Physics › Section V · Nuclear physics and its applications › Topic V.4
Binding energy and tunneling
A nucleus has less mass than the protons and neutrons that make it, and that missing mass measures how tightly it is held together. One curve of binding energy explains why both fission and fusion release energy, and quantum tunnelling explains how an alpha particle escapes a nucleus at all.
Lighter than its parts
Put 8 protons and 8 neutrons on a balance and they have more mass than the oxygen-16 nucleus they form. The difference is the mass defect, \(\Delta m\). When nucleons come together, the strong force pulls them into a lower energy state and the surplus energy is given off, so by \(E = mc^2\) the bound nucleus must have less mass. To pull the nucleus apart again, the same energy must be supplied. That energy is the binding energy, BE: the work needed to separate a nucleus completely into free protons and neutrons. It is a property of the nucleus, not something stored inside it that can be taken out.
Calculating the binding energy
Tables list atomic masses, which include the electrons. Count each proton as a hydrogen-1 atom, 1.007825 u, so that its electron is included, and each neutron as 1.008665 u; then the electrons cancel against those in the neutral atom:
With masses in u, \(c^2\) is replaced by 931.5 MeV/u. To compare nuclei of different sizes, divide by the mass number to get the binding energy per nucleon, BE/A. The larger BE/A is, the more tightly each nucleon is held and the more stable the nucleus is against breaking up.
Worked example: oxygen-16
An oxygen-16 atom has a mass of 15.994915 u. Find its binding energy and its binding energy per nucleon. 1. Count: \(Z = 8\) and \(N = 16 - 8 = 8\). 2. Mass of the separate parts:
3. Mass defect: subtracting 15.994915 u gives \(\Delta m = 0.137005\) u. 4. Binding energy: \(0.137005 \times 931.5 = 127.6\) MeV. 5. Per nucleon: \(127.6 \div 16 = 7.98\) MeV. 6. Check: the mass defect is under 1% of the mass, as for every nucleus. Compare deuterium, \({}^{2}\mathrm{H}\), whose single proton and neutron are bound by only 2.22 MeV, or 1.11 MeV per nucleon.
The curve of binding energy
Plot BE/A against \(A\) for all nuclei and a striking shape appears. It climbs steeply through the light nuclei, from 1.11 MeV for deuterium, with helium-4 standing out at 7.07 MeV. It reaches a broad peak of about 8.8 MeV per nucleon near \(A = 60\): nickel-62, at 8.79 MeV, is the most tightly bound nucleus of all, with iron-58 and iron-56 only a whisker lower. Beyond the peak the curve falls slowly, to about 7.6 MeV for uranium. Beyond the lightest few, nearly all nuclei lie between about 7.5 and 8.8 MeV per nucleon, so total binding energy is roughly proportional to the number of nucleons.
Why the curve has this shape
The strong force reaches only nearest neighbours. In a small nucleus a large share of the nucleons sit at the surface with fewer neighbours to bind them, so BE/A is low; as nuclei grow, the surface share falls and BE/A rises. Each proton, though, repels every other proton in the nucleus, not just its neighbours. That repulsion grows roughly as \(Z^2\), faster than the number of nucleons, and in heavy nuclei it starts to win, pulling BE/A down. The peak near iron and nickel is the best balance between these two effects. Extra neutrons dilute the repulsion, but adding them has limits, which is why the heaviest nuclei are all unstable.
Worked example: why splitting uranium releases energy
Uranium-238 has an atomic mass of 238.050787 u, and nuclei near \(A = 120\) have BE/A of about 8.5 MeV. Estimate the energy released if a uranium nucleus split into two such halves. 1. Parts:
2. Subtracting 238.050787 u leaves a mass defect of 1.934203 u. 3. BE: \(1.934203 \times 931.5 = 1802\) MeV, so BE/A \(= 1802 \div 238 = 7.57\) MeV. 4. The fragments together would have BE \(\approx 238 \times 8.5 = 2023\) MeV. 5. Energy released \(\approx 2023 - 1802 \approx 220\) MeV, roughly 200 MeV. Check: real fissions release about 200 MeV, confirming that moving up the curve, towards the peak, is what releases energy.
Barriers and tunnelling
In classical physics, a ball rolling towards a hill with too little energy to reach the top simply rolls back. Quantum particles are described by waves, and a wave meeting a barrier does not stop dead at its edge: it dies away inside and, if the barrier is thin enough, a small part emerges on the far side. So a particle has a small but real probability of appearing beyond a barrier it could never climb. This is quantum tunnelling. The probability depends extremely strongly on the barrier: a little higher or wider can cut the chance by many powers of ten. Electrons tunnelling across a tiny gap let a scanning tunnelling microscope image single atoms.
Worked example: the barrier around polonium-210
An alpha particle leaving polonium-210 is pushed away by the 82 protons of the lead-206 nucleus left behind. Estimate the height of this Coulomb barrier where the two nuclei just touch. 1. Add the two radii:
2. Electric potential energy of charges \(2e\) and \(82e\):
3. \(U = 4.21 \times 10^{-12}\) J; dividing by \(1.602 \times 10^{-13}\) J per MeV gives 26.3 MeV. 4. Compare: the alpha comes out with only 5.30 MeV, a fifth of the barrier height. Classically it could never escape. It leaves only by tunnelling, after striking the barrier an enormous number of times.
Tunnelling and alpha half-lives
Because tunnelling depends so sensitively on energy, small differences in alpha energy produce huge differences in half-life. A more energetic alpha meets a barrier that is thinner at its energy, so it escapes far more easily. Polonium-212 emits alphas of 8.79 MeV and has a half-life of 0.29 microseconds. Thorium-232 emits alphas of 4.01 MeV and has a half-life of \(1.40 \times 10^{10}\) years. Roughly halving the energy lengthens the half-life by a factor of about \(10^{24}\). Tunnelling works the other way round in the Sun, where protons that lack the energy to overcome their mutual repulsion still occasionally tunnel close enough to fuse.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking binding energy is energy a nucleus contains and can release; it is the energy needed to take it apart, and a larger BE means a more stable nucleus. Second, mixing atomic and nuclear masses: use hydrogen-1 atoms with atomic masses, so the electrons cancel. Third, comparing total binding energies instead of BE/A; uranium has a far larger total BE than iron but is less tightly bound per nucleon. Fourth, thinking an alpha particle needs enough energy to clear the barrier; it tunnels through. Fifth, dropping the factor of 2 in the alpha particle's charge.
Key takeaways
A nucleus has less mass than its separate nucleons; the mass defect times 931.5 MeV/u is the binding energy, the energy needed to pull it apart. BE = [Z m(¹H) + N mₙ − m(atom)]c² with atomic masses. BE/A rises steeply for light nuclei, peaks at about 8.8 MeV near A = 60 (nickel-62 and iron-56), and falls to about 7.6 MeV for uranium, so fission of heavy nuclei and fusion of light ones both release energy. Alpha particles escape by tunnelling through a Coulomb barrier several times higher than their energy, and higher alpha energies mean vastly shorter half-lives.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Mass of the separate nucleons minus the mass of the nucleus
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A lithium-7 atom (Z = 3) has a mass of 7.016003 u. Using m(¹H) = 1.007825 u and mₙ = 1.008665 u, what is its binding energy per nucleon?
Question 2 of 5
Which nucleus has the largest binding energy per nucleon?
Question 3 of 5
Why does the binding energy per nucleon fall for the heaviest nuclei?
Question 4 of 5
Estimate the Coulomb barrier for an alpha particle (charge 2e) touching a daughter nucleus of charge 90e at a centre separation of 9.0 fm. (k = 8.99 × 10⁹ N·m²/C², e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C)
Question 5 of 5
Two nuclides decay by alpha emission. Nuclide P emits 8 MeV alphas and nuclide Q emits 4 MeV alphas. What do you expect?
