Philosophy › Section B · Critical thinking, reading, and writing › Topic B.3

Developing good habits of mind

Biases cannot be switched off, but they can be outflanked. A handful of deliberate habits, practised until they become routine, make your thinking fairer, more testable and more honest about its limits.

Habits, not quick fixes

The topic Overcoming cognitive biases ended with a sobering point: knowing the names of biases does little on its own. What helps is changing how you work. This topic gathers habits that philosophers have long relied on: stepping back from your own circumstances, building the strongest case for views you reject, hunting for counterexamples, treating strong feelings as data to examine, and holding beliefs with the confidence the evidence allows. They overlap with the methods in How philosophers arrive at truth. None is a guarantee; each makes errors easier to catch.

Stepping back from your circumstances

We tend to assume that our experience is typical. If you think about fair government, you will probably picture the institutions of your own country and era, though people have governed themselves in many other ways. Abstraction means deliberately setting aside the details of your situation to see whether your view still holds in general. But abstraction has limits. Philosophy, like other fields, has been written mostly by members of dominant groups, and the experience of people from marginalised groups can reveal problems that the general picture missed. The skill is judging which particulars are distorting your view and which are evidence it needs.

Steelmanning and charity

A straw man is a weakened version of an opponent's view, built to be knocked down; the topic Informal fallacies treats it as a fallacy. The opposite habit is steelmanning: stating the view you disagree with in the strongest form you can, ideally so well that its defenders would accept your summary. It is closely related to the principle of charity, interpreting others' words in their most reasonable sense. Steelmanning is not agreeing. It ensures that if you reject a view, you reject its best version, and it often shows you something your own position lacked.

Counterexamples

Many philosophical claims are general: every case of knowledge is like this, nothing is art unless that. A counterexample is a case that meets the conditions a claim lays down but lacks the feature it says must follow. Against a truly universal claim, one solid counterexample is enough to show the claim false as stated. That makes counterexamples one of philosophy's most powerful tools, and the topic Arguments, validity, and soundness shows how they test arguments as well as claims. The response to a good counterexample is rarely to give up; it is to revise the claim so that it survives.

Worked example: testing a definition

Claim: something is a work of art only if it took great skill to make. 1. Structure: this is universal, so a single case of art made without great skill would refute it. 2. Candidate: in 1917 Marcel Duchamp submitted a mass-produced urinal, signed "R. Mutt" and titled Fountain, for exhibition. It is now widely treated as an important artwork, yet its making required little craft. 3. Replies: a defender may deny that Fountain is art, or argue that choosing and presenting it took a different, conceptual skill. 4. Assessment: the first reply rejects much of what the art world counts as art; the second changes what "skill" means. 5. Lesson: either way the claim must be revised, so even a disputed counterexample moves the debate forward.

Handling strong emotions

Emotions are part of good reasoning, as The brain as an inference machine showed, but a strong reaction to a claim can stop you from weighing it. When an argument makes you angry or delighted, treat the feeling as a signal to examine. Ask what lies beneath it: a reason, such as a value the argument threatens, or only a sense of being challenged? The reason, not the feeling, counts philosophically. Pause before replying, or swap the emotive details of an example for neutral ones and see whether your judgement changes.

Epistemic humility

Epistemic humility is recognising the limits of what you know: your perspective is shaped by your time and place, your reasoning is open to bias, and even the best current science leaves much unexplained. Intellectual humility, the related trait of owning the limits of your own views, has been linked in recent research to more careful weighing of evidence, though this work is still young. Humility does not mean having no views; it means matching your confidence to your evidence, checking base rates (how common something is in general) before judging a single case, being able to say "I don't know", and asking in advance what evidence would change your mind. If the answer is "nothing", you are holding a commitment, not a conclusion.

Where did that belief come from?

Beliefs arrive from perception, memory, testimony and imagination, and we often forget which. Repetition makes this worse: in studies of the illusory truth effect, first reported by Lynn Hasher and colleagues in 1977, statements people had seen before were rated as more likely to be true, regardless of their accuracy. The popular claim that we use only 10% of our brains survives this way, although brain imaging shows activity throughout the brain. A useful habit is to ask of any confident belief: where did I get this, and would that source convince me now?

The Dunning-Kruger effect

In 1999 Justin Kruger and David Dunning reported that participants who scored lowest on tests of logic, grammar and humour greatly overestimated how well they had done compared with others, while top scorers slightly underestimated themselves. Their explanation was that the skills needed to do a task well are also needed to judge how well you did it. Later critics argued that part of the pattern is a statistical artefact, produced by regression to the mean together with most people's tendency to rate themselves above average; how much of the effect remains is still debated. The practical lesson survives: in a field new to you, your sense of your own competence is an unreliable guide.

Worked example: auditing a belief

Jo believes that sugar makes children hyperactive. Apply the habits. 1. Source: she heard it from other parents and has seen lively children at birthday parties. 2. Alternative explanation: parties are exciting whatever is eaten, so the observation fits other causes. 3. Better evidence: double-blind experiments, in which neither children nor observers knew who had sugar, have generally found no effect on behaviour, and a 1995 review of such studies agreed. 4. Emotion check: does she resist the result because it contradicts what she has always "seen"? 5. What would change her mind? Well-controlled studies showing an effect. 6. Verdict: hold the belief much less firmly, or drop it.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, steelmanning only in name: a summary the other side would reject is a straw man. Second, thinking abstraction always helps: sometimes the particular experience is the evidence. Third, giving up a claim at the first counterexample instead of testing the counterexample and revising. Fourth, treating humility as having no opinions. Fifth, taking a feeling of certainty as evidence, especially for things heard many times. Sixth, quoting the Dunning-Kruger effect as settled science, or using it to dismiss other people rather than to check yourself.

Key takeaways

Step back from your own circumstances, but notice when particular experience is the evidence. Steelman opposing views and read them charitably. Test general claims with counterexamples, then revise rather than abandon. Treat strong emotions as signals and look for the reasons beneath them. Practise epistemic humility: match confidence to evidence, say "I don't know", and ask what would change your mind. Check where beliefs came from, since repetition breeds false confidence. The Dunning-Kruger effect is debated, but self-assessment in a new field is unreliable.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Abstraction

Setting aside the details of your own situation to test a view in general

Beyond your own country and era.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these is the best example of steelmanning?

Question 2 of 5

Someone claims: "Every work of art took great skill to make." What would a counterexample need to be?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement best reflects current views of the Dunning-Kruger effect?

Question 4 of 5

Why does the illusory truth effect matter for epistemic humility?

Question 5 of 5

A student says no possible evidence could change her view on a factual question. What does this suggest?

← Previous topicNext topic →