Microeconomics › Section T · Globalization and protectionism › Topic T.4
How trade policy is made
Trade rules are set in three arenas at once: global agreements through the World Trade Organization, regional deals between groups of countries, and national laws and agencies. Knowing who decides, and under what authority, explains much of the trade news since 2018.
Three arenas
Trade policy is made at three levels that constantly interact. Globally, members of the World Trade Organization (WTO) negotiate shared rules and settle disputes. Regionally, groups of countries sign agreements that cut barriers among themselves further than WTO rules require. Nationally, legislatures pass trade laws and government agencies apply them, deciding on particular tariffs, quotas and anti-dumping duties. A tariff that appears in the news has usually passed through national law, and whether it is allowed may depend on both regional and global commitments.
From GATT to the WTO
After the Second World War, 23 countries signed the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1947. It rested on two principles that the WTO keeps. Most-favoured-nation treatment means a member must offer every other member the lowest tariff it offers any of them. National treatment means imported goods, once inside, must be treated no worse than domestic goods. Members also bind their tariffs, promising not to raise them above agreed ceilings. Exceptions allow regional free trade agreements, special treatment for developing countries, and measures such as anti-dumping duties. Eight rounds of GATT talks cut tariffs steeply, and the Uruguay Round created the WTO in 1995.
The WTO today
In 2025 the WTO had 166 members, covering nearly all world trade. It is not a world government: decisions are taken by consensus, and its secretariat is small. Its distinctive feature was a strong dispute system, in which panels rule on complaints and an Appellate Body hears appeals. Since December 2019 the Appellate Body has been unable to hear appeals, because the United States has blocked new appointments, arguing that it overstepped its role. A losing party can now appeal "into the void", leaving the case unresolved, although some members, including the EU and China, use an interim appeal arrangement among themselves.
Regional agreements
Regional deals come in increasing depths of integration. A free trade agreement removes tariffs among members, but each keeps its own tariffs on outsiders, as in the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), which replaced NAFTA in July 2020. A customs union adds a common external tariff, as in Mercosur in South America. A common market also lets labour and capital move freely. An economic union coordinates economic policy too; the European Union is the main example, and most of its members share the euro. Large newer deals include the CPTPP among Pacific countries and the RCEP in Asia. The economist Jagdish Bhagwati called the tangle of overlapping deals a "spaghetti bowl".
Worked example: trade diversion
Home charges a 50% tariff on widgets from everyone. Country A can make a widget for $10 and Country B for $8. 1. Before any agreement: B's widgets cost \(8 \times 1.5 = 12\) dollars in Home and A's cost 15, so Home buys from B and collects $4 a unit in revenue. 2. Home signs a free trade agreement with A only. A's widgets now enter tariff-free at $10, cheaper than B's $12, so Home switches to A. 3. On each unit already bought, consumers save $2, but the government loses $4 of revenue. 4. Net effect: a loss of $2 a unit, because Home now buys from a higher-cost producer. 5. Check: this is trade diversion. Trade creation, the opposite case, is when an agreement replaces costlier domestic production with cheaper imports from a partner.
The national level in the United States
The US Constitution gives Congress the power to lay duties. Since the 1930s Congress has delegated much of that power to the president through statutes. Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 allows tariffs on imports that threaten national security, after a Commerce Department investigation. The Trade Act of 1974 allows safeguard tariffs against import surges (Section 201), action against unfair foreign practices (Section 301), and a temporary tariff of up to 15% for up to 150 days (Section 122). The Commerce Department and the International Trade Commission run anti-dumping cases, and Congress approves trade agreements, sometimes under a fast-track procedure.
Worked example: tracing a tariff's authority
Follow the legal path of recent US tariffs. 1. Steel: in 2018 the president used Section 232, on national security grounds, to impose a 25% tariff, raised to 50% in June 2025. 2. Broad 2025 tariffs: the 10% baseline and higher country-specific rates were imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), a 1977 law that does not mention tariffs. 3. Importers sued, and lower courts ruled against the tariffs. 4. On 20 February 2026 the Supreme Court held, 6 to 3, that IEEPA does not authorise tariffs. 5. The administration then imposed a temporary 10% global tariff under Section 122 from 24 February 2026 and used Sections 232 and 301 for further measures. 6. Check: the law chosen determines how long a tariff can last and how easily courts can review it.
Why countries tie their own hands
Why would a government sign agreements that stop it protecting its own industries? One answer lies in political economy. The benefits of protection are concentrated on a few organised producers, while the costs are spread thinly over millions of consumers who rarely lobby. Agreements let politicians resist pressure, since the treaty forbids the tariff. Reciprocity helps too: when foreign markets open in return, exporters lobby for the deal and balance the import-competing industries that oppose it. For about seventy years after 1947 this bargain drove tariffs steadily down, before the reversal that began in 2018.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the WTO can impose policy on members: it works by consensus, and its rulings depend on members complying. Second, confusing a free trade agreement with a customs union: only the customs union has a common external tariff. Third, assuming every regional agreement raises welfare: trade diversion can make a member worse off. Fourth, believing the US president has unlimited tariff power: it rests on specific laws passed by Congress, which courts can review, as the 2026 ruling showed. Fifth, treating most-favoured-nation status as special favouritism: it means equal treatment.
Key takeaways
Trade policy is made globally through the WTO, regionally through agreements and nationally through law. GATT and the WTO rest on most-favoured-nation treatment, national treatment and bound tariffs; the WTO's appeal system has been stalled since 2019. Regional integration runs from free trade agreements through customs unions and common markets to economic unions, and can divert trade as well as create it. In the United States, tariff power belongs to Congress and is delegated by statute; in 2026 the Supreme Court ruled that IEEPA does not authorise tariffs.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Global, regional and national trade policy
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does the WTO's most-favoured-nation principle require?
Question 2 of 5
What does a customs union have that a free trade agreement does not?
Question 3 of 5
Home charges a 20% tariff on all imports. An outside country makes a good for $10 and a partner for $11. After Home signs a free trade deal with the partner, what is the net effect per unit already bought?
Question 4 of 5
What did the US Supreme Court decide in February 2026 about the broad tariffs imposed in 2025?
Question 5 of 5
Why might a government sign a trade agreement that limits its own power to protect industries?
