Psychology › Section G · Thinking and intelligence › Topic G.4
Intelligence and creativity
Is intelligence one general ability or many separate ones, and is a gifted painter intelligent in the same way as a gifted mathematician? This topic compares the main theories of intelligence, the evidence for each, and how creativity relates to them.
What do we mean by intelligence?
Psychologists have never agreed on one definition, but most include the ability to learn from experience, reason, solve problems and adapt to new situations. Two questions divide the theories. Is intelligence a single general capacity or a collection of separate abilities? And should it cover only the reasoning measured in schools, or also practical, social and creative skills? The answers matter, because a theory decides what gets measured and who is labelled able. The next two topics cover measurement and where differences come from.
Spearman's general intelligence, g
In 1904 the British psychologist Charles Spearman noticed that children who did well on one kind of school test tended to do well on others, from vocabulary to arithmetic to musical pitch. Using factor analysis, a statistical method for finding what a set of correlated scores have in common, he proposed a general intelligence factor, g, that contributes to performance on every mental task, plus specific abilities for each task. The core observation has held up extremely well in large samples, though what g actually is remains debated. Louis Thurstone argued in the 1930s for several primary abilities instead, but even his abilities turned out to correlate.
Fluid and crystallised intelligence
Raymond Cattell, later working with John Horn, split general ability into two broad kinds. Fluid intelligence is the ability to reason and solve new problems that do not depend on prior knowledge, such as completing an unfamiliar pattern or working out a puzzle's rule. Crystallised intelligence is accumulated knowledge and skill, such as vocabulary, general knowledge and arithmetic facts. They follow different paths with age: fluid intelligence tends to peak in early adulthood and decline gradually, while crystallised intelligence often keeps rising into middle age and holds up well later.
The CHC model
Many researchers now combine these ideas in the Cattell-Horn-Carroll (CHC) model, named after Cattell, Horn and John Carroll, whose 1993 reanalysis of more than 460 data sets supported a hierarchy. At the top sits general ability, g. In the middle are broad abilities, such as fluid reasoning, crystallised knowledge, short-term memory, visual processing and processing speed. At the bottom are many narrow abilities, such as memory span or reading speed, which are the ones tests measure directly. The model reconciles the one-or-many debate: abilities are distinct but correlated, sharing a general component. Most modern tests are built around it.
Worked example: classifying tasks
Fluid or crystallised? 1. Defining the word "ephemeral": it depends on vocabulary already learned, so crystallised. 2. Working out the next shape in a sequence of abstract figures you have never seen: reasoning about a new problem, so fluid. 3. Recalling that the French Revolution began in 1789: stored knowledge, so crystallised. 4. Finding a new route home when your usual road is closed and you do not know the area: reasoning in a new situation, so fluid. 5. Predict: a 70-year-old would probably match or beat a 25-year-old on tasks 1 and 3, but be slower on tasks 2 and 4.
Sternberg's triarchic theory
Robert Sternberg argued in the 1980s that tests capture only part of what makes people succeed, and proposed a triarchic theory. Analytical intelligence is the ability to analyse, compare and evaluate, the kind schools reward. Creative intelligence is the ability to deal with novel situations and generate new ideas. Practical intelligence, sometimes called "street smarts", is the ability to apply knowledge to everyday problems and adapt to one's surroundings, such as reading what a manager really wants. The theory has been influential, but critics argue that its measures of practical intelligence overlap heavily with g, and the claim that the three are independent has weak support.
Gardner's multiple intelligences
Howard Gardner proposed in 1983 that people have several independent intelligences, later listing eight: linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily-kinaesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal and naturalistic. He drew on cases such as savants and people whose brain damage removes one ability but spares others. The idea is popular with teachers because it suggests everyone is intelligent in some way. Most researchers, however, find little evidence for it: the proposed intelligences are not independent, since linguistic, logical and spatial scores correlate strongly, and few are measured by validated tests. Critics also ask whether musical or athletic skill should be called intelligence rather than talent.
Emotional and cultural intelligence
Peter Salovey and John Mayer introduced emotional intelligence in 1990: the ability to perceive, understand, use and manage emotions in yourself and others. Daniel Goleman's 1995 bestseller claimed it could matter more than IQ. Research supports it as a measurable set of skills with modest links to social and work outcomes, but critics note inconsistent definitions, and self-report questionnaires overlap with personality traits. Ideas of intelligence also vary by culture. Robert Serpell's research in rural Zambia found that local ideas of a clever child included social responsibility as well as quick thinking, which Western tests do not measure.
Creativity
Creativity is the ability to produce ideas or products that are both new and useful or appropriate; novelty alone is not enough, since a random string of words is new but not creative. J. P. Guilford distinguished divergent thinking, generating many possible answers to an open problem, from convergent thinking, narrowing down to the single best answer. A common test of divergent thinking asks for as many uses as possible for a brick. Creativity and intelligence are only modestly correlated, at about 0.2 in large reviews, so high intelligence does not guarantee creativity. Major creative work also tends to need deep knowledge of a field, persistence and willingness to take risks.
Worked example: convergent or divergent?
1. "Solve 3x + 4 = 19": there is one correct answer, x = 5, so convergent thinking. 2. "List as many uses for a paperclip as you can in two minutes": there are many acceptable answers, scored for number and originality, so divergent thinking. 3. "Design a poster for a recycling campaign": divergent thinking to generate ideas, then convergent thinking to choose and refine the best one. 4. "Find the word linked to cottage, swiss and cake": this remote-associates item has one answer, cheese, so it is usually classed as convergent, though finding it means searching widely through associations, which is why it is used to study creativity. 5. Check: real creative work usually alternates between producing options and selecting among them.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating g and multiple abilities as incompatible: the CHC model includes both. Second, thinking crystallised intelligence declines as early as fluid intelligence: it often rises into middle age. Third, presenting Gardner's intelligences as established fact: they have little empirical support and are not independent. Fourth, assuming emotional intelligence is a proven replacement for IQ: its definition and measurement are still debated. Fifth, defining creativity as mere novelty: it must also be useful or appropriate. Sixth, assuming high intelligence guarantees creativity: the two are only modestly related.
Key takeaways
Intelligence includes learning from experience, reasoning, problem solving and adapting. Spearman's g rests on the robust finding that mental test scores correlate. Cattell and Horn separated fluid intelligence (new problems, declining gradually from early adulthood) from crystallised intelligence (knowledge, often rising into middle age). The CHC model arranges g, broad and narrow abilities in a hierarchy. Sternberg's triarchic theory adds creative and practical intelligence; Gardner's eight intelligences are popular but weakly supported. Emotional intelligence is measurable but contested, and cultures define intelligence differently. Creativity is producing what is new and useful, combining divergent and convergent thinking, and is only modestly linked to intelligence.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Ability to learn from experience, reason, solve problems and adapt
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Spearman proposed g mainly because he observed that:
Question 2 of 5
Which task depends most on crystallised intelligence?
Question 3 of 5
What is the main scientific criticism of Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences?
Question 4 of 5
A manager who quickly works out how to get a reluctant team to cooperate, without any formal training, shows which part of Sternberg's theory?
Question 5 of 5
Asked to list as many uses for an old tyre as possible, a student gives twenty varied answers. This mainly measures:
