Microeconomics › Section G · Production, costs, and industry structure › Topic G.1

Explicit and implicit costs, accounting and economic profit

Ask an accountant whether a business is making money and you get one answer; ask an economist and you may get another - often lower. The difference is what the owner's own time and money could have earned elsewhere, and ignoring it quietly bankrupts people whose books look healthy.

Two kinds of cost

A firm's costs come in two currencies. Explicit costs are actual payments to someone else: wages, rent, materials, utilities - money that leaves the business with a receipt attached. Implicit costs are the opportunity costs of resources the owner already has and uses without paying anyone: the salary the owner could have earned working elsewhere, the interest her savings could have earned instead of being tied up in the business, the rent her own building could have fetched from another tenant. No cash changes hands, but each is a real cost of keeping the resources where they are. Economic cost counts both; a receipt is not the test of a cost.

Accounting profit versus economic profit

The two cost lists produce two profits. Both start from total revenue: price multiplied by units sold. Accounting profit subtracts only explicit costs from revenue - it is what the books show and what income tax is based on. Economic profit subtracts explicit and implicit costs:

\text{Economic profit} = \text{Revenue} - \text{Explicit costs} - \text{Implicit costs}

Because implicit costs cannot be negative, economic profit is never larger than accounting profit, and it is smaller whenever the owner contributes anything. The gap between them is the value of everything the owner quietly contributes for free - and the gap is exactly where the economist's different verdict hides.

Worked example: two profits for one designer

A graphic designer leaves a $65,000 job to open a studio and puts in savings that would have earned $5,000 a year in interest. In its first year the studio books revenue of $260,000 and pays $180,000 in rent, wages, software and materials. 1. Accounting profit: \(260000 - 180000 = 80000\) dollars - healthy, by the books. 2. Implicit costs: \(65000\) forgone salary plus \(5000\) forgone interest: \(70000\) in total. 3. Economic profit: \(80000 - 70000 = 10000\) dollars - positive, so the studio genuinely outperforms the designer's next best alternative. 4. Check: with revenue of $250,000 the same arithmetic gives \(70000 - 70000 = 0\) - economic profit exactly zero, meaning the studio merely matches the alternatives. Assumptions: the salary and interest figures are the true next-best uses of her time and money.

Normal profit: the zero that is not failure

Zero economic profit has a technical name - normal profit - and it does not mean the business is failing. It means revenue covers every opportunity cost, including what the owner could have earned elsewhere: the owner is doing exactly as well as the next best alternative. Positive economic profit means resources are doing better here than in their next best use - a signal that attracts entrants. Negative economic profit means they would do better elsewhere - a signal that owners eventually leave, even when the accounting books still show black ink. Zero is not failure; it is the break-even of opportunity cost.

Why the distinction matters

The accounting profit is the right number for taxes and reporting; the economic profit is the right number for decisions. A firm can report healthy accounting profits for years while its owners earn less than they could elsewhere, because the books never charge for the owners' own time and capital. This is why economists treat entry and exit as driven by economic, not accounting, profit, and why the long-run topics ahead (perfect competition, entry and exit) all measure success with the economic yardstick. An entrepreneur who ignores implicit costs is not counting her own wage bill.

Worked example: should the owner stay?

A cafe owner is deciding whether to keep going. Revenue is $210,000; explicit costs (staff, supplies, utilities) are $150,000. 1. Accounting profit: \(210000 - 150000 = 60000\) dollars - the books look good. 2. Implicit costs: she could earn a $55,000 salary managing a hotel, and she could lease her building to another business for $12,000 a year: \(67000\) total. 3. Economic profit: \(60000 - 67000 = -7000\) dollars. 4. Verdict: resources - her time and her building - would earn $7,000 more in their next best uses. 5. Check the boundary: if the lease offer were $5,000 instead, economic profit would be exactly zero - normal profit - and staying would be defensible. Assumptions: the salary and lease figures are genuine, available alternatives; the decision looks only forward.

Implicit costs beyond salary

The forgone salary is only the most obvious implicit cost. Self-financed businesses forgo the return their capital could have earned elsewhere - forgone interest, dividends or gains. Owners who use their own building forgo its rent; family members who work for the business forgo their own market wages; time spent on one venture forgoes income from others. Each is invisible in the accounts precisely because nobody writes a cheque, yet each represents a real alternative forgone. Even lost leisure counts if the business demands longer hours than the old job. A complete profit calculation prices every owned resource at what it could earn somewhere else.

Sunk costs: a cost that is no cost at all

Distinct from both kinds sits the sunk cost: money already spent and unrecoverable, like non-refundable research on a product that will never launch. A sunk cost is not an implicit cost - it has no opportunity value, because nothing can now be done with it; its alternative uses are all gone. Rational decisions therefore ignore it, exactly as the consumer topics argued with the ski ticket: the question is only whether future benefits exceed future costs. 'We have spent so much already' is the sunk cost fallacy, and it is a bias, not an argument - the money is gone whichever way the firm now turns.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating accounting profit as the verdict on a business - it ignores the owner's own time and capital, which are real costs. Second, forgetting implicit interest: money invested in the firm is not free, even when the owner's own. Third, calling zero economic profit failure - normal profit means the resources earn exactly their alternatives, which is the long-run norm in competitive markets. Fourth, confusing sunk with implicit costs: sunk costs have no alternative use, implicit costs do. Fifth, deciding with 'we have spent so much already' - past spending is not a reason to continue.

Key takeaways

Explicit costs are payments out (wages, rent, materials); implicit costs are the forgone returns on the owner's own resources - salary, interest, rent on property, family labour. Accounting profit subtracts only explicit costs; economic profit subtracts both, so it is never the larger number. Zero economic profit is normal profit - resources doing exactly as well as their alternatives - not failure; positive economic profit attracts entrants, negative signals eventual exit. The designer's studio: $80,000 accounting, $10,000 economic; the cafe owner: $60,000 accounting but -$7,000 economic, better off elsewhere. Sunk costs are past payments that cannot be recovered; they have no opportunity cost now and deserve no weight in any forward decision.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Explicit costs

Actual payments to others: wages, rent, materials

There is a receipt.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A designer's studio books revenue of $260,000, pays $180,000 in explicit costs, and she forgoes $65,000 salary and $5,000 interest. What is her economic profit?

Question 2 of 5

What does zero economic profit mean?

Question 3 of 5

Why can a cafe with a $60,000 accounting profit still be worth leaving?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is an implicit cost?

Question 5 of 5

How should a firm treat non-refundable research spending on a cancelled product?

← Previous topicNext topic →