Microeconomics › Section I · Monopoly › Topic I.2
How a monopoly chooses output and price
Unlike a competitive firm, a monopolist faces the whole market's demand curve alone, and that one fact changes its arithmetic. Selling more means cutting the price on every unit, so extra output earns less than the price suggests - and the profit-maximising monopoly ends up smaller and dearer than the competition it replaced.
Facing the whole demand curve
A competitive firm saw a flat demand line at the market price; a monopolist sees the market's entire downward-sloping demand curve, because it IS the market. The slope is power and constraint at once. Power: the monopolist can raise price and keep many of its customers, losing only some. Constraint: the curve's height at each quantity caps what can be charged for that quantity - a monopolist maximises profit, not price. The first task is to see what the curve does to revenue.
Why marginal revenue falls below price
To sell one more unit, the monopolist must lower the price - and with a single price for all buyers, that cut applies to every unit sold, not just the extra one. Marginal revenue is therefore the new unit's price MINUS the revenue lost by cutting the price on all earlier units: always less than price. Watch it happen: with demand \(P = 120 - 2Q\), at \(Q = 10\) price is $100 and revenue $1,000; at \(Q = 11\) price is $98 and revenue $1,078. The eleventh unit 'earns' $98, but the ten before it each gave up $2 - so marginal revenue is \(1078 - 1000 = 78\), well below the $98 price. For a straight-line demand curve, the MR curve starts at the same intercept as demand with twice the slope: here \(MR = 120 - 4Q\).
Worked example: marginal revenue, step by step
Confirm the MR rule on the same demand curve, \(P = 120 - 2Q\). 1. Revenue at any quantity: \(TR = P \times Q = (120 - 2Q)Q = 120Q - 2Q^2\). 2. Marginal revenue: the rate revenue changes per unit - \(MR = 120 - 4Q\), the same intercept, twice the slope. 3. Check at \(Q = 10\): \(MR = 120 - 40 = 80\); the table arithmetic gave 78 for the discrete eleventh unit, and the curve's value between 10 and 11 is \(120 - 4(10.5) = 78\) - exact match. 4. Interpret: the gap between price (100 at Q = 10) and MR (80) is the discount paid to earlier buyers - pure cost of expanding sales, felt by no competitive firm. Assumptions: single price for all buyers; linear demand.
The monopolist's two-step rule
Profit maximisation still runs on \(MR = MC\) - the same marginal logic as every firm. But for a monopolist the two numbers then diverge. Step one: choose quantity where \(MR = MC\). Step two: charge not that quantity's MR but its PRICE - read upward from the chosen quantity to the demand curve. Because MR lies below price everywhere on a downward demand curve, the price charged ends up above marginal cost: the mark-up of monopoly. A competitive industry with identical costs would produce where \(P = MC\); the monopolist produces less and charges more - the same technology, a different outcome, purely from market structure.
Worked example: the monopoly solution
A monopolist faces \(P = 120 - 2Q\) (so \(MR = 120 - 4Q\)) with constant marginal cost of $16. 1. Set \(MR = MC\): \(120 - 4Q = 16\), so \(4Q = 104\) and \(Q = 26\). 2. Price: read the demand curve at 26 - \(P = 120 - 52 = 68\) dollars. 3. Check the mark-up: price 68 against marginal cost 16 - $52 of power per unit. 4. Compare with competition: a competitive industry with the same demand and costs produces where \(P = MC\): \(120 - 2Q = 16\), so \(Q = 52\) at \(P = 16\). 5. The verdict: the monopoly halves output (52 to 26) and more than quadruples price (16 to 68), earning profit of \((68 - 16) \times 26 = 1352\) dollars, with identical costs and identical buyers. Assumptions: single price, linear demand, constant MC, no fixed cost, no entry (the barriers of the previous topic).
The deadweight loss of monopoly
Between the monopoly's 26 units and competition's 52 lie trades that would have benefited both sides: every unit from 26 to 52 is valued by buyers above its $16 cost, yet is never made. The lost surplus is the familiar deadweight triangle: \(\frac{1}{2} \times (68 - 16) \times (52 - 26) = 676\) dollars. Where did the rest of the consumers' surplus go? Partly into the monopolist's profit - a transfer, fought over by buyers and seller - and partly into nothing at all, the 676. That split is why economists object to monopoly chiefly on efficiency grounds: the transfer is a question of who gets the pie, but the triangle is the pie shrinking. A protected monopoly may also feel little pressure to cut costs or innovate.
No supply curve for a monopolist
A competitive firm had a supply curve - its MC curve above AVC - because price was given and quantity was its one response. A monopolist does not have one. It faces a demand curve, not a given price, so what it sells depends on the whole shape of demand: two different demand curves can lead it to sell the same quantity at different prices, so no single schedule links price to quantity. A monopolist chooses a POINT on demand; the idea of 'quantity supplied at each price' dissolves. This is why the demand-and-supply diagram of the early chapters does not apply directly to monopoly markets.
Price discrimination: charging by willingness to pay
A monopolist that can separate its customers, and prevent them reselling to each other, can abandon the single price: charge more to those who will pay more. Airlines sort flexible business travellers from price-sensitive tourists by refund rules and booking windows; cinemas discount students and seniors, whose demand is more elastic; software is cheaper for students. Each group is charged nearer its own willingness to pay, converting consumer surplus into profit. The limiting case - charging every buyer exactly their maximum - would capture ALL consumer surplus; paradoxically it also eliminates deadweight loss, since every buyer willing to cover marginal cost is served. The barrier is information and resale: separating markets is hard, and arbitrage between them defeats the scheme.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading MR = MC's conclusion off the wrong curve: price comes from the DEMAND curve at the chosen quantity, never from the MR curve. Second, assuming MR = MC means price equals marginal cost - true only for price takers; for a monopolist the point is the gap. Third, expecting the monopolist to maximise price: at $100 the example sells 10 units for profit of \((100 - 16) \times 10 = 840\) dollars, well below the 1,352 at $68. Fourth, hunting for the monopolist's supply curve - there is none; it picks points, not a curve. Fifth, assuming price discrimination is always impossible: markets are separated routinely, but resale and information set its limits.
Key takeaways
A monopolist faces the whole demand curve, so selling more means cutting price on all units: marginal revenue falls below price (the $98 unit netted $78), and for linear demand MR has demand's intercept with twice the slope. The rule: choose Q where \(MR = MC\), then price from the demand curve - so price exceeds marginal cost, the signature of market power. The example: \(Q = 26\), \(P = 68\) against a competitive \(Q = 52\), \(P = 16\) - half the output, over four times the price, and a 676-dollar deadweight triangle of trades never made. A monopolist has no supply curve, only chosen points. And price discrimination - where separation and no-resale allow it - moves surplus from buyers to the seller, with the perfect case oddly efficient but unreachable.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The whole market's downward-sloping demand
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
For a monopolist with demand P = 120 - 2Q, what is the marginal revenue curve?
Question 2 of 5
Why is a monopolist's marginal revenue less than its price?
Question 3 of 5
A monopolist has MR = 120 - 4Q and marginal cost of $16. What output does it choose, and what price does it charge from demand P = 120 - 2Q?
Question 4 of 5
Compared with a competitive industry having the same demand and costs, the monopolist in the example:
Question 5 of 5
In the example, why is the 676-dollar deadweight loss called a loss rather than a transfer?
