Physics › Section U · Quantum and atomic physics › Topic U.4
Discovering the atom and its parts
No one can see an atom with visible light, yet by 1911 physicists knew that atoms exist, how big they are, and that each holds tiny electrons around an even tinier nucleus. The experiments that showed it used nothing more than the electric and magnetic forces you already know.
An old idea, indirect evidence
Greek thinkers such as Democritus argued in the fifth century BCE that matter ends in uncuttable atoms, but they had no way to test it. By the early 1800s John Dalton had explained why elements combine in fixed mass ratios, strong indirect evidence for atoms. Mendeleev's periodic table of 1869 and the success of the kinetic theory of gases pointed the same way. Still, some leading scientists doubted that atoms were real until the early twentieth century.
Brownian motion: the first direct evidence
In 1827 the botanist Robert Brown saw tiny particles released from pollen grains jiggling endlessly in water under a microscope. This Brownian motion happens because the particle is struck from all sides by water molecules, and at any instant the hits on one side slightly outnumber those on the other. In 1905 Albert Einstein worked out how far such a particle should wander, which depends on the size and number of the molecules. Around 1908 Jean Perrin measured the motion, confirmed Einstein's theory and obtained accurate values for molecular sizes and Avogadro's number. Today scanning tunnelling microscopes image individual atoms directly.
Cathode rays
In a glass tube pumped nearly empty, a high voltage makes a beam stream from the negative electrode, the cathode, and glass it strikes glows. William Crookes and others found that these cathode rays travel in straight lines, casting sharp shadows, and bend in a magnetic field the way negative charges should. In 1897 J. J. Thomson deflected them with an electric field too and collected them in a metal cup, which gained negative charge. He found the same particles whatever gas or electrode metal he used, so they had to be a part of every atom. They are electrons.
Measuring e/m
Thomson could not measure the charge or mass of one electron, but he could measure their ratio. First, a velocity selector of crossed fields picks one speed: the beam passes straight through when \(eE = evB\), so \(v = E/B\). Then, with the magnetic field alone, the beam bends into a circle of radius \(r = mv/(eB)\), as in the earlier topic on the force on a moving charge. Rearranging gives
The modern value is \(1.759 \times 10^{11}\) C/kg. Hydrogen ions have a charge-to-mass ratio 1836 times smaller, so if their charges are equal in size, the electron is about 1836 times lighter than a proton.
Worked example: Thomson's ratio
An electron beam passes undeflected through crossed fields \(E = 2.00 \times 10^4\) V/m and \(B = 1.00 \times 10^{-3}\) T. With the electric field switched off, the beam curves in a circle of radius 11.4 cm. Find the electron speed and e/m. 1. Velocity selector: \(v = E/B\), which is \(2.00 \times 10^7\) m/s. 2. Magnetic bending: \(e/m = v/(Br)\). 3. Substitute, with r = 0.114 m:
4. Check: this matches the accepted \(1.76 \times 10^{11}\) C/kg to the precision of r. The speed is under 7% of c, so non-relativistic formulas are fine.
Millikan's oil drops
From 1909 Robert Millikan sprayed fine oil drops between two horizontal metal plates a distance \(d\) apart. Some drops picked up charge, and he adjusted the voltage \(V\) until the upward electric force held a drop still against its weight: \(qE = mg\), with \(E = V/d\). So
He found each drop's mass from how fast it fell with the voltage off, since tiny drops quickly reach a terminal speed set by air resistance. Every charge was a whole-number multiple of one value, the elementary charge \(e = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\) C: charge is quantised. Dividing \(e\) by e/m gives the electron mass, \(9.109 \times 10^{-31}\) kg.
Worked example: counting electrons on a drop
An oil drop of mass \(2.00 \times 10^{-15}\) kg is held motionless between plates 1.00 cm apart when the voltage is 408 V, with the upper plate positive. Find its charge and the number of excess electrons. 1. Balance: \(q = mgd/V\), with d = 0.0100 m. 2. Substitute:
3. Number of electrons: \(q/e = 3.00\). 4. Check: a whole number, as quantised charge requires. The drop is negative, so the upward field force from the positive upper plate makes sense.
Rutherford scattering
Thomson pictured the atom as a sphere of spread-out positive charge with electrons dotted through it, the plum pudding model. To test it, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, working under Ernest Rutherford, fired alpha particles, helium nuclei with energies of several MeV from a radioactive source, at gold foil less than a micrometre thick. Spread-out charge could only nudge such fast, heavy particles. Most did pass straight through, but in 1909 they reported that a few were deflected through large angles, and a very small fraction bounced back towards the source. Rutherford later compared it to firing a large shell at tissue paper and having it come back.
The nuclear atom
In 1911 Rutherford explained the results. All of an atom's positive charge and nearly all its mass sit in a tiny nucleus, and the electrons occupy the space far around it. An alpha particle that heads almost straight for a nucleus meets an enormous repulsive Coulomb force and turns back; most miss every nucleus by a wide margin. Later measurements put nuclei at about \(10^{-15}\) to \(10^{-14}\) m across, while atoms are about \(10^{-10}\) m, so an atom is mostly empty space and nuclear matter has a density of about \(2 \times 10^{17}\ \text{kg/m}^3\). Rutherford's planetary model pictured electrons orbiting the nucleus, held by the Coulomb force as planets are held by gravity.
Worked example: how small is the nucleus?
A 5.0 MeV alpha particle, charge +2e, heads straight for a gold nucleus, charge +79e. How close can it get? 1. At closest approach it stops for an instant, so all its kinetic energy has become electric potential energy, \(kq_1q_2/r\). 2. Kinetic energy in joules: 5.0 MeV is \(8.01 \times 10^{-13}\) J. 3. Solve for r, taking the gold nucleus as fixed:
4. Interpret: because such alphas bounce back as predicted, the gold nucleus must be smaller than this, thousands of times smaller than the atom.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Thomson measured the electron's charge; he measured only e/m, and Millikan supplied e. Second, writing \(v = B/E\) for the velocity selector instead of \(E/B\). Third, leaving plate separations in centimetres or alpha energies in eV when using SI formulas. Fourth, forgetting that an alpha particle carries charge +2e, not +e. Fifth, concluding from the gold foil that atoms are solid; most alphas passed straight through, showing mostly empty space. Sixth, treating the planetary model as final; the next topic shows why Bohr had to change it.
Key takeaways
Mass ratios and kinetic theory gave indirect evidence for atoms; Brownian motion, explained by Einstein and measured by Perrin, gave direct evidence. Thomson's cathode rays showed that every atom contains electrons, and crossed fields gave e/m = E/(B²r) = 1.759 × 10¹¹ C/kg. Millikan's oil drops, q = mgd/V, showed that charge is quantised in units of e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C, giving m_e = 9.109 × 10⁻³¹ kg. Rutherford's alpha scattering showed a tiny, dense, positive nucleus holding nearly all the mass, about 10⁻¹⁵ to 10⁻¹⁴ m across inside an atom about 10⁻¹⁰ m across. His planetary model had electrons orbiting that nucleus.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The random jiggling of small particles in a fluid, caused by molecular collisions
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Thomson found that cathode-ray particles have a charge-to-mass ratio about 1800 times that of hydrogen ions. Assuming the charges are equal in size, what does this show?
Question 2 of 5
An oil drop of mass 1.0 × 10⁻¹⁵ kg is held still between plates 1.50 cm apart by a voltage of 459 V. What is its charge? Use g = 9.80 m/s².
Question 3 of 5
In the gold foil experiment, what did the few alpha particles that bounced back towards the source reveal?
Question 4 of 5
A 7.7 MeV alpha particle (charge +2e) heads straight for a fixed gold nucleus (charge +79e). What is its distance of closest approach? Use k = 8.99 × 10⁹ N·m²/C².
Question 5 of 5
An electron beam passes undeflected through crossed fields of 3.0 × 10⁴ V/m and 2.0 mT. What is the electrons' speed?
