Microeconomics › Section O · Poverty and economic inequality › Topic O.3

The safety net

The US safety net is not one programme but a patchwork: cash aid, tax credits, food benefits and health insurance, each with its own rules. Knowing how each one works, and how each handles the poverty trap, is the key to judging what the safety net does.

A patchwork, not a net

The safety net is the set of government programmes that support people with low incomes or none. Most are means-tested: eligibility depends on income and sometimes assets. They differ in form. Some pay cash, which families can spend as they choose. Some are in kind, such as food benefits or health insurance. Some work through the tax system as refundable credits, paid even to families who owe no income tax. Separate from all of these is social insurance, such as Social Security, which is not means-tested but does more than any other programme to keep older Americans out of poverty.

From AFDC to TANF

From the New Deal until 1996, the main cash programme, widely called welfare, was AFDC (Aid to Families with Dependent Children). Federal funding rose automatically with the number of eligible families, and there were no time limits and only limited work requirements. The 1996 welfare reform law swapped AFDC for a new programme, TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families). Each state now receives a fixed block grant it can spend on a wide range of antipoverty goals. States must meet work participation targets, and federal funds cannot pay an adult for more than 60 months in a lifetime.

TANF today

Caseloads fell from about 4.4 million families under AFDC in 1996 to roughly 1 million in recent years. Supporters credit work rules and the strong late-1990s economy; critics note that fewer poor families get help at all. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities estimates that only about 21 of every 100 families in poverty received TANF cash in 2023, compared with about 68 of every 100 under AFDC in 1996. The federal block grant has stayed at $16.5 billion a year since 1996 and has never been raised for inflation, so it has lost roughly half its purchasing power.

The earned income tax credit

The earned income tax credit (EITC), created in 1975, pays low-income workers through the tax system, so it reaches only families with earnings. It has three ranges. In the phase-in range, the credit rises with each dollar earned: 40 cents per dollar for a parent of two. On the plateau it stays at its maximum. In the phase-out range it falls gradually: 21.06 cents per dollar for a parent of two. For tax year 2025 the maximum credits (IRS) were $649 with no children, $4,328 with one, $7,152 with two and $8,046 with three or more. Rewarding work and phasing out slowly, it has support across the political spectrum.

Worked example: an EITC for a parent of two

Use the 2025 parameters for a single parent of two: a 40% phase-in, a maximum of $7,152, and a 21.06% phase-out above $23,350 of income. 1. The maximum is reached at \(7{,}152 \div 0.40 = \$17{,}880\) of earnings. 2. Earning $10,000: credit \(0.40 \times 10{,}000 = \$4{,}000\). 3. Earning $30,000: credit \(7{,}152 - 0.2106 \times (30{,}000 - 23{,}350) \approx \$5{,}752\). 4. The credit ends where \(0.2106 \times (E - 23{,}350) = 7{,}152\), at about $57,310. 5. Read it: below $17,880 each dollar of work earns $1.40, and the slow phase-out keeps the implicit tax well short of 100%.

The child tax credit

For 2021 only, the per-child credit was raised to as much as $3,600 per young child, made fully refundable even for families with no earnings, with half paid in monthly instalments. The Census Bureau's Supplemental Poverty Measure showed child poverty falling to a record low of 5.2% that year, and rising to 12.4% in 2022 after the expansion expired. Debate continues over how much the expanded credit reduced work. The 2025 budget law, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, set the credit at $2,200 per child from 2025, indexed to inflation later, with up to $1,700 refundable for 2025 for families with enough earnings.

SNAP: food benefits

The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), formerly called food stamps, gives households a monthly benefit on an electronic card that can be spent only on food. In fiscal year 2024 it reached about 42 million people a month, with an average benefit of about $187 per person (US Department of Agriculture). Because most families already spend more on food than their SNAP benefit, the benefit frees cash for other needs, so economists treat it as close to an income transfer. Congress tightened work requirements in 2025: adults without a child under 14, now up to age 64, generally lose benefits after three months in three years unless they work or train 80 hours a month.

Worked example: a SNAP benefit

A simplified calculation for a household of three, using fiscal year 2025 figures for the 48 contiguous states: a maximum benefit of $768 a month and a standard deduction of $204. The household earns $2,000 a month and, for simplicity, has no other deductions. 1. Earned income deduction: \(0.8 \times 2{,}000 = \$1{,}600\). 2. Net income: \(1{,}600 - 204 = \$1{,}396\). 3. Expected contribution: SNAP assumes households spend 30% of net income on food, \(0.3 \times 1{,}396 = \$418.80\). 4. Benefit: \(768 - 418.80 \approx \$349\) a month. 5. Check the phase-out: $100 more of earnings lowers the benefit by \(0.3 \times 0.8 \times 100 = \$24\).

Medicaid and health coverage

Medicaid, created in 1965, is health insurance for people with low incomes, run by states with substantial federal funding, so rules vary by state. Children are a large share of enrollees, but older and disabled people account for most spending. Medicaid once fed the poverty trap: a parent who took a low-paid job without health benefits could lose the family's coverage. Expansions for children and the Affordable Care Act's option to cover adults up to 138% of the poverty line eased that cliff; about 40 states and DC have adopted it. A 2025 law adds work requirements for many expansion adults, due to start by January 2027.

Other strands of the net

Smaller programmes fill particular gaps. Supplemental Security Income (SSI) pays cash to low-income people who are elderly, blind or disabled. WIC supports the nutrition of low-income pregnant women, new mothers and young children. School meals feed low-income pupils. Housing Choice Vouchers help pay rent, but funding is capped, so many eligible families wait years or never get one. A federal energy programme helps with heating bills. Each has its own rules, so families often face several phase-outs at once.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling TANF the safety net: it is now one of the smaller strands, far smaller than the EITC, SNAP or Medicaid. Second, assuming the EITC helps families with no earnings: it requires earned income. Third, thinking in-kind food benefits must raise food spending one for one: most families already spend more on food than the benefit, so it frees cash. Fourth, forgetting that TANF and Medicaid rules vary by state. Fifth, quoting programme figures without the year: the child tax credit and SNAP rules both changed in 2021 and again in 2025.

Key takeaways

The safety net mixes cash (TANF, SSI), in-kind aid (SNAP, Medicaid, WIC, housing) and refundable tax credits (EITC, child tax credit). TANF replaced AFDC in 1996 with block grants, work rules and a 60-month limit, and reached about 21 of every 100 poor families in 2023. The EITC rewards work: for a parent of two in 2025 it phased in at 40% to $7,152 and out at 21.06%. SNAP reached about 42 million people a month in fiscal year 2024 and phases out at about 24 cents per dollar earned. Medicaid's expansion eased a health-insurance cliff.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Means-tested

Eligibility depends on income, and sometimes assets

Most safety-net programmes work this way.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did the 1996 welfare reform change federal cash aid?

Question 2 of 5

Using the 2025 parameters, what EITC does a single parent of two with $10,000 of earnings receive?

Question 3 of 5

Why do economists treat SNAP as close to an income transfer, even though it can be spent only on food?

Question 4 of 5

In the SNAP worked example, a household of three earns $2,000 a month. What is its approximate monthly benefit?

Question 5 of 5

What happened to the SPM child poverty rate when the expanded 2021 child tax credit expired?

← Previous topicNext topic →