Microeconomics › Section E · Elasticity › Topic E.4

Income, cross-price, and other elasticities

Quantity responds to more than a good's own price: it responds to buyers' incomes, to the prices of other goods, and on the supply side to everything that makes production flexible. The elasticity formula stretches to measure each of these - and the sign of the answer often carries the whole finding.

One formula, a family of questions

Elasticity is not a single number about price; it is a grammar: the percentage change in one thing, divided by the percentage change in the thing that moved it. Own-price elasticity answered 'how does quantity respond to price?'. Swap the denominator and new questions open: how does demand respond to income? To the price of a different good? And on the supply side, how does quantity supplied respond to price over different horizons? Each member of the family is one division - and in the new members, unlike own-price demand elasticity, the sign is information you must not throw away.

Income elasticity of demand

Income elasticity measures how quantity demanded responds to income:

E_Y = \frac{\%\Delta Q}{\%\Delta Y}

The sign sorts goods into kinds. Positive: a normal good - richer people buy more. Above 1: a luxury, growing faster than income and taking a bigger share of the budget as people prosper. Between 0 and 1: a necessity - rising with income, but less than proportionally. Negative: an inferior good - rising incomes push buyers toward preferred alternatives, as with instant noodles or discount-store brands. Income elasticity is the formal version of what 'luxury' and 'necessity' have always meant.

Putting income elasticity to work

Businesses forecast with it. If restaurant meals have an income elasticity around 2, then a growing economy is a tailwind: each 1% of income growth brings about 2% more spending on dining out. Discount grocers run the opposite book: their target demand is partly inferior, so recessions - falling incomes - can raise their sales. Air travel and luxury goods tend to track the upside of growth; bus travel and store brands often track the downside. Income elasticities tell each business how strongly growth or recession will reach its own sales.

Worked example: reading two income elasticities

Average household incomes in a city rise by 4%. Spending at restaurants rises 8%; spending on bus passes falls 2%. 1. Restaurant income elasticity: \(8 \div 4 = 2.0\). 2. Interpretation: above 1 - a luxury; restaurant spending grows twice as fast as income. 3. Bus pass elasticity: \(-2 \div 4 = -0.5\). 4. Interpretation: negative - an inferior good; some households respond to higher incomes by switching from buses to cars or ride-hailing. 5. Check the forecast use: if the economy booms with 6% income growth, restaurant demand should rise about 12% and bus demand fall about 3%. Assumptions: prices, fares and routes held fixed, so spending changes equal quantity changes; the 4% is measured on comparable households.

Cross-price elasticity

Cross-price elasticity measures how demand for one good responds to the price of another:

E_{AB} = \frac{\%\Delta Q_A}{\%\Delta P_B}

The sign does the classification. Positive: the goods are substitutes - when B gets dearer, buyers move to A, so A's demand rises (tea and coffee, two streaming services). Negative: complements - B's price rise chokes off the pair together, lowering A's demand (consoles and games, printers and cartridges). Near zero: unrelated goods - the price of salt barely moves the demand for cinema tickets. One number, three verdicts.

Worked example: two cross-price readings

Streaming service A raises its monthly price 10%; its rival B gains 6% more subscribers. 1. Cross-price elasticity: \(6 \div 10 = 0.6\). 2. Positive - substitutes, and strongly so: many of A's customers treat B as a real alternative. 3. Now game consoles rise 20% in price, and game sales fall 8%. 4. Elasticity: \(-8 \div 20 = -0.4\). 5. Negative - complements: consoles and games are consumed together, so a dearer console shrinks the player base that buys games. Assumptions: nothing else moved the two quantities; the periods are comparable.

Elasticity in competition law

When two firms want to merge, regulators must first define the market: does the merged firm face real competition, or would it dominate? Cross-price elasticity is the evidence. If a small price rise by firm A sends a large flow of customers to firm B, the firms are in the same market - the merger removes a genuine rival, and prices could rise. If the flow is near zero, they occupy different markets, whatever the product labels suggest. Market definition, an early step in most merger reviews, rests largely on evidence about cross-price elasticities.

Supply elasticity, revisited in full

Supply is elastic when production can expand easily: spare capacity, readily available inputs, and storable output all help - a warehouse of canned goods can meet a demand surge at little extra cost. It is inelastic when quantity is stuck: the day's fishing catch is on the dock whatever the price; housing in a crowded city is famously slow to grow because land and planning permission are scarce. And time remains the master variable: nearly fixed in a day, flexible within months, highly elastic across years as firms build capacity and new firms enter. These differences decide who feels a demand shock - elastic supply absorbs it into quantity; inelastic supply passes it into price.

Elasticity in labour and savings markets

The same division works in the markets for work and for savings. The wage elasticity of labour supply is the percentage change in hours supplied divided by the percentage change in the wage. Studies generally find it fairly high for teenagers, who can easily take up or drop part-time work, and low for adults in their prime working years, most of whom work full time whatever the wage. The elasticity of savings is the percentage change in the quantity saved divided by the percentage change in the interest rate. The evidence is mixed, but in the short run saving looks fairly unresponsive, so tax breaks that raise the return on saving may add less saving than hoped.

Why low elasticities attract tax designers

The incidence rule from the previous topic has a companion that tax collectors know well. When both demand and supply are inelastic, quantity barely changes when a tax wedges the two sides apart - so the deadweight loss is small and revenue is reliable. That is part of why cigarettes, alcohol and petrol attract taxes: buyers keep buying, quantity falls little, and the treasury collects. A tax on one brand of crisps, with elastic demand, would shrink its sales sharply, collecting little and wasting more. Elasticities decide not only who bears each tax but whether the tax is worth its waste at all.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, discarding the sign in the new elasticities: negative income elasticity identifies an inferior good; positive cross-price elasticity identifies substitutes - in both, the sign is the headline. Second, assuming a large cross-price number means 'the goods are the same': it means they compete strongly, a matter of degree. Third, calling a necessity 'low-elasticity' without saying which elasticity: necessities have low income elasticity; luxuries high. Fourth, expecting one supply elasticity everywhere: storage, capacity, land and time make each supply market different. Fifth, forgetting that deadweight loss, not just incidence, depends on elasticity when judging a tax.

Key takeaways

The elasticity grammar extends to every responsiveness. Income elasticity \(\%\Delta Q / \%\Delta Y\) sorts goods: positive normal, above 1 luxury, between 0 and 1 necessity, negative inferior (restaurants 2.0, bus passes -0.5 in the example). Cross-price elasticity \(\%\Delta Q_A / \%\Delta P_B\) sorts relationships: positive substitutes (rival streaming at 0.6), negative complements (consoles-games at -0.4), zero unrelated - and it is how competition law defines markets for mergers. Supply elasticity runs from nearly fixed (the day's catch, city housing) to highly elastic (storable goods, growing industries over years); the same idea measures how hours respond to wages and saving to interest rates. And low elasticity on both sides of a market is what tax designers prize: little quantity change, little deadweight loss, reliable revenue.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Elasticity grammar

% change in one thing over % change in its driver

One division, a family of measures.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

When household incomes rise 4%, spending at restaurants rises 8%. What is the income elasticity, and what kind of good is dining out?

Question 2 of 5

Spending on bus passes falls 2% when incomes rise 4%. What does the income elasticity of -0.5 tell us?

Question 3 of 5

Streaming service A raises prices 10% and rival B gains 6% more subscribers. What does the cross-price elasticity of 0.6 indicate?

Question 4 of 5

Game console prices rise 20% and game sales fall 8%. What is the cross-price elasticity between consoles and games?

Question 5 of 5

Why do competition authorities care about cross-price elasticities when reviewing a merger?

← Previous topicNext topic →