.5 billion, and so on, summing to $60 billion. Real estimates are uncertain: for 2009's stimulus law, the Congressional Budget Office's later reports put the multiplier on federal purchases at about 0.5 to 2.5, and one-year tax cuts for higher-income people at about 0.1 to 0.6.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, writing the simple multiplier as \(\frac{1}{MPC}\); it is \(\frac{1}{1 - MPC}\), so an MPC of 0.75 gives 4, not 1.33. Second, assuming the gap equals the spending needed; with a multiplier above 1, less initial spending closes it. Third, forgetting taxes and imports, which shrink the multiplier. Fourth, thinking the multiplier applies only to government spending; it applies to any autonomous change, including falls in investment or exports. Fifth, saying sticky wages mean wages never change; they adjust, but slowly.

Key takeaways

Keynesian analysis rests on two building blocks: recessions usually begin with too little aggregate demand, and sticky wages and prices slow the adjustment. Sticky wages come from the coordination problem, morale, contracts and minimum wages; sticky prices come from menu costs. Together they make a macroeconomic externality: a flat aggregate supply curve below potential GDP. Spending is someone's income, so a change in spending is multiplied. The simple multiplier is 1/(1 - MPC); taxes and imports make it smaller.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Keynesian building blocks

Demand can fall short of full employment; wages and prices are sticky

The two core claims.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Households spend 90 cents of each extra dollar of income, so MPC = 0.9. What is the simple expenditure multiplier?

Question 2 of 5

With an MPC of 0.8 and no taxes or imports, investment falls by $5 billion. By how much does GDP eventually fall?

Question 3 of 5

Which idea did Keynes use to explain why wages do not fall quickly in a recession?

Question 4 of 5

An economy is $40 billion below potential. Each round, half of extra income is re-spent on domestic output after taxes, saving and imports. How much extra government spending closes the gap?

Question 5 of 5

Why are real-world spending multipliers usually smaller than 1 / (1 - MPC)?

← Previous topicNext topic →