Physics › Section L · Sound and hearing › Topic L.4

Standing waves in air columns

Blow across the open end of an empty pen cap and it sings one clear note. Air trapped in a tube can only vibrate at certain frequencies, and those frequencies, fixed by the tube's length and whether its ends are open or closed, are what give flutes, clarinets and organ pipes their notes.

Why a tube picks out notes

Sound travelling along a tube reflects at each end, from a closed end and also from an open one, where for a narrow tube only a small part of the energy escapes. The outgoing and reflected waves overlap and superpose. At most frequencies the many reflections arrive out of step and largely cancel, so the air barely responds. At a few special frequencies every reflection arrives in step with the next wave, they reinforce one another, and a large standing wave builds up. This is resonance, and those special frequencies are the natural frequencies of the air column.

Nodes and antinodes in air

A standing wave has displacement nodes, where the air does not move, and displacement antinodes, where it moves the most, a quarter of a wavelength apart. The ends of a tube decide where they sit. At a closed end the air is pressed against a wall and cannot move, so there is always a displacement node. At an open end the air is free to move in and out, so there is a displacement antinode. In fact the antinode sits slightly beyond the open end, a small end correction this topic ignores unless stated. Pressure behaves the opposite way: a closed end is where the pressure swings most, and an open end stays close to atmospheric pressure.

Tubes closed at one end

With a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, the simplest pattern fits exactly a quarter of a wavelength in the tube: \(L = \lambda/4\). The next pattern adds one more node, giving \(L = 3\lambda/4\), then \(5\lambda/4\), and so on. In general \(\lambda_n = 4L/n\), and using \(f = v/\lambda\):

f_n = \frac{nv}{4L}, \quad n = 1, 3, 5, \ldots

Only odd multiples of the lowest frequency appear. The lowest, \(f_1 = v/4L\), is the fundamental, or first harmonic. Every other natural frequency is a whole-number multiple of it, and the next one up, \(3f_1\), is the third harmonic: the even harmonics are missing.

Worked example: tuning a closed pipe

An organ builder needs a pipe closed at one end whose fundamental is middle C, 262 Hz, in air at 20 °C. How long must it be, and what are its next two natural frequencies? Ignore the end correction. 1. Speed of sound: \(v = 343\) m/s. 2. For the fundamental, \(L = \lambda/4\), so \(L = v/(4f_1) = 343/(4 \times 262) = 0.327\) m. 3. Only odd harmonics exist, so the next two are \(3f_1 = 786\) Hz and \(5f_1 = 1{,}310\) Hz. 4. Check: \(\lambda = 4L = 1.31\) m, and \(f\lambda = 262 \times 1.31 = 343\) m/s, the speed of sound, as it must be.

Tubes open at both ends

A tube open at both ends has a displacement antinode at each end. The simplest pattern has one node in the middle, so half a wavelength fits: \(L = \lambda/2\). The next fits a whole wavelength, then one and a half, and so on: \(\lambda_n = 2L/n\) and

f_n = \frac{nv}{2L}, \quad n = 1, 2, 3, \ldots

Every harmonic is present, even and odd. A string fixed at both ends has the same set of frequencies: its ends are nodes rather than antinodes, but they are still alike, so whole half-wavelengths fit. Compared with a closed tube of the same length, the open tube's fundamental is twice as high, since \(v/2L\) is twice \(v/4L\).

Worked example: an open pipe and a closed one

A pipe 0.600 m long is open at both ends, in air at 20 °C. Find its first three natural frequencies, then the fundamental if one end is stopped. 1. Open at both ends: \(f_1 = v/2L = 343/(2 \times 0.600) = 286\) Hz. 2. All harmonics occur: \(f_2 = 572\) Hz and \(f_3 = 858\) Hz. 3. Closed at one end: \(f_1 = v/4L = 343/(4 \times 0.600) = 143\) Hz. 4. Check: stopping one end doubles the wavelength of the fundamental, from 1.20 m to 2.40 m, so the frequency halves, from 286 Hz to 143 Hz. Stopping an end lowers the note by an octave.

Harmonics, overtones and timbre

A real instrument sounds its fundamental, which usually sets the pitch you hear, together with higher natural frequencies called overtones. The first overtone is the next natural frequency above the fundamental: the second harmonic in an open tube but the third harmonic in a closed one, so overtone numbers and harmonic numbers do not always match. The mix of overtones and their strengths gives each instrument its timbre, the quality that lets you tell a flute from a clarinet playing the same note. A flute acts roughly as a tube open at both ends; a clarinet behaves much like a tube closed at its reed end, so its low notes are rich in odd harmonics.

Worked example: measuring the speed of sound

A 512 Hz tuning fork is held over a glass tube whose lower end dips into water, making a closed tube of adjustable length. As the tube is raised, loud resonances occur at air-column lengths of 15.5 cm and 49.0 cm. Find the speed of sound. 1. Neighbouring resonances of a closed tube differ by half a wavelength: from \(\lambda/4\) to \(3\lambda/4\). 2. So \(\lambda/2 = 49.0 - 15.5 = 33.5\) cm, and \(\lambda = 0.670\) m. 3. Speed: \(v = f\lambda = 512 \times 0.670 = 343\) m/s. 4. Check: \(\lambda/4 = 16.75\) cm, a little more than 15.5 cm. The gap is the end correction, which taking the difference of two lengths cancels.

Temperature and tuning

The natural frequencies of an air column are proportional to the speed of sound, and that speed rises with temperature. So a wind instrument plays sharp, slightly higher in pitch, when its air is warm and flat when it is cold. A pipe that sounds 440 Hz at 20 °C would sound \(440\sqrt{303/293} = 447\) Hz at 30 °C, a difference a trained ear notices at once. This is why wind players warm their instruments by blowing through them before tuning.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, putting a node at an open end: open ends are displacement antinodes, closed ends are displacement nodes. Second, using \(f_n = nv/2L\) for a closed tube, or allowing even harmonics in one; a closed tube has only odd harmonics, \(f_n = nv/4L\). Third, confusing overtones with harmonics: in a closed tube the first overtone is the third harmonic. Fourth, forgetting that a closed tube's fundamental is half that of an open tube of the same length. Fifth, in a resonance-tube experiment, taking the first resonance length as exactly \(\lambda/4\) without allowing for the end correction; use the difference between two lengths, which is \(\lambda/2\).

Key takeaways

Reflections in a tube interfere to form standing waves only at its natural frequencies, the resonances. Closed ends are displacement nodes and open ends are displacement antinodes. A tube closed at one end fits odd quarter-wavelengths: f_n = nv/4L with n = 1, 3, 5, so only odd harmonics occur. A tube open at both ends fits whole half-wavelengths: f_n = nv/2L with n = 1, 2, 3, and its fundamental is twice that of a closed tube of equal length. Overtones are the natural frequencies above the fundamental, and their mix sets timbre. Warmer air raises every natural frequency.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Natural frequencies

The frequencies at which an air column resonates

Set by its length and its ends.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A tube 0.250 m long is closed at one end. With sound at 343 m/s, what is its fundamental frequency?

Question 2 of 5

A tube closed at one end has a fundamental of 200 Hz. Which list gives its three lowest natural frequencies?

Question 3 of 5

How long must a tube open at both ends be for its fundamental to be 440 Hz, with sound at 343 m/s?

Question 4 of 5

A pipe open at both ends has its fundamental at 300 Hz. One end is then closed. What is the new fundamental?

Question 5 of 5

In a resonance-tube experiment with a 520 Hz tuning fork, two neighbouring resonance lengths differ by 0.330 m. What is the speed of sound?

← Previous topicNext topic →