Physics › Section F · Momentum and collisions › Topic F.4

Inelastic collisions in one dimension

Most real collisions are inelastic: momentum survives, but some kinetic energy turns into heat, sound and crumpled metal. When the objects stick together the loss is as large as momentum conservation allows, and calculating it explains crash design and the ballistic pendulum.

Collisions that lose energy

Catch a cricket ball, and ball and hands stop together. Drop a lump of modelling clay and it lands with a thud and stays put. Two railway wagons meet and couple. In every one of these, the total momentum of the isolated system is the same before and after, but the kinetic energy is not. Some of it has gone into warming the objects, making a noise and bending them out of shape. This topic shows how to find the final motion from momentum alone, and then how to calculate how much kinetic energy was lost.

Inelastic and perfectly inelastic

A collision is inelastic when the total kinetic energy afterwards differs from the total before. Usually it falls, as energy is converted into thermal energy, sound and permanent deformation. It can also rise when stored energy is released during the contact, such as a compressed spring between two carts; some books call that case superelastic. Momentum is still conserved in every case. When the objects stick together and move off as one, the collision is called perfectly inelastic. As the next cards show, sticking together removes more kinetic energy than any other outcome that conserves momentum.

Finding the common velocity

If two objects stick, there is only one final velocity, \(v'\), and momentum conservation alone is enough to find it:

m_1v_1 + m_2v_2 = (m_1 + m_2)v'

so

v' = \frac{m_1v_1 + m_2v_2}{m_1 + m_2}

This is the total momentum divided by the total mass, which is exactly the velocity of the centre of mass, unchanged by the collision. Signs matter as usual: give each velocity its sign along the chosen positive direction. Once \(v'\) is known, compare the kinetic energies before and after to find the loss.

Worked example: coupling railway wagons

A 12,000 kg wagon rolling at 2.50 m/s runs into an 8,000 kg wagon at rest, and they couple together. Assume the track is level and friction is negligible during the collision. 1.

v' = \frac{(12{,}000)(2.50)}{20{,}000} = 1.50\ \mathrm{m/s}

2. Kinetic energy before: \(\frac{1}{2}(12{,}000)(2.50)^2 = 37{,}500\) J. 3. After: \(\frac{1}{2}(20{,}000)(1.50)^2 = 22{,}500\) J. 4. Loss: 15,000 J, which is 40.0% of the original. 5. Check momentum: 30,000 kg·m/s before and \(20{,}000 \times 1.50 = 30{,}000\) kg m/s after. The lost energy goes into the couplings and buffers as heat and sound.

How much can be lost?

Momentum conservation sets a floor under the kinetic energy. After the collision the centre of mass must still move at \(\frac{p}{M}\), so the pair always keeps at least \(\frac{p^2}{2M}\) of kinetic energy, where \(M\) is the total mass. Sticking together leaves exactly this amount, which is why a perfectly inelastic collision loses the most. For a moving object hitting one at rest, \(KE = p^2/2m\) gives the fraction kept as

\frac{KE_f}{KE_i} = \frac{m_1}{m_1 + m_2}

For the wagons that is 12,000/20,000 = 60%, matching the example. If the total momentum is zero, all of the kinetic energy can be lost.

Worked example: a head-on trolley crash

A 1.20 kg trolley moving right at 3.00 m/s hits a 0.80 kg trolley moving left at 4.00 m/s, and they stick. Take right as positive. 1. Total momentum:

(1.20)(3.00) + (0.80)(-4.00) = 0.40\ \mathrm{kg\,m/s}

2. \(v' = \frac{0.40}{2.00} = 0.20\) m/s, to the right. 3. Kinetic energy before: \(5.40 + 6.40 = 11.8\) J. 4. After: \(\frac{1}{2}(2.00)(0.20)^2 = 0.040\) J. 5. Almost all of it, 11.76 J or 99.7%, is lost. Because the momenta nearly cancel, the wreck barely moves, so almost no kinetic energy can remain.

Worked example: the ballistic pendulum

A 0.00800 kg bullet embeds in a 1.50 kg wooden block hanging on light strings, and the block swings up 0.120 m. Find the bullet's speed. Use g = 9.80 m/s² and ignore air resistance. 1. The swing: mechanical energy is conserved after the impact, so \(\frac{1}{2}Mv'^2 = Mgh\) and

v' = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(9.80)(0.120)} = 1.534\ \mathrm{m/s}

2. The impact is perfectly inelastic, so use momentum: \(mv = (m + M)v'\), giving \(v = \frac{1.508}{0.00800} \times 1.534 = 289\) m/s. 3. Check: the fraction kept is \(\frac{0.00800}{1.508} = 0.53\%\), so energy conservation could never be used across the impact itself.

Between the extremes

Most collisions are neither elastic nor perfectly inelastic: the objects bounce apart, but more slowly. The coefficient of restitution, \(e\), measures this. It is the speed at which the objects separate divided by the speed at which they approach. For an elastic collision \(e = 1\); for a perfectly inelastic one \(e = 0\). For a ball dropped onto a hard floor, ignoring air resistance, it equals \(\sqrt{h'/h}\), where \(h\) is the drop height and \(h'\) the rebound height. A ball dropped from 1.25 m that rebounds to 0.80 m has \(e = 0.80\). Tennis balls, for instance, must pass a drop-and-rebound test of this kind.

Crashes and crumple zones

In a car crash, the kinetic energy that disappears has to go somewhere, and engineers decide where. Crumple zones are designed to absorb it by folding progressively, turning kinetic energy into the work of bending steel, so that less is left to deform the passenger compartment. The same folding lengthens the collision time, which, as the impulse topic showed, lowers the average force on the occupants. A car that crumples is not a weak car: it is spending the crash energy where it does the least harm.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming that momentum is lost when kinetic energy is lost; in an isolated system momentum is always conserved. Second, dividing by only one mass when objects stick; the final velocity uses \(m_1 + m_2\). Third, using energy conservation across the impact in a ballistic pendulum; it holds only during the swing afterwards. Fourth, forgetting that a velocity to the left is negative, which makes the total momentum too large. Fifth, squaring the final speed but not adding the masses when finding the final kinetic energy.

Key takeaways

An inelastic collision conserves momentum but not kinetic energy; most real collisions are inelastic. In a perfectly inelastic collision the objects stick, and the common velocity is v′ = (m₁v₁ + m₂v₂)/(m₁ + m₂), the centre-of-mass velocity. This loses the most kinetic energy that momentum allows; with the target at rest, the fraction kept is m₁/(m₁ + m₂). Always compute the kinetic energy before and after to find the loss. The ballistic pendulum uses momentum for the impact and energy for the swing. The coefficient of restitution runs from 0 for sticking to 1 for elastic.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Inelastic collision

Momentum conserved, total kinetic energy changes

Usually lost to heat, sound and deformation.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A 2000 kg car moving at 15 m/s hits a 1000 kg car at rest, and they lock together. What is their speed just after?

Question 2 of 5

A 4.0 kg cart at 5.0 m/s collides with a 1.0 kg cart at rest, and they stick. How much kinetic energy is lost?

Question 3 of 5

A puck slides into an identical puck at rest and they stick together. What fraction of the original kinetic energy remains?

Question 4 of 5

In a ballistic pendulum, why can't energy conservation be used to link the bullet's speed directly to the block's swing height?

Question 5 of 5

Two 1.5 kg carts move towards each other, each at 2.0 m/s, and stick together. What happens?

← Previous topicNext topic →