Microeconomics › Section C · Demand and supply › Topic C.3

Changes in equilibrium: the four-step process

Any economic event - a harvest failure, a fashion trend, a new tax - can be pushed through the same four questions: draw the market first, name the curve, name the direction, compare the equilibria. The four-step process turns the demand-supply model from a picture into a working tool.

One process for every event

Demand and supply are umbrella concepts: demand quietly covers everything that moves buyers - income, tastes, related prices, expectations, numbers - and supply covers everything that moves sellers - costs, technology, weather, policy. That is why a two-axis diagram can analyse an enormous range of events. The four-step process is the discipline for doing it: 1. Draw the market before the change. 2. Decide whether the event affects demand or supply. 3. Decide the direction of the shift. 4. Compare the new equilibrium with the original. The same four questions fit a coffee frost, a smartphone launch and a change in the school-leaving age.

Step 1: draw the market before

Start from the pre-event picture: a demand curve sloping down (law of demand), a supply curve sloping up (law of supply), crossing at the initial equilibrium price and quantity. Sketching this first is not ceremony - it fixes what 'changed' means. Without the before-picture, people argue about what happened; with it, there is a concrete reference point to compare against. If numbers are available, find the initial equilibrium algebraically; if not, a qualitative sketch still carries the reasoning, and the process works identically either way.

Step 2: which curve?

Ask what the event changes: buyers' willingness and ability to purchase, or sellers' ability and willingness to produce. A spell of excellent growing weather changes what farmers can bring to market - supply. A fitness trend changes what consumers want at each price - demand. A rise in household incomes changes demand for most goods. A wage rise in the factories changes costs - supply. Watch for the trap: an event in one market can shift a curve in another (a rise in the price of bread, a complement, shifts demand for jam left), and some events touch both curves - those go to step 3 twice.

Step 3: which direction?

Once the curve is named, ask whether the event raises or lowers it. Increase in demand: the whole demand curve shifts right - more wanted at every price. Decrease: shifts left. Increase in supply: the supply curve shifts right - more offered at every price. Decrease: shifts left. Direction comes from the nature of the event, not from what you hope the outcome is: a tax is a cost (supply left), a subsidy is a negative cost (supply right), a health scare is a taste shift (demand left). This is where circular reasoning dies - the shift is an input, the price change an output.

Step 4: compare the equilibria

Finally, find the new crossing and compare. Demand right: price and quantity both rise. Demand left: both fall. Supply right: price falls, quantity rises. Supply left: price rises, quantity falls. If both curves shifted, apply the pattern from the previous topic: the variable both shifts push the same way moves for certain, and the opposed variable depends on which shift is larger. The comparison, not the shift itself, is the answer to the original question - 'what happened to price and quantity?'

Worked example: a bumper harvest

A perfect growing season hits the apple market, where demand is \(Q_d = 400 - 20P\) and supply is \(Q_s = 80 + 20P\) (dollars per crate, thousands of crates). Step 1: before the event, \(400 - 20P = 80 + 20P\) gives \(320 = 40P\), so \(P = 8\) and \(Q = 240\). Step 2: weather changes what growers can offer - supply. Step 3: a bumper season is good natural conditions: supply shifts right, say by 40: \(Q_s = 120 + 20P\). Step 4: solve \(400 - 20P = 120 + 20P\): \(280 = 40P\), so \(P = 7\), \(Q = 260\). Check: \(Q_d = 400 - 140 = 260\), \(Q_s = 120 + 140 = 260\). Price fell from $8 to $7, quantity rose from 240 to 260 - the textbook supply-right pattern.

Worked example: a demand trend

A swimming craze hits the goggle market: demand \(Q_d = 150 - 10P\), supply \(Q_s = 30 + 10P\). Step 1: initial equilibrium: \(150 - 10P = 30 + 10P\) gives \(120 = 20P\), \(P = 6\), \(Q = 90\). Step 2: a craze changes buyers' tastes - demand. Step 3: more people want goggles at every price: demand shifts right by 20, \(Q_d = 170 - 10P\). Step 4: \(170 - 10P = 30 + 10P\) gives \(140 = 20P\), \(P = 7\), \(Q = 100\). Check: \(Q_d = 170 - 70 = 100\), \(Q_s = 30 + 70 = 100\). Price up from $6 to $7, quantity up from 90 to 100 - the demand-right pattern. Notice the sellers gained from a shift they did nothing to cause.

Worked example: both curves at once

Back to apples: a blight cuts supply by 20, and a fitness craze raises demand for apples by 20. Base: \(P = 8\), \(Q = 240\) (240 thousand crates). Step 1: as before. Step 2: two curves - the blight hits supply, the craze hits demand. Step 3: blight is bad natural conditions: supply left, \(Q_s = 60 + 20P\); craze: demand right, \(Q_d = 420 - 20P\). Step 4: \(420 - 20P = 60 + 20P\) gives \(360 = 40P\), so \(P = 9\), \(Q = 240\). Check: \(Q_d = 420 - 180 = 240\), \(Q_s = 60 + 180 = 240\). Price rose from $8 to $9; quantity stayed at 240 - the two shifts pushed quantity opposite ways and exactly cancelled. With slightly different magnitudes quantity would have moved; the moral is that both-shift answers need the sizes, not just the directions.

Markets adjust, and quickly

The four-step process looks slow on paper, but real markets run it fast. When a frost damages a coffee harvest, wholesale prices begin moving within days as traders anticipate the shortage - often before the smaller crop even reaches the docks. Shifts also travel between markets: pricier coffee shifts demand for tea, scarcer syrup shifts the costs of cafés. None of this needs a coordinator. Every participant responds to the one piece of information that matters to them - the price they face - and their combined responses produce the new equilibrium. The model is static, but the process it describes is continuous.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, skipping step 1: without the before-equilibrium, 'higher' and 'lower' have no anchor. Second, letting the expected outcome choose the shift - deciding supply must have risen because you think price should fall is backwards; the shift causes the outcome, never the reverse. Third, forcing every event onto one curve: some belong to both, and the answer may then be ambiguous in one variable. Fourth, confusing a curve shift with movement along it during step 3 - a price rise is the output of step 4, not a supply change. Fifth, over-claiming precision: qualitative directions are often all the data justify.

Key takeaways

The four-step process: draw the market before the event; decide whether demand or supply is affected; decide the shift's direction; compare the new equilibrium with the old. Supply-right (the bumper harvest: $8 to $7, 240 to 260) lowers price and raises quantity; demand-right (the goggle craze: $6 to $7, 90 to 100) raises both; when both shift (blight and craze: $8 to $9, quantity unchanged at 240), the variable pushed both ways depends on magnitudes. The model's reach comes from the umbrella structure of demand and supply - every factor folds into one curve or the other - and real markets run the process continuously, with prices moving as traders anticipate the shifts.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Four-step process

Draw before, name the curve, name the direction, compare equilibria

The same four questions for every event.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In the four-step process, what happens in step 2?

Question 2 of 5

A perfect growing season boosts the apple crop. In the market example, demand is Qd = 400 - 20P and supply rises from Qs = 80 + 20P to Qs = 120 + 20P. What happens?

Question 3 of 5

A swimming craze shifts goggle demand from Qd = 150 - 10P to Qd = 170 - 10P, with supply Qs = 30 + 10P. What is the new equilibrium price?

Question 4 of 5

In apples, a blight shifts supply left by 20 (Qs = 60 + 20P) while a fitness craze shifts demand right by 20 (Qd = 420 - 20P). What is the result?

Question 5 of 5

Why do economists warn against letting the expected outcome choose the shift in step 3?

← Previous topicNext topic →