Microeconomics › Section T · Globalization and protectionism › Topic T.2
Trade, jobs, wages, and working conditions
The fiercest arguments about trade are about work: does it destroy jobs, push down wages, or reward bad working conditions abroad? The evidence gives a two-part answer. Trade changes which jobs exist far more than how many, but its costs can land hard on particular workers and places.
Three worries
Imports could, in principle, hurt workers in three ways: by reducing the number of jobs, by lowering wages, or by rewarding countries where working conditions are poor. Each worry has a real basis, and each needs to be separated into two questions. What happens to workers on average across the whole economy? And what happens to the particular workers whose industry or town meets new competition? Confusing these two questions is the source of most disagreement about trade and labour.
The number of jobs
Over long periods, trade does not shrink total employment. US trade has grown for decades, yet the number of US jobs more than doubled between 1970 and the 2020s, rising and falling with the business cycle rather than trending down with imports. When the North American Free Trade Agreement took effect in January 1994, opponents predicted a mass loss of jobs to Mexico; the late 1990s instead brought strong job growth and low unemployment, and most studies found NAFTA's effect on total US employment was small. The level of employment depends mainly on overall demand, which macroeconomics studies, not on trade policy.
Protection moves jobs around
Protection does save jobs in the shielded industry, but it costs jobs elsewhere, for two reasons. First, buyers who pay more for the protected good have less to spend on everything else, so other industries hire less. Second, firms that use the protected good as an input face higher costs and lose sales to foreign rivals who pay world prices. Retaliation by trading partners can also hit exporters. So protection reshuffles jobs from unprotected to protected industries rather than adding to the total. A Federal Reserve study of the 2018-2019 tariffs, by Aaron Flaaen and Justin Pierce, found that in US manufacturing the job losses from higher input costs and retaliation outweighed the gains from protection.
Worked example: cost per job saved
A tariff on an imported good raises what consumers pay by $1.2 billion a year, and it keeps 2,000 domestic jobs that would otherwise have gone. Average pay in those jobs is $50,000. 1. Cost per job saved: \(1{,}200{,}000{,}000 \div 2{,}000 = 600{,}000\) dollars a year. 2. Compare with pay: \(600{,}000 \div 50{,}000 = 12\), so each job costs consumers 12 times its wage. 3. Why so high: much of the extra spending goes to higher profits and to tariff revenue, part is deadweight loss, and only a slice preserves jobs. 4. Check against evidence: one study of the 2018 US tariffs on washing machines estimated a cost to consumers of roughly $815,000 per job created.
Worked example: a tariff on an input
A domestic firm builds machines that sell for $20,000, each containing $2,000 of steel. A tariff raises the price of steel by 25%. 1. Extra steel cost per machine: \(0.25 \times 2{,}000 = 500\) dollars. 2. As a share of the machine's price: \(500 \div 20{,}000 = 2.5\%\). 3. Suppose the firm's profit is $1,000 per machine. It can absorb the $500, halving its profit, or raise its price by 2.5% and lose customers to foreign machine makers who buy steel at world prices. 4. Check the wider point: there are many more workers in steel-using industries than in steelmaking, so even small cost increases spread across them can cost more jobs than the tariff saves.
Trade and average wages
Trade lets an economy specialise in what it does relatively well, which raises output per worker. Higher productivity raises the demand for labour and so the average level of real wages. Lower prices for imported goods add to real wages too, because each dollar buys more. Barriers to trade work the other way, lowering average real wages. Low-wage households gain especially from cheaper imports, because they spend a large share of their income on traded basics such as food and clothing.
Winners and losers among workers
Averages hide a spread. Workers in exporting industries see demand for their labour rise; workers in industries facing new imports see it fall. The Stolper-Samuelson theorem predicts that trade tends to benefit owners of a country's abundant input and hurt owners of its scarce input, which in the United States raises a concern about less-skilled workers. Research on the "China shock" by David Autor, David Dorn, Gordon Hanson and others found that the surge of Chinese imports after about 2000 cost many US manufacturing jobs, by one estimate around 2 million including indirect effects, concentrated in particular towns, with lasting harm to local wages and employment.
Why the damage varies
How much trade hurts particular workers depends on how easily they can move to new jobs. Where workers can retrain, relocate or switch industry quickly, losses are short-lived; where a whole town depends on one industry, they can last a decade or more. Many less-skilled jobs, such as care work, construction and food service, cannot be imported at all, so foreign competition is not the main influence on their wages. Much US trade is also with other high-wage economies. Many economists find that technology and automation have reshaped work at least as much as trade, which makes their separate effects hard to untangle.
Working conditions abroad
Factory wages in many low-income countries are a small fraction of US wages, and conditions can be unsafe: the 2013 Rana Plaza collapse in Bangladesh killed more than 1,100 garment workers. It helps to separate the morally unacceptable, such as forced labour and exploitative child labour, from the merely uncomfortable, such as low pay that still beats a worker's other options. Most people support banning imports made with forced labour, as US law does. For low pay, the usual alternatives to a factory job are worse, so blocking imports may hurt the workers it aims to help; enforceable minimum standards are the better target.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming trade lowers total employment: it mainly changes the mix of jobs. Second, counting jobs saved by protection while ignoring jobs lost in user industries and exporters. Third, judging protection by its effect on one industry's wages rather than on average real wages, including lower prices. Fourth, the opposite error: treating average gains as proof that nobody loses, when the China shock shows local losses can be deep and lasting. Fifth, lumping all poor working conditions together instead of distinguishing forced labour from low pay.
Key takeaways
Trade changes which jobs exist far more than how many. Protection saves jobs in one industry at the cost of jobs elsewhere, often at a consumer cost per job many times the wage. Trade raises average real wages through specialisation and cheaper imports, but workers in import-competing industries and places can lose heavily and for years. On conditions abroad, forced and exploitative child labour justify trade action; low pay is better addressed through enforceable standards than through blocking imports.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Effect on workers on average versus on particular workers
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A tariff raises consumer spending by $720 million a year and saves 1,600 jobs paying $40,000 each. What is the cost per job saved?
Question 2 of 5
Why does protecting one industry not raise a country's total employment?
Question 3 of 5
According to the reading, how does trade affect wages in an economy?
Question 4 of 5
What did research on the China shock find about US job losses from Chinese imports after about 2000?
Question 5 of 5
A campaign urges a ban on imports from factories paying very low wages. What does the reading suggest?
