Physics › Section W · Particle physics and frontiers › Topic W.3
Quarks and grand unified theories
Hundreds of particles turned out to be built from just six kinds of quark, held together by a force so strong that no quark has ever been pulled free. The theory that describes them, the Standard Model, is one of the most precisely tested in science, and grand unified theories try to go one step further.
Order in the particle zoo
By the early 1960s accelerators had made so many hadrons that physicists spoke of a particle zoo, and patterns in their charges, strangeness and masses hinted that hadrons were not fundamental. In 1964 Murray Gell-Mann and George Zweig independently proposed that every hadron is built from a few smaller particles, which Gell-Mann named quarks. Leptons, by contrast, show no inner structure at all, down to at least \(10^{-18}\) m. A fundamental particle is one with no known parts, so today's list of fundamental matter particles is short: six quarks and six leptons, with their antiparticles.
Six flavours of quark
Quarks come in six types, called flavours, arranged in three generations. Each has spin 1/2, baryon number 1/3, and a charge that is a fraction of \(e\). First generation: up (u), charge \(+\tfrac{2}{3}e\), and down (d), \(-\tfrac{1}{3}e\). Second: charm (c), \(+\tfrac{2}{3}e\), and strange (s), \(-\tfrac{1}{3}e\). Third: top (t), \(+\tfrac{2}{3}e\), and bottom (b), \(-\tfrac{1}{3}e\). Each antiquark has the opposite charge and baryon number, and the strange quark carries strangeness −1. Approximate masses climb steeply: a few MeV/c² for u and d, about 95 MeV/c² for s, 1.3 GeV/c² for c, 4.2 GeV/c² for b and about 173 GeV/c² for t. Ordinary matter needs only up and down quarks.
Building hadrons
Two rules build every hadron. A baryon is three quarks (an antibaryon, three antiquarks), and a meson is one quark and one antiquark. The proton is uud, with charge \(\tfrac{2}{3} + \tfrac{2}{3} - \tfrac{1}{3} = +1\), and the neutron is udd, with charge 0. The positive pion is u d̄, with charge \(\tfrac{2}{3} + \tfrac{1}{3} = +1\) and baryon number \(\tfrac{1}{3} - \tfrac{1}{3} = 0\). The rules always give whole-number charges, so no free particle shows a fractional one. They also explain baryon number: three quarks give \(B = 1\), a quark-antiquark pair \(B = 0\).
Worked example: reading quark content
Find the charge, baryon number and strangeness of the Ω⁻, made of sss, and of the K⁺, made of u s̄. 1. Ω⁻: charge \(3 \times (-\tfrac{1}{3}) = -1\); baryon number \(3 \times \tfrac{1}{3} = 1\); strangeness \(3 \times (-1) = -3\). 2. K⁺: charge \(+\tfrac{2}{3} + \tfrac{1}{3} = +1\), since the antistrange quark has charge \(+\tfrac{1}{3}\); baryon number \(\tfrac{1}{3} - \tfrac{1}{3} = 0\), so it is a meson; strangeness +1. 3. Check: the superscripts in the names match the charges. The Ω⁻ was predicted from the pattern of hadron charges and strangeness before it was found at Brookhaven in 1964 with the predicted properties, a major early success for the ideas behind quarks.
Colour and confinement
The Ω⁻ seems to break the Pauli exclusion principle: three identical strange quarks in the same state. The fix is a new property called colour charge, with three values named red, green and blue (nothing to do with real colour). Every observed hadron is colourless: a baryon holds one quark of each colour, and a meson pairs a colour with its anticolour. The force between colour charges, described by quantum chromodynamics (QCD), is carried by eight massless gluons that themselves carry colour. Unlike electric force, it does not weaken as quarks separate. Pulling quarks apart stores so much energy that new quark-antiquark pairs form, so a collision yields sprays of hadrons called jets, never a lone quark. This is confinement.
The evidence for quarks
No quark has been isolated, yet the evidence is overwhelming. From 1968, experiments at SLAC found high-energy electrons scattering off small, point-like charges inside protons, much as Rutherford's alpha particles revealed the nucleus. The charm quark appeared in 1974 in the J/ψ meson, the bottom quark in 1977 and the top quark, at Fermilab, in 1995. In 1979, collisions in Germany produced three-jet events, the signature of a quark pair emitting a gluon. All of it fits the six-flavour, three-colour picture.
Worked example: beta decay inside the neutron
Show what happens to the quarks when a neutron decays, n → p + e⁻ + ν̄ₑ. 1. Write the quark content: udd becomes uud. 2. So one down quark has turned into an up quark: d → u + e⁻ + ν̄ₑ. 3. Check the charge: \(-\tfrac{1}{3}\) on the left; \(+\tfrac{2}{3} - 1 + 0 = -\tfrac{1}{3}\) on the right. 4. Check baryon number: \(\tfrac{1}{3}\) → \(\tfrac{1}{3}\), with the leptons contributing 0. 5. The process: the d quark emits a virtual W⁻ boson and becomes a u; the W⁻ turns into the electron and antineutrino. Only the weak force can change a quark's flavour, which is also why weak decays alone change strangeness.
The Standard Model
QCD and the electroweak theory together form the Standard Model. In the 1960s Sheldon Glashow, Abdus Salam and Steven Weinberg showed that the electromagnetic and weak forces are two faces of one electroweak force, unified at energies above about 100 GeV. Their theory predicted the W and Z bosons, found at CERN in 1983 with the predicted masses. It also needed a Higgs field, whose interactions give the W, Z, quarks and charged leptons their masses. Its particle, the Higgs boson, was discovered at the LHC in 2012 with a mass of about 125 GeV/c², completing the model. The Standard Model leaves out gravity, does not explain dark matter, and had to be extended to give neutrinos mass.
Grand unified theories
A grand unified theory, or GUT, would merge the strong force with the electroweak force into one. The forces' strengths drift closer together as collision energy rises, and extrapolating suggests they come close to meeting near \(10^{15}\) to \(10^{16}\) GeV, roughly a hundred billion times the LHC's 13.6 TeV. No GUT has been confirmed. Most predict that the proton decays, for example into a positron and a neutral pion, breaking baryon number conservation. Going further, a theory of everything would include gravity too. String theory, which pictures particles as tiny vibrating strings, is the best-known attempt, but it is speculative and has made no tested prediction.
Worked example: hunting for proton decay
The Super-Kamiokande detector in Japan watches about 22,500 t of water for proton decays. How many decays per year would it see if the proton lifetime were \(1.0 \times 10^{34}\) years? 1. Moles of water:
2. Each H₂O molecule holds 10 protons (2 in hydrogen, 8 in oxygen):
3. When the lifetime is vastly longer than the watching time, decays per year are about \(N\) divided by the lifetime, assuming every decay is detected: \(7.52 \times 10^{33}/10^{34} = 0.75\). 4. Check: none has been seen in over 25 years, so the lifetime for this decay must exceed about \(10^{34}\) years, nearly a trillion trillion times the universe's age.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, giving the antistrange or antidown quark the same charge as its quark; antiquarks have the opposite charge, \(+\tfrac{1}{3}e\). Second, assuming fractional charges can appear on free particles; confinement allows only whole-number totals. Third, calling the proton or neutron fundamental; they are made of quarks, while leptons are fundamental. Fourth, saying the strong force can change a quark's flavour; only the weak force can. Fifth, presenting GUTs or string theory as established; the Standard Model is tested, they are not.
Key takeaways
Baryons are three quarks; mesons are a quark and an antiquark. The six flavours, in three generations, have charges +2/3 e (u, c, t) and −1/3 e (d, s, b). The proton is uud and the neutron udd. Gluons bind colour charges so tightly that quarks stay confined in colourless hadrons. The weak force changes quark flavour, as in beta decay. QCD plus electroweak theory form the Standard Model, completed by the Higgs boson at 125 GeV in 2012. GUTs predict proton decay, which no experiment has seen.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A fundamental particle with fractional charge that builds hadrons
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What is the charge of a baryon made of the quarks u, u and s?
Question 2 of 5
Which quark combination describes a meson?
Question 3 of 5
Why has no experiment ever produced a free quark?
Question 4 of 5
Which discovery, made at the LHC in 2012, completed the Standard Model?
Question 5 of 5
A detector holds 3.0 × 10³³ protons. If the proton lifetime were 1.0 × 10³⁴ years, about how many decays per year would it expect?
