Physics › Section T · Special relativity › Topic T.4

Relativistic addition of velocities

Add two speeds close to that of light the old way and you get more than light speed, which nature never allows. Relativity replaces simple addition with a formula that agrees with it at everyday speeds but never exceeds c.

When simple addition breaks

A ship passes Earth at \(0.600c\) and launches a probe forwards at \(0.700c\) relative to the ship. Simple addition, from the topic on relative velocity, predicts \(1.300c\) relative to Earth, faster than light. Worse, a light pulse fired forwards would travel at \(1.600c\), contradicting the second postulate. Simple addition assumes that both observers measure time and distance alike, and the last two topics showed they do not. Once time dilation, length contraction and the relativity of simultaneity are all included, velocities combine by a new rule.

Setting up the frames

This topic deals only with motion along one line, with a chosen positive direction. Frame S is, say, Earth. Frame S′ is a ship moving at velocity \(v\) relative to S. An object, such as a probe, has velocity \(u'\) measured in the ship's frame, and velocity \(u\) measured in Earth's frame. Classically, \(u = v + u'\), the rule used for walkways, boats and aircraft. Each velocity carries a sign: positive along the chosen direction, negative against it. Keeping track of which observer measures which velocity is half the work in every relativity problem.

The relativistic rule

The correct rule, which follows from the earlier results, is

u = \frac{v + u'}{1 + \dfrac{vu'}{c^2}}

The numerator is the classical sum; the denominator is the correction. When either speed is small compared with \(c\), \(vu'/c^2\) is tiny, the denominator is almost 1, and the classical rule returns. To go the other way, finding the velocity in the ship's frame from Earth's measurement, swap the roles and reverse the frame velocity:

u' = \frac{u - v}{1 - \dfrac{uv}{c^2}}

Both forms use the same sign convention, so negative values go in with their signs.

Light and the speed limit

Put a light pulse into the rule: \(u' = c\). Then

u = \frac{v + c}{1 + v/c} = \frac{v + c}{(c + v)/c} = c

whatever the ship's speed \(v\). The formula builds in the second postulate: everyone measures light at \(c\). More generally, if \(v\) and \(u'\) are both less than \(c\) in size, \(u\) is always less than \(c\) as well. Combine \(0.900c\) with \(0.900c\) and the result is \(0.994c\), not \(1.800c\). No sequence of launches from launches can push an object up to light speed.

Worked example: launching a probe

A ship moves away from Earth at \(0.600c\) and launches a probe at \(0.700c\) relative to the ship. Find the probe's velocity relative to Earth if it is launched forwards, then backwards. Take away from Earth as positive. 1. Forwards, \(u' = +0.700c\):

u = \frac{0.600c + 0.700c}{1 + (0.600)(0.700)} = \frac{1.300c}{1.420} = 0.915c

2. Backwards, \(u' = -0.700c\):

u = \frac{0.600c - 0.700c}{1 - 0.420} = \frac{-0.100c}{0.580} = -0.172c

3. Check: the forward result is below both \(c\) and the classical \(1.300c\); the backward probe moves towards Earth, as the minus sign says, faster than the classical \(0.100c\).

Worked example: two ships meeting

Two ships approach Earth from opposite sides, each at \(0.800c\) in Earth's frame. How fast does each crew see the other ship approach? 1. Let S be Earth and S′ ship A, moving at \(v = +0.800c\). Ship B has \(u = -0.800c\) in Earth's frame. 2. Velocity of B in A's frame:

u' = \frac{-0.800c - 0.800c}{1 - (-0.800)(0.800)} = \frac{-1.600c}{1.640} = -0.976c

3. So each crew sees the other approaching at \(0.976c\). Check: Earth's observers see the gap closing at \(1.600c\). That is allowed, because a closing rate between two objects is not the velocity of any one object; each ship still moves slower than \(c\).

Why everyday speeds add simply

On a train moving at 30 m/s you throw a ball forwards at 20 m/s. The correction term is

\frac{vu'}{c^2} = \frac{(30)(20)}{(3.00 \times 10^8)^2} = 6.7 \times 10^{-15}

so the ball's speed relative to the ground is less than 50 m/s by only about \(3 \times 10^{-13}\) m/s, far below anything measurable. Even combining two speeds of 10 km/s, close to the speed a spacecraft needs to leave Earth, the correction is about one part in a billion. That is why the classical rule served physics so well for centuries, and why it remains the right tool below about 1% of \(c\).

The relativistic Doppler effect

The speed of light never changes, but its wavelength and frequency do when source and observer move apart or together. For light, with a relative velocity \(u\) taken as positive when the source and observer separate,

\lambda_{\text{obs}} = \lambda_s\sqrt{\frac{1 + u/c}{1 - u/c}}

and the frequency changes the opposite way:

f_{\text{obs}} = f_s\sqrt{\frac{1 - u/c}{1 + u/c}}

A receding source gives longer wavelengths, a red shift; an approaching one, with \(u\) negative, gives a blue shift. Unlike sound, only the relative velocity matters, since light needs no medium.

Worked example: a receding galaxy

Hydrogen in a laboratory emits red light of wavelength 656 nm. A galaxy moves away from us at \(0.200c\). At what wavelength do we receive this light? 1. Receding, so \(u = +0.200c\). 2. Substitute:

\lambda_{\text{obs}} = 656\ \mathrm{nm} \times \sqrt{\frac{1.200}{0.800}} = 656 \times 1.225 = 803\ \mathrm{nm}

3. Check: the wavelength is longer, a red shift, as expected for a receding source; 803 nm lies in the infrared. Astronomers run this reasoning backwards, measuring the shift of known spectral lines to find how fast galaxies are moving.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, adding speeds directly near \(c\): \(0.600c\) and \(0.700c\) combine to \(0.915c\), not \(1.300c\). Second, a sign slip in the denominator: in \(u = (v + u')/(1 + vu'/c^2)\) it is a plus, and negative velocities must go in with their signs. Third, mixing up \(u\) and \(u'\), which are measured by different observers. Fourth, thinking a closing rate above \(c\) breaks relativity; only an object's velocity is limited. Fifth, flipping the Doppler ratio: a receding source must give a longer wavelength and a lower frequency.

Key takeaways

For motion along one line, an object with velocity u′ in a frame moving at v has velocity u = (v + u′)/(1 + vu′/c²). The inverse is u′ = (u − v)/(1 − uv/c²). Signs show direction. At everyday speeds the correction vu′/c² is negligible and the classical sum returns. Speeds below c always combine to less than c, and light gives c in every frame. Relativistic Doppler: λ(obs) = λ(s)√((1 + u/c)/(1 − u/c)), with u positive for separation; receding sources are red-shifted, approaching ones blue-shifted.

Flashcards

Flashcard

u = (v + u′)/(1 + vu′/c²)

Relativistic velocity addition along one line

v: frame velocity; u′: object in that frame.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A ship moving at 0.500c relative to Earth fires a probe forwards at 0.500c relative to the ship. What is the probe's speed relative to Earth?

Question 2 of 5

A ship moving away from Earth at 0.900c shines a light beam backwards towards Earth. At what speed do Earth observers measure the light?

Question 3 of 5

In a laboratory two particles fly straight towards each other, each at 0.600c. What is the speed of one particle measured in the other's rest frame?

Question 4 of 5

A space probe moves directly away from Earth at 0.600c and transmits radio waves at 2.40 GHz. At what frequency are they received on Earth?

Question 5 of 5

Why do everyday velocities, such as a ball thrown forwards on a moving train, seem to add simply?

← Previous topicNext topic →