Macroeconomics › Section H · Unemployment › Topic H.3

Short-run causes: cyclical unemployment

When a recession hits, millions of people who would gladly work at the going wage cannot find jobs. Explaining why requires one key idea: wages adjust upward easily but resist falling.

A puzzle for supply and demand

The topic "Patterns of unemployment" showed that unemployment rises sharply in recessions and falls in expansions. The basic labour market model from the earlier topic "Demand and supply in labor markets" struggles to explain this. In that model, if fewer workers are wanted, the wage falls until everyone willing to work at the new wage finds a job. Nobody is left involuntarily without work. Yet in every recession, many unemployed people would happily take jobs like those their employed friends hold, at similar pay, and cannot get them. This topic explains that gap between the simple model and the real world.

Cyclical unemployment

Over a few months or years, the number of hours people want to work at a given wage changes little, so the labour supply curve is fairly stable. Labour demand is different. Firms hire according to how much they expect to sell. When they expect a boom, demand for labour shifts right; when they expect a recession, it shifts left. Cyclical unemployment is the unemployment caused by these swings in the business cycle. It is the part of unemployment that rises when the economy moves from expansion into recession and falls again as the economy recovers.

Voluntary or involuntary?

One possible explanation is that the unemployed simply want more than the going wage. Someone who will work only at $35 an hour, when similar jobs pay $20, may tell the survey they are looking for work. Economists would call that person voluntarily unemployed. A few people fit this description, but the evidence suggests they are a small share. Most of the unemployed in a recession are involuntarily unemployed: they are willing to work at the current wage for their skills, but employers are not hiring. Explaining involuntary unemployment requires wages that do not fall to clear the market.

Laws and contracts

Some wages cannot legally or contractually be cut. A minimum wage makes pay below a floor illegal, and a union contract may fix wages for several years. But these cover too few US workers to explain economy-wide stickiness. BLS data show that in 2025 only about 1% of hourly-paid workers earned at or below the federal minimum of $7.25, although many states set higher minimums. Union members were 10.0% of wage and salary workers in 2025, and about 11.2% were covered by union contracts. Economists have therefore looked for reasons why wages are sticky downward across ordinary, non-union jobs too.

Why firms avoid cutting pay

Several theories point the same way. Implicit contracts: employers informally promise steady pay in bad times, and workers accept smaller raises in good times, a kind of insurance. Efficiency wages: paying above the market rate raises effort and cuts costly turnover, so a pay cut can lose more in productivity than it saves. Adverse selection: an across-the-board cut drives away the best workers, who have the most outside offers, so firms prefer to choose whom to lay off. Insider-outsider: experienced staff run the firm and train newcomers, and cutting their pay damages morale. Relative wages: workers resist cuts that leave them behind others. Interview studies of managers support morale-based explanations.

The sticky-wage diagram in words

Picture a labour market in equilibrium at wage \(W_0\) and employment \(Q_0\). A recession shifts labour demand to the left. With flexible wages, the wage would slide down to a new equilibrium, employment would fall a little, and some people would leave the market voluntarily at the lower wage. With wages stuck at \(W_0\), the quantity of labour supplied stays at \(Q_0\), but firms now want only \(Q_2\), a smaller amount. The gap between \(Q_0\) and \(Q_2\) is people willing to work at the going wage who cannot find jobs: involuntary, cyclical unemployment.

Worked example: a recession with sticky wages

In a hypothetical labour market, quantity demanded is \(Q_d = 120 - 4W\) and quantity supplied is \(Q_s = 20 + 6W\), in thousands of workers, with \(W\) in dollars per hour. 1. Equilibrium: \(120 - 4W = 20 + 6W\), so \(W = 10\) and \(Q = 80\). 2. A recession shifts demand to \(Q_d = 100 - 4W\). 3. If wages stay at $10: \(Q_d = 60\) and \(Q_s = 80\), so 20,000 people are involuntarily unemployed and employment falls by 20,000. 4. If wages were flexible: \(100 - 4W = 20 + 6W\) gives \(W = 8\) and \(Q = 68\). Employment would fall by only 12,000, and nobody willing to work at $8 would lack a job.

Worked example: a real wage cut without a pay cut

Sticky wages are usually sticky in dollar terms. Suppose a worker earns $20.00 an hour and prices rise 4% over the year while her pay stays fixed. 1. Her real wage, measured in start-of-year prices, becomes \(20.00 \div 1.04 \approx 19.23\) dollars. 2. That is a real cut of about 3.8%, with no cut on her pay slip. 3. Interpret: mild inflation lets real wages fall gradually, which makes the labour market adjust more easily. 4. When inflation is close to zero, real wages can fall only through nominal cuts, which firms resist. Some economists see this as one reason for keeping inflation low but above zero.

Booms are different

The stickiness is one-sided. When labour demand shifts right in an expansion, nobody objects to a pay rise, so wages climb and employment increases fairly smoothly towards the new equilibrium. In a downturn, the wage stays put and the adjustment falls on jobs instead. This asymmetry helps explain why unemployment can jump quickly in a recession but takes years to come back down. Because cyclical unemployment comes from too little demand for goods and services, the main remedies are policies that support total spending, covered later in "Using fiscal policy against recession and inflation" and "Monetary policy and economic outcomes".

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming that everyone counted as unemployed has turned down available jobs; most are involuntarily unemployed. Second, blaming sticky wages mainly on the minimum wage or unions, which cover a small share of US workers. Third, thinking sticky wages mean wages never change; they rise readily but resist falling. Fourth, confusing nominal and real wages: a fixed dollar wage is a falling real wage when prices rise. Fifth, treating cyclical unemployment as permanent; it shrinks as demand recovers, though the recovery can be slow.

Key takeaways

Cyclical unemployment is the rise in unemployment caused by recessions, when expected sales fall and labour demand shifts left. With flexible wages the market would clear, but wages are sticky downward. Minimum wages and union contracts explain only a little of this in the US. Implicit contracts, efficiency wages, adverse selection, insider-outsider effects and concern for relative pay explain why firms lay workers off instead of cutting everyone's pay. The result is involuntary unemployment: at the stuck wage, quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded. Wages rise easily in booms, so the adjustment is asymmetric.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Cyclical unemployment

Unemployment caused by the business cycle

Rises in recessions, falls in expansions.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Labour demand is Qd = 200 − 5W and supply is Qs = 50 + 10W (thousands; W in $ per hour). Equilibrium is W = $10. A recession shifts demand to Qd = 170 − 5W, but the wage stays at $10. How many workers are involuntarily unemployed?

Question 2 of 5

Why do economists say the minimum wage and union contracts cannot explain most downward wage stickiness in the US?

Question 3 of 5

A firm facing falling sales lays off 10% of its staff instead of cutting everyone's pay by 10%, fearing its best workers would leave. Which theory does this illustrate?

Question 4 of 5

A worker's pay stays at $25.00 an hour while prices rise 5%. About what is her real wage in start-of-year prices?

Question 5 of 5

Why can unemployment rise quickly in a recession but fall only slowly afterwards, according to the sticky-wage view?

← Previous topicNext topic →