Microeconomics › Section S · International trade › Topic S.2
Gains from trade when one country is better at everything
If a rich, highly productive country can make every good more cheaply in terms of labour, why would it trade with a poorer one? Ricardo's answer, that both still gain, is one of the most surprising and most tested results in economics.
The puzzle
High-income countries usually have well-trained workers, plenty of machinery and up-to-date technology, so they can often make almost every good with fewer workers than a low-income country. It seems to follow that they have nothing to gain from trading with less productive economies, and that the poorer country cannot compete at all. Both conclusions are wrong. The previous topic showed that trade rests on comparative advantage, which is about opportunity cost. A country can be better at everything in absolute terms, but it cannot have a lower opportunity cost in everything.
Relative productivity
There is a second way to find comparative advantage that is handy when one country leads in every good. Compare how big its lead is in each good. Suppose a worker in Ostra makes 6 phones or 12 shirts a month, while a worker in Pelan makes 1 phone or 6 shirts. Ostra is 6 times as productive in phones but only 2 times as productive in shirts. Its comparative advantage lies where its lead is largest: phones. Pelan's comparative advantage lies where its disadvantage is smallest: shirts. This gives the same answer as comparing opportunity costs, because both methods compare ratios.
Worked example: finding the advantages
Use the Ostra and Pelan output table. 1. Absolute advantage: Ostra makes more of both goods per worker (6 against 1 phones, 12 against 6 shirts), so it has the absolute advantage in both. 2. Opportunity cost of a phone: Ostra gives up \(12 \div 6 = 2\) shirts; Pelan gives up \(6 \div 1 = 6\) shirts. 3. Opportunity cost of a shirt: Ostra gives up 0.5 phone; Pelan gives up only \(\frac{1}{6}\) phone. 4. Conclusion: Ostra has the comparative advantage in phones, Pelan in shirts. 5. Check with relative productivity: Ostra's lead is 6 times in phones and 2 times in shirts, so phones again. Pelan is worse at both goods but still has the lower opportunity cost in one of them.
Worked example: moving workers
Each country has 100 workers and starts with half on each good. Ostra makes 300 phones and 600 shirts; Pelan makes 50 phones and 300 shirts. World total: 350 phones and 900 shirts. 1. Ostra moves 10 workers from shirts to phones: phones rise by 60, shirts fall by 120. 2. Pelan moves 30 workers from phones to shirts: phones fall by 30, shirts rise by 180. 3. New output: Ostra 360 phones and 480 shirts; Pelan 20 phones and 480 shirts. 4. World total: 380 phones and 960 shirts. 5. Check: shifting labour towards comparative advantage raised world output of both goods, by 30 phones and 60 shirts, with no new resources at all.
Sharing the gains
Higher world output only helps if trade spreads it. Ostra's own cost of a phone is 2 shirts and Pelan's is 6, so any rate between them benefits both. Try 1 phone for 4 shirts, and let Ostra export 40 phones for 160 shirts. Ostra ends with 320 phones and 640 shirts, more of both than its starting 300 and 600. Pelan ends with 60 phones and 320 shirts, more of both than its starting 50 and 300. The less productive country gains even though it is worse at everything, and the more productive country gains even though it could have made shirts itself.
Ricardo's own example
Ricardo made the same point with England and Portugal, cloth and wine. In his numbers, a quantity of cloth took the labour of 100 men for a year in England and 90 in Portugal; a quantity of wine took 120 in England and 80 in Portugal. Portugal needed less labour for both. Yet in England the wine cost \(120 \div 100 = 1.2\) units of cloth, while in Portugal it cost \(80 \div 90 \approx 0.89\). So Portugal had the comparative advantage in wine and England in cloth, and Ricardo concluded that both countries would gain if Portugal exported wine and England exported cloth.
The same logic at a smaller scale
Think of a hospital's best surgeon who also happens to file paperwork faster than any clerk. If she spends an hour filing, the hospital loses an hour of surgery, which is enormously valuable, so her opportunity cost of filing is very high. The clerk is slower at filing but gives up little to do it. Even though the surgeon has an absolute advantage in both tasks, the hospital does better when she operates and the clerk files. Time is the scarce resource: being better at everything does not give anyone more hours in which to do it all.
Wages and the low-wage worry
A common fear runs the other way: high-wage countries cannot compete with low-wage ones. But wages largely reflect productivity. Pelan's workers earn less because they produce less per hour, so Pelan is not cheaper at everything; it is cheaper only in the good where its productivity gap is smallest. Ostra's higher wages are matched by higher output per worker. Trade between them follows comparative advantage, not wage levels alone. This is why rich and poor countries trade with each other on a large scale, and why both can raise their living standards by doing so.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, concluding that a country with an absolute advantage in everything has no reason to trade: it gains by focusing where its lead is largest. Second, thinking the less productive country cannot export anything: it exports the good where its disadvantage is smallest. Third, comparing raw output across countries instead of comparing ratios within each country. Fourth, assuming every trade rate helps both sides: the rate must lie between the two opportunity costs. Fifth, treating low wages as proof that a country is cheaper at producing every good.
Key takeaways
A country can hold an absolute advantage in every good but a comparative advantage in at most one of two goods. Its comparative advantage lies where its productivity lead is largest; its partner's lies where its disadvantage is smallest. Moving resources towards comparative advantage raises world output of both goods, and trade at a rate between the two opportunity costs lets both countries consume more of both. Ricardo's England and Portugal example made this point in 1817, and the same logic applies to people dividing tasks.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Producing every good with fewer resources than a partner
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A worker in Tarn makes 12 bowls or 4 lamps a week. A worker in Ulm makes 3 bowls or 2 lamps. Which good should Ulm export?
Question 2 of 5
Tarn's opportunity cost of a lamp is 3 bowls and Ulm's is 1.5 bowls. Which rate lets both gain when Ulm sells lamps to Tarn?
Question 3 of 5
Why can a country with an absolute advantage in every good still gain from trade?
Question 4 of 5
Ricardo's Portugal needed less labour than England for both cloth and wine. Why did he say Portugal should export wine?
Question 5 of 5
A worker in Pelan earns far less than a worker in Ostra. What does the comparative-advantage model suggest about this gap?
