Psychology › Section G · Thinking and intelligence › Topic G.2

Language

By about age four, most children in every culture speak in complex sentences without a single grammar lesson. This topic covers the building blocks of language, how children acquire it, why timing matters, and how far the language you speak shapes the way you think.

What makes language special

Many animals communicate: bees dance to signal where food is, and vervet monkeys give different alarm calls for eagles and leopards. Language is a particular kind of communication system in which a set of symbols, words or signs, is combined by rules to express meaning. Three features set it apart. It is generative: a limited stock of words and rules produces an unlimited number of new sentences. It allows displacement: we can talk about the past, the future, the imaginary and the far away, far more freely than a bee's dance can point to distant food. And it takes several forms: spoken, written, and signed languages such as British Sign Language, which are full languages with their own grammar, not mimes of speech.

The building blocks

A phoneme is the smallest unit of sound that can change meaning in a language: "pat" and "bat" differ by one phoneme. English has roughly 40 to 45 phonemes, depending on accent, and each language uses its own set. A morpheme is the smallest unit that carries meaning; it can be a whole word ("book") or a part ("-s" for plural, "un-" for not). The lexicon is a language's stock of words. Grammar, the system of rules for using them, includes syntax, the rules for ordering words, and semantics, how meaning is drawn from words and sentences. "The dog bit the man" and "The man bit the dog" use the same words; syntax changes the meaning.

Worked example: counting units

Break each item into its units. 1. "Unbreakable" has three morphemes: "un-" (not), "break" and "-able" (can be). 2. "Cats" has two morphemes, "cat" and the plural "-s", and four phonemes: the sounds k, a, t and s. 3. "Dogs" also has four phonemes, but its plural ending is pronounced z, not s; the morpheme is the same even though the sound differs. 4. "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously", a sentence Noam Chomsky made famous (quoted in his US spelling), has correct syntax but no sensible meaning. 5. Check: phonemes concern sound, morphemes concern meaning, syntax concerns order and semantics concerns sense; a sentence can pass one test and fail another.

From cries to sentences

Language development follows a similar timetable across cultures, though individual children vary. Newborns already prefer their mother's voice, which they heard in the womb. Babies coo from about two months and begin babbling, repeating syllables such as "ba-ba", at around six months; deaf babies exposed to sign language babble with their hands. First words usually appear around 12 months, and in the one-word stage a single word can carry a whole message: "juice" may mean "I want juice". Around 18 to 24 months vocabulary grows quickly and two-word phrases appear, such as "more milk", followed by longer sentences. By about four or five, most children use complex grammar.

Tuning in to one language

Young babies can tell apart speech sounds from any language, including contrasts their parents cannot hear. In the early 1980s Janet Werker and Richard Tees showed that English-learning infants could distinguish sounds from Hindi and from a First Nations language at six to eight months, but most had lost this by ten to twelve months. Their perception had narrowed to the sounds that matter in the language around them. Babies are also skilled statistical learners. In a 1996 study, eight-month-olds who heard two minutes of a stream of made-up syllables could tell which syllables tended to follow one another, a likely clue to where words begin and end.

Worked example: what "I goed" reveals

A three-year-old says, "I goed to the park and saw two mouses." Earlier she said "went" correctly. 1. Notice: she has never heard an adult say "goed" or "mouses", so these are not copies. 2. Infer: she has extracted rules, add "-ed" for the past and "-s" for the plural, and is applying them to irregular words. This error is called overgeneralisation. 3. Explain the dip: "went" was first memorised whole; the new rule temporarily overrides it, and the correct form returns later. 4. Evaluate: imitation and reinforcement, the account B. F. Skinner proposed in 1957, cannot easily explain forms no one modelled or rewarded.

Nature, nurture or both?

Skinner argued that children learn language as they learn other behaviour, through imitation and reinforcement. Noam Chomsky replied, from 1959 onwards, that children produce sentences they have never heard and master grammar from limited and messy input, so humans must have an inborn capacity for language, sometimes called universal grammar. Striking support came from Nicaragua in the 1970s and 1980s, where deaf children brought together in new schools created a new sign language, Nicaraguan Sign Language, which grew more grammatically complex with each new group of children. Most researchers now take an interactionist view: a biological readiness for language that needs rich social input to develop.

A sensitive period

Language seems easiest to acquire early in life. In 1989 Jacqueline Johnson and Elissa Newport tested Korean and Chinese immigrants to the United States on English grammar. Those who arrived before about age seven performed like native speakers; performance fell steadily with later arrival. The case of Genie, a girl found in Los Angeles in 1970 at 13 after years of extreme isolation and abuse, is often cited too: she learned many words but never mastered grammar. Her case is weak evidence, since her abuse and possible early developmental problems confound it, and it raised ethical concerns about studying a vulnerable child. Most researchers now speak of a sensitive period rather than a strict critical period.

Does language shape thought?

The linguistic relativity hypothesis, linked with Edward Sapir and Benjamin Lee Whorf, proposes that the language you speak shapes how you think. Its strong form, linguistic determinism, says language limits what you can think; this is now rejected. In the early 1970s Eleanor Rosch (then publishing as Eleanor Heider) found that the Dani of New Guinea, whose language has only two basic colour terms, still remembered vivid focal colours better than other shades, much as English speakers do. Weaker effects do appear: Russian has separate basic words for light and dark blue, and Russian speakers tell those shades apart slightly faster. Speakers of Guugu Yimithirr in Australia describe locations by compass direction, not left and right, and track north remarkably well.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating communication with language: animal signals lack the open-ended generative rules of language, and few show even limited displacement. Second, confusing phonemes (units of sound) with morphemes (units of meaning). Third, treating sign languages as gestures rather than full languages with grammar. Fourth, reading errors such as "goed" as failures: they show a rule has been learned. Fifth, presenting Genie as proof of a critical period: her case is confounded by abuse. Sixth, stating the strong Sapir-Whorf view as fact: language can nudge perception and memory, but it does not set the limits of thought.

Key takeaways

Language combines symbols by rules; it is generative, allows displacement, and can be spoken, written or signed. Phonemes are units of sound, morphemes units of meaning; grammar covers syntax (order) and semantics (meaning). Babies coo, babble at about six months, say first words around 12 months and combine words around 18 to 24 months; their sound perception narrows to their own language by about ten to twelve months. Overgeneralisation shows rule learning. Skinner stressed reinforcement, Chomsky an inborn capacity; most researchers now combine both. Johnson and Newport's findings support a sensitive period; Genie's case is confounded. Strong linguistic determinism is rejected, but weaker effects of language on thought are supported.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Language

Symbols combined by rules to express meaning

Generative, with displacement; spoken, written or signed.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How many morphemes are in the word "replayed"?

Question 2 of 5

A child who used to say "feet" now says "foots". What is the best interpretation?

Question 3 of 5

Johnson and Newport (1989) tested immigrants' English grammar. What did they find?

Question 4 of 5

The Dani, whose language has only two basic colour terms, remembered vivid focal colours better than other shades. This finding challenges:

Question 5 of 5

Why is Genie's case considered weak evidence for a critical period for language?

← Previous topicNext topic →