Psychology › Section O · Psychological disorders › Topic O.9

Dissociative disorders

Memory, identity and the sense of being real normally fit together seamlessly; in dissociative disorders that integration breaks down, and these disorders remain among the most debated in psychology. This topic is for education only, not for diagnosing yourself or anyone else; if you are concerned, see a qualified professional.

What dissociation means

Our memories, sense of identity, perceptions and actions usually feel like parts of one continuous self. Dissociation is a disruption in that normal integration. Mild dissociation is part of ordinary life: arriving home after a familiar drive with no memory of the route, or becoming so absorbed in a film that the room fades away. Dissociative disorders lie at the far end of this continuum, where the disruptions are severe, persistent and distressing, and are not explained by a substance, a medical condition such as epilepsy, or another disorder. The DSM-5-TR lists dissociative amnesia, depersonalisation/derealisation disorder and dissociative identity disorder. Many people with these disorders report a history of trauma.

Dissociative amnesia

Dissociative amnesia is an inability to recall important personal information, usually about a traumatic or highly stressful experience, that goes far beyond ordinary forgetting and is not caused by brain injury or substances. Most often the gap is localised, covering a specific period such as the hours around an assault. Less often it is selective, covering only parts of an event, or, rarely, generalised, covering a person's whole life history. The DSM-5-TR treats dissociative fugue as a specifier of this disorder: sudden travel or bewildered wandering combined with amnesia for one's identity. A small US community study found that about 1.8% of adults met the criteria for it over one year.

The recovered memory debate

Dissociative amnesia is controversial. Many memory researchers point out that traumatic events are usually remembered too well rather than forgotten, as the intrusive memories of PTSD show. They also warn that suggestion can create false memories. In the 1990s Elizabeth Loftus and colleagues showed that some adults could be led to "remember" a childhood event, such as being lost in a shopping mall, that never happened. In the same decade, memories of abuse "recovered" through suggestive therapy techniques led to bitter legal disputes. Most researchers accept that people sometimes do not think about painful events for years, but they urge great caution about memories that first appear during highly suggestive therapy.

Depersonalisation/derealisation disorder

Depersonalisation is a feeling of detachment from oneself: being an outside observer of one's own thoughts, feelings or body, or feeling robotic and unreal. Derealisation is a feeling that the surroundings are unreal, dreamlike, foggy or lifeless. In depersonalisation/derealisation disorder these experiences are persistent or recurrent and cause significant distress. Crucially, reality testing stays intact: the person knows that the feeling of unreality is just a feeling, not a fact about the world. Brief episodes are common, and about half of adults have had at least one, often during extreme stress or tiredness. The disorder itself is far rarer, affecting roughly 2% of people at some point.

Dissociative identity disorder

Dissociative identity disorder (DID), called multiple personality disorder until the DSM-IV of 1994, involves two or more distinct personality states, which some cultures describe as possession. Each state brings changes in the sense of self and agency, with altered behaviour, memory, perception or thinking. People with DID also have recurrent gaps in memory for everyday events, personal information or traumatic experiences, well beyond ordinary forgetting, and the symptoms cause significant distress. Experiences that are part of a broadly accepted cultural or religious practice, or a child's imaginary companions, do not count. A small US community study found that about 1.5% of adults had symptoms consistent with DID over one year.

Two explanations of DID

Two models compete. The trauma model proposes that DID develops when a young child faces severe, repeated trauma, often abuse, before a unified sense of self has formed; dissociating into separate states protects the child from overwhelming experience. Supporters note that most people with DID report such histories, some of which are confirmed by records, and that brain scans of people with DID differ from those of people asked to simulate it. The sociocognitive model, argued by Nicholas Spanos and others, proposes that identities are shaped by suggestion, media portrayals and therapists' expectations. Supporters note that diagnoses surged in North America in the 1980s after the condition became famous. Both factors may play a part.

Worked example: weighing a famous case

The 1973 book Sybil, about a woman said to have 16 personalities, helped make DID famous. Evaluate it as evidence. 1. Type of evidence: a single, vivid case study, which can generate hypotheses but cannot establish how common or how caused a disorder is. 2. Later scrutiny: investigations, including a 2011 book by the journalist Debbie Nathan, argued that the identities emerged during therapy that used hypnosis and drugs, and that the case was misrepresented. 3. What this shows: in at least this case, suggestion may have shaped the symptoms, supporting the sociocognitive concern. 4. What it does not show: one doubtful case cannot prove that every diagnosis of DID is false. Conclusion: judge a disorder by systematic research, not by its most famous story.

Worked example: dissociation, psychosis or everyday life?

Compare three descriptions to practise the key distinctions. 1. A driver arrives home with no memory of the familiar route but drove safely: everyday absorption, a normal and harmless form of dissociation. 2. For months, someone feels as if they are watching their own life like a film, while knowing this is only a feeling: this matches depersonalisation, because reality testing is intact. 3. Someone firmly believes their body has literally been replaced by a machine and cannot be persuaded otherwise: this is a delusion, a psychotic symptom, because reality testing is lost. Conclusion: whether the person recognises the experience as unreal separates dissociation from psychosis. Distinguishing such experiences in a real person requires a qualified clinician.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing dissociative identity disorder with schizophrenia: DID involves distinct identity states, while schizophrenia involves psychosis. Second, treating brief, everyday dissociation as a disorder. Third, assuming memories recovered through suggestive techniques must be accurate. Fourth, swinging to the other extreme and assuming every DID diagnosis is faked. Fifth, believing media images of people with DID as dangerous. Sixth, forgetting that depersonalisation keeps reality testing intact. Seventh, using these descriptions to label yourself or others instead of seeking a professional assessment.

Key takeaways

Dissociation is a disruption in the normal integration of memory, identity, perception and action; mild forms are everyday experiences. Dissociative amnesia is a loss of important personal memories beyond ordinary forgetting, with fugue as a specifier. Its validity is debated, and suggestion can create false memories, as Loftus showed. Depersonalisation/derealisation disorder involves persistent feelings that oneself or the world is unreal, with reality testing intact. Dissociative identity disorder involves two or more personality states and memory gaps. The trauma model links DID to severe early trauma; the sociocognitive model stresses suggestion and media. Case studies such as Sybil cannot settle the question.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Dissociation

A disruption in the normal integration of memory, identity, perception and action

Mild forms are everyday experiences.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What is the core feature of dissociation?

Question 2 of 5

What most clearly distinguishes depersonalisation from a psychotic delusion?

Question 3 of 5

How does the DSM-5-TR classify dissociative fugue?

Question 4 of 5

The sociocognitive model of dissociative identity disorder proposes that identity states are:

Question 5 of 5

Why do memory researchers urge caution about memories first "recovered" during highly suggestive therapy?

← Previous topicNext topic →