Microeconomics › Section F · Consumer choices › Topic F.2

How income and price changes shift choices

When income rises or a price falls, the consumer's whole map changes: the budget line moves, the old best point drifts, and the new one can be found at a touch. This topic builds the full graphical model - budget lines, indifference curves - and then uses it to split every price change into two forces.

Two tools: budgets and preferences

Consumer choice needs two maps. The budget constraint, met earlier, lists every combination of two goods a consumer can afford: \(P_xX + P_yY = I\), a straight line whose slope is \(-P_x/P_y\) - the rate at which the market lets you trade one good for the other. What it cannot say is which affordable bundle is best. For that, preferences enter as indifference curves. Put the two maps together and the best choice can be located on one graph.

Indifference curves

An indifference curve connects all combinations of two goods that give a consumer the same satisfaction - the person is indifferent among them. Curves farther from the origin represent higher satisfaction. Three properties follow from consistent preferences. They slope downward: to keep satisfaction level while taking some of good Y away, more X must compensate. They cannot cross: a crossing would claim one bundle is both equal to and better than another bundle. And they bow inward toward the origin, for a reason the next card gives.

The marginal rate of substitution

The slope of an indifference curve is the marginal rate of substitution (MRS): how much Y a consumer would give up for one more unit of X while staying equally happy. The bow in the curve comes from diminishing MRS: someone with very little X will surrender plenty of Y for more X, but someone already loaded with X gives up little Y for yet another unit. Diminishing MRS is closely related to diminishing marginal utility, read as a trade-off rate, and the bow it produces gives the consumer a single best point on the budget line.

The optimal choice: a tangency

The consumer's best affordable bundle sits where the budget line just touches the highest reachable indifference curve - the tangency point. At that point the MRS equals the price ratio: the rate the consumer is willing to trade equals the rate the market allows. If the two differed - say the consumer would give up more Y than the market demands for an extra X - more X could be bought and utility would rise, so only tangency leaves no move open. This is the graphical twin of the marginal-utility-per-dollar rule: MRS equals \(MU_X/MU_Y\), and setting it equal to \(P_X/P_Y\) rearranges into \(MU_X/P_X = MU_Y/P_Y\).

Worked example: mapping a hobby budget

Theo has $90 for games and comics: board games cost $30, comics $6. 1. The budget line runs from 3 games (\(90 \div 30\)) to 15 comics (\(90 \div 6\)). 2. Its slope is \(-30/6 = -5\): each game costs five comics at market prices. 3. An interior bundle: 2 games and 5 comics costs \(2 \times 30 + 5 \times 6 = 90\) - exactly on the line. 4. If Theo's MRS is 7 comics per game at some bundle, he values a game above the market price and should trade comics for games until diminishing MRS brings him to 5. 5. Check the twin rule: MRS 5 equals the price ratio 5. Assumptions: fixed prices, $90 spent on these two goods.

Income changes: parallel shifts

Raising income moves every affordable quantity up proportionally - the budget line shifts outward in parallel, slope unchanged. The consumer's optimum moves with it, but not necessarily in the same proportions. For normal goods, consumption rises with income; for inferior goods it falls, as buyers move to preferred alternatives - bus rides give way to car trips, instant noodles to restaurant meals. And the composition shifts even among normal goods: the income elasticities of the elasticity section mean luxuries grow faster than income, necessities slower. A richer consumer does not just buy more; the whole basket reshapes.

Price changes: rotations and two forces

A price change rotates the budget line around the opposite good's endpoint: a cheaper board game pivots the line outward along the games axis, keeping the 15-comics corner fixed. The optimum then moves, and economists split the move into two effects. The substitution effect: the good is now relatively cheaper, so buy more of it and less of the other - always working against the price change. The income effect: a cheaper good raises real purchasing power, like a small income rise - which adds more of the good if it is normal, subtracts some if it is inferior. Every price change is both stories at once; for normal goods they reinforce each other.

Worked example: splitting a fare cut

Maya has $60 a month for bus trips and other spending. At a $3 fare she chooses 15 trips (\(15 \times 3 = 45\) dollars) and $15 of other goods. 1. The fare falls to $2, rotating her budget line outward: she could now afford up to \(60 \div 2 = 30\) trips. 2. Income effect, size: her old 15 trips now cost only $30, freeing \(15 \times (3 - 2) = 15\) dollars, like a small pay rise. 3. Substitution effect: with buses relatively cheaper, she would ride more even if that freed $15 were taken away - say 18 trips. 4. Income effect: spending part of the freed money on a normal good adds, say, 2 more trips, so she ends at 20 trips. 5. Check: \(20 \times 2 = 40\) dollars on buses plus $20 of other goods is exactly $60. Were buses inferior for Maya, the income effect would subtract trips. The 18 and 2 split is illustrative.

Giffen goods: the rare exception

Could a price rise ever increase quantity demanded? In theory, yes - for a strongly inferior good that eats a large share of a very poor household's budget. There the negative income effect can outweigh the substitution effect and produce an upward-sloping response. Such Giffen goods are famous precisely because they are so rare. One much-cited study found behaviour consistent with this for rice among very poor households in parts of China - plausible because rice dominated those food budgets. The mainstream case stands: for almost every good, demand curves slope downward.

From choices to demand curves

This machinery is the foundation the demand curve was standing on. Vary the price of a good, trace the consumer's tangency points, and each price maps to a chosen quantity - the individual demand curve, which slopes downward except in the rare Giffen case. Sum horizontally across consumers and the market demand curve of the early chapters appears - now with microfoundations. The same lens explains a policy point: a tax that raises one good's price also squeezes real income, so buyers may cut spending on other goods too, not just the taxed one.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, moving the whole line for a price change: only income shifts it in parallel; a single price rotates it. Second, treating the tangency as optional: any interior optimum must satisfy MRS = price ratio, or a profitable swap remains. Third, forgetting the two effects have separate identities - the substitution effect always fights the price change, the income effect can go either way. Fourth, expecting Giffen behaviour anywhere convenient: it needs a strongly inferior good dominating a very tight budget. Fifth, letting indifference curves cross in a sketch - crossed curves mean inconsistent preferences.

Key takeaways

The budget line (slope \(-P_x/P_y\)) shows what is affordable; indifference curves show what is preferred and are downward-sloping, non-crossing and bowed inward. The optimum is the tangency where MRS equals the price ratio, the twin of equal marginal utility per dollar. An income rise shifts the line out in parallel; a price change rotates it and splits into a substitution effect, always against the price move, and an income effect whose sign depends on whether the good is normal or inferior. Giffen goods are the rare case where the income effect wins.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Budget line

PxX + PyY = I; slope -Px/Py

The affordability map.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Theo has $90; board games cost $30 and comics $6. What is the slope of his budget line?

Question 2 of 5

In the indifference-curve model, where is a consumer's best affordable bundle?

Question 3 of 5

Anita's income rises. What happens to her budget line?

Question 4 of 5

A bus fare falls from $3 to $2. What are the two effects on Maya's bus travel?

Question 5 of 5

What makes a Giffen good possible in theory?

← Previous topicNext topic →