Macroeconomics › Section J · International trade and capital flows › Topic J.4

The national saving and investment identity

Why does the United States run trade deficits year after year, while Germany runs surpluses? One line of accounting answers much of it: a country's trade balance equals what it saves minus what it invests.

Trade as a macroeconomic question

The previous topic, "Trade balances and flows of financial capital", showed that a trade deficit is matched by a net inflow of financial capital. That suggests looking at the trade balance through the market for financial capital as a whole: who supplies funds, and who borrows them? The answer is the national saving and investment identity. It is called an identity because it is true by definition, in every country and every year, once the terms are measured consistently. It links the trade balance to saving by households and firms, to government budgets and to investment.

Supply and demand for financial capital

In an open economy, funds for borrowing come from two sources: private saving \(S\) by households and firms, and the net inflow of capital from abroad, which equals the trade deficit \(M - X\). Funds are demanded by two groups: firms making physical investment \(I\), in machines, buildings and software, and the government when it borrows to cover a budget deficit, \(G - T\). Here \(G\) is government spending and \(T\) is taxes minus transfer payments. Because every dollar lent is a dollar borrowed, the two sides must be equal:

S + (M - X) = I + (G - T)

Where the identity comes from

It follows from the expenditure measure of GDP in "Measuring the economy with GDP":

Y = C + I + G + (X - M)

where \(Y\) is GDP and \(C\) is consumption. Private saving is income left after taxes and consumption, \(S = Y - T - C\). 1. Subtract \(C\) and \(G\) from both sides of the GDP equation: \(Y - C - G = I + (X - M)\). 2. Add and subtract \(T\) on the left: \((Y - T - C) + (T - G) = I + (X - M)\). 3. Replace the first bracket with \(S\): \(S + (T - G) = I + (X - M)\). Moving \(X - M\) across gives the supply-and-demand form above. Strictly the identity gives net exports; adding income and transfers turns it into the current account.

National saving minus investment

Rearranging puts the trade balance on its own:

X - M = S + (T - G) - I

The term \(S + (T - G)\) is national saving: private saving plus public saving, where public saving is the budget surplus. So the trade balance is national saving minus domestic investment. A country that saves more than it invests at home has funds left over, lends them abroad and runs a trade surplus. A country that invests more than it saves must borrow the difference from abroad and runs a trade deficit. On this view the trade balance is decided by saving and investment across the whole economy, not by the fortunes of any one industry.

Terms that can switch sides

Private saving always supplies funds and investment always demands them, but the other two terms can change sides. When a government runs a budget deficit, \(G - T > 0\) and it borrows. When it runs a surplus, as the US federal government did in fiscal years 1998 to 2001, \(T - G > 0\) and public saving adds to the supply of funds. Likewise, a trade deficit brings foreign funds in, while a trade surplus sends domestic funds abroad, so a surplus country appears among the users of its own saving. Keep the signs straight and the identity always balances.

Worked example: finding the trade balance

A country has private saving of $900 billion, investment of $1,000 billion and a government budget deficit of $250 billion. 1. Public saving is the budget surplus, so \(T - G = -250\). 2. National saving: \(900 - 250 = 650\). 3. Trade balance: \(X - M = 650 - 1{,}000 = -350\), a trade deficit of $350 billion. 4. Check the supply-and-demand form: supply is \(900 + 350 = 1{,}250\) and demand is \(1{,}000 + 250 = 1{,}250\). 5. To cut the trade deficit to $200 billion with investment unchanged, national saving must rise by $150 billion: private saving rising by $150 billion, the budget deficit falling by $150 billion, or a mix of the two.

Worked example: starting from GDP

An economy has GDP of $2,000 billion, consumption of $1,300 billion, investment of $400 billion, government spending of $350 billion and net taxes of $300 billion. 1. Net exports: \(2{,}000 - 1{,}300 - 400 - 350 = -50\). 2. Private saving: \(S = 2{,}000 - 300 - 1{,}300 = 400\). 3. Public saving: \(T - G = 300 - 350 = -50\). 4. National saving minus investment: \(400 - 50 - 400 = -50\). 5. The two routes give the same trade deficit of $50 billion, as an identity must. Here private saving exactly matches investment, so the trade deficit equals the government's borrowing.

One factor at a time

The identity organises thinking about what moves the trade balance. Change one term and hold the others fixed. If investment rises, the trade deficit must rise, as in the late-1990s US technology investment boom. If private saving rises, the trade deficit must fall. If the government budget deficit widens, the trade deficit must rise. That last case is the "twin deficits" idea, and the US mid-1980s, when budget and trade deficits widened together, is the classic example. But the other terms rarely sit still. From 1998 to 2001 the federal budget was in surplus, yet the trade deficit grew, because investment rose while private saving fell.

An identity, not a theory

The identity says the terms must add up, but not which one gives way. A larger inflow of foreign capital could be matched by lower private saving, higher investment or more government borrowing. Economic theory, such as how interest rates and exchange rates respond, is needed to say which. The identity also helps explain the business cycle pattern in "Trade balances in historical context": in a recession investment usually falls more than saving, so the trade deficit tends to shrink, while a boom tends to widen it. These are tendencies, not laws, as 2020 showed.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, writing the budget term with the wrong sign: public saving is \(T - G\), negative in a deficit. Second, blaming a trade deficit on one industry or on trade policy alone; the identity says it reflects national saving and investment. Third, treating the identity as a forecast: it shows what must hold, not which term adjusts. Fourth, assuming twin deficits always move together; 1998 to 2001 is a counterexample. Fifth, forgetting that the trade deficit is part of the supply of funds, as foreign capital flowing in.

Key takeaways

In an open economy, \(S + (M - X) = I + (G - T)\): private saving plus foreign capital equals investment plus government borrowing. It follows from \(Y = C + I + G + (X - M)\). Rearranged, \(X - M = S + (T - G) - I\): the trade balance equals national saving minus domestic investment. Higher investment or a larger budget deficit, other things equal, means a larger trade deficit; higher private saving means a smaller one. The identity always holds but does not say which term adjusts.

Flashcards

Flashcard

S + (M − X) = I + (G − T)

The national saving and investment identity

Supply of funds equals demand for funds.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A country has private saving of $600 billion, investment of $700 billion and a government budget deficit of $150 billion. What is its trade balance?

Question 2 of 5

GDP is $5,000 billion, consumption $3,400 billion, investment $900 billion, government spending $1,000 billion and net taxes $800 billion. What is private saving?

Question 3 of 5

Holding private saving and the government budget fixed, what happens to the trade balance if domestic investment rises by $100 billion?

Question 4 of 5

From 1998 to 2001 the US federal budget was in surplus, yet the trade deficit grew. Which explanation fits the identity?

Question 5 of 5

What does it mean to call the national saving and investment relationship an identity?

← Previous topicNext topic →