Macroeconomics › Section C · Demand and supply › Topic C.2
Shifts in demand and supply
Prices change because curves move. Income shifts, rival prices, tastes, costs and technology all shove the demand or supply curve to a new position - and the market then finds a new equilibrium. This topic is the catalogue of what moves which curve, and in which direction.
Movement versus shift, once more
The previous topic drew the line: a change in the good's own price moves you along a curve; everything else shifts the curve itself. This topic is about those everything-elses. When economists say demand increased, they mean the whole schedule moved: at every price, buyers now want more than before. When supply decreased, sellers offer less at every price. A shifted curve produces a new equilibrium, and comparing the two crossings is how the model explains price changes in the world. The ceteris paribus assumption is what makes the shift-versus-move distinction clean: each law describes one curve while everything else is held fixed.
What shifts demand
Five families of factors move the demand curve. 1. Income: for most goods, higher income raises demand. 2. Prices of related goods: substitutes and complements, covered next. 3. Tastes and preferences: information, fashions, advertising and culture all reshape what people want. 4. Expectations about the future: expected price rises or income changes change buying today. 5. The number and composition of buyers: population growth, or a demographic wave into a product's age group, moves the whole curve. Each works the same way: anything that makes buyers want more at the same price shifts demand right; anything that makes them want less shifts it left.
Income: normal and inferior goods
For a normal good, higher income raises demand: restaurant meals, better trainers, holidays. For an inferior good, higher income lowers demand - not because quality fell, but because people graduate to preferred alternatives: instant noodles when the budget allows fresh food. The same good can be normal for one household and inferior for another, and the test is empirical: watch which way demand moves when income rises, other things equal. Note the asymmetry with price: income shifts the curve, it does not slide along it.
Related goods: substitutes and complements
Substitutes are goods used in place of each other, like tea and coffee. When coffee's price rises, some drinkers switch, and demand for tea shifts right. Complements are goods used together, like printers and ink cartridges. When printers get dearer, fewer are bought, and demand for cartridges shifts left - the cartridge's own price never moved. Recognising these links lets firms anticipate a competitor's pricing and lets a shopper see why one product's sale changes another's demand. The test: does the other good's price rise make buyers want more of this one (substitutes) or less (complements)?
What shifts supply
On the sellers' side, the shifters are: 1. Input costs: wages, raw materials, energy - cheaper inputs shift supply right. 2. Technology: better methods make more output possible from the same inputs, shifting supply right. 3. The number of sellers: new firms shift supply right, exits shift it left. 4. Expectations: expected higher prices later may make sellers hold back stock today. 5. Government policy: a producer tax or a costly regulation shifts supply left (a cost); a subsidy shifts it right (as if an input got cheaper). 6. Natural conditions: weather, disease and disasters move agricultural and resource supply. Anything that raises the cost of offering goods shifts supply left; anything that lowers it shifts supply right.
Worked example: a demand shift in the honey market
Return to the honey market from the previous topic: \(Q_d = 120 - 10P\), \(Q_s = 20 + 10P\), equilibrium $5, 70 jars. A nutrition study praises honey, and demand shifts right by 20 jars at every price: new demand \(Q_d = 140 - 10P\). 1. Set the new demand against the unchanged supply: \(140 - 10P = 20 + 10P\). 2. Solve: \(120 = 20P\), so \(P = 6\). 3. Quantity: \(Q = 20 + 10 \times 6 = 80\). 4. Check: \(Q_d = 140 - 60 = 80\) - they agree. 5. Compare equilibria: price rose from $5 to $6, quantity from 70 to 80. A rightward demand shift raises both - the standard pattern, and sellers benefit from a shift they did not cause.
Worked example: a supply shift in the same market
Now suppose demand returns to \(Q_d = 120 - 10P\) but cheaper beekeeping equipment shifts supply right by 20: \(Q_s = 40 + 10P\). 1. Set equal: \(120 - 10P = 40 + 10P\). 2. Solve: \(80 = 20P\), so \(P = 4\). 3. Quantity: \(Q = 120 - 40 = 80\). 4. Check in supply: \(Q_s = 40 + 40 = 80\). 5. Compare: price fell from $5 to $4, quantity rose from 70 to 80. A rightward supply shift lowers price and raises quantity - the mirror image of the demand case. Reverse each shift and you have the other two of the model's four basic patterns.
The four patterns
Collect the directions. Demand shifts right: higher price, higher quantity. Demand shifts left: lower price, lower quantity. Supply shifts right: lower price, higher quantity. Supply shifts left: higher price, lower quantity. Notice the asymmetry of cause: a demand shift moves price and quantity in the same direction, a supply shift in opposite directions. That asymmetry is a useful diagnostic when only one curve has moved: if price and quantity rise together, demand shifted right; if price rises while quantity falls, supply shifted left.
When both curves shift
Real events often shift both curves at once, and then one variable's direction can become uncertain. Take the two shifts from the worked examples happening together: demand \(140 - 10P\), supply \(40 + 10P\). Equilibrium: \(100 = 20P\), so \(P = 5\) and \(Q = 90\). Quantity clearly rose, from 70 to 90 - both shifts pushed it up. Price? Back to exactly $5 - each shift pushed it a different way, and they happened to cancel. The general rule: when both curves shift, the variable the two shifts push in the same direction moves for sure, and the variable they push in opposite directions depends on which shift is bigger. You cannot read the answer off the words; you need the sizes.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, shifting a curve for its own price change - price moves along curves, never shifts them. Second, inventing a shift where there is none: a hot summer raising ice-cream demand is a taste/number-of-buyers effect, but 'the price of ice cream rose' is not a shifter. Third, getting substitutes and complements backwards: a rise in the other good's price raises demand for a substitute and lowers it for a complement. Fourth, confusing a movement of the supply curve with movement along it when costs change - a wage rise shifts supply, it does not slide along it. Fifth, expecting a definite answer when both curves shift: identify which variable the shifts oppose, and say it depends on magnitudes.
Key takeaways
Anything other than the good's own price shifts curves. Demand shifts with income (normal goods up, inferior goods down), with prices of related goods (substitutes' price up raises demand, complements' price up lowers it), with tastes, expectations and the number of buyers. Supply shifts with input costs, technology, seller numbers, expectations, taxes and subsidies, and natural conditions. The four patterns: demand right raises price and quantity, demand left lowers both, supply right lowers price and raises quantity, supply left does the reverse. Demand shifts move price and quantity together; supply shifts move them oppositely. When both curves shift, one direction may be ambiguous until the sizes are known - as when demand and supply both grew and price returned to $5.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Other factors shift the whole curve; own price moves along it
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Consumers' incomes rise, and demand for instant noodles falls. Instant noodles are what kind of good for these consumers?
Question 2 of 5
The price of printers rises sharply. What happens in the ink cartridge market?
Question 3 of 5
In the honey market, Qd = 120 - 10P and Qs = 20 + 10P. Cheaper equipment shifts supply to Qs = 40 + 10P. What is the new equilibrium?
Question 4 of 5
In a market, price has risen while quantity has fallen. Assuming only one curve moved, which curve shifted, and which way?
Question 5 of 5
Demand and supply both shift right at once. What can be said about the new equilibrium?
