Psychology › Section I · Lifespan development › Topic I.2
Lifespan theories
Five thinkers shaped how psychology describes growing up: Freud, Erikson, Piaget, Vygotsky and Kohlberg. This topic sets out what each proposed, how they answer the big questions of development, and how well each has held up against later evidence.
Theories as maps, and Freud's start
A developmental theory is a map: it predicts what changes, when and why. Most of the classic theories are stage theories, which treat development as discontinuous. Sigmund Freud proposed five psychosexual stages, oral, anal, phallic, latency and genital, each centred on a different source of bodily pleasure, and argued that unresolved conflicts could leave a person fixated at a stage. Little modern research supports these stages, and the personality topics examine them more closely. Freud's lasting contribution was the idea that childhood experiences shape the adult, which every theory below accepts in some form.
Erikson's eight psychosocial stages
Erik Erikson replaced Freud's sexual focus with a social one and extended development across the whole life. At each stage a person faces a central conflict, and a good resolution builds a lasting strength. In approximate ages: trust versus mistrust (birth to 1); autonomy versus shame and doubt (1 to 3); initiative versus guilt (3 to 6); industry versus inferiority (6 to 12); identity versus role confusion (adolescence); intimacy versus isolation (young adulthood); generativity versus stagnation, contributing to the next generation (middle adulthood); and integrity versus despair, looking back on life with acceptance or regret (late adulthood). The scheme is widely used but hard to test directly, and its ages are loose guides.
Piaget: children build their understanding
Jean Piaget, a Swiss psychologist, watched children closely, including his own, and concluded that they reason differently from adults, not just with less knowledge. Children build schemas, mental frameworks for understanding objects and events. They take in new experiences through assimilation, fitting them into an existing schema, and change schemas through accommodation when the schema does not fit. A toddler whose schema for "bird" is anything that flies may call an aeroplane a bird (assimilation); learning that aeroplanes are machines forces a new category (accommodation). Piaget proposed four stages of cognitive development, each a new way of thinking.
Piaget's first two stages
In the sensorimotor stage, from birth to about 2, infants know the world through senses and actions: mouthing, grasping, shaking. Its key achievement is object permanence, the understanding that things still exist when out of sight, which Piaget placed at around 8 months, when babies start searching for a toy hidden under a cloth. In the preoperational stage, from about 2 to 7, children use language and pretend play but cannot yet perform mental operations. They are egocentric, struggling to see a scene from another person's viewpoint, and they lack conservation, the understanding that quantity stays the same when only appearance changes.
Piaget's later stages, and the verdict
In the concrete operational stage, from about 7 to 11, children reason logically about concrete situations. They master conservation and reversibility, understanding that a change can be undone, as when pouring water back into its first glass. In the formal operational stage, from about 11 or 12, adolescents can reason abstractly and test hypotheses systematically. Later research kept Piaget's sequence but revised the details. Renée Baillargeon's looking-time studies suggest infants expect hidden objects to persist months earlier than Piaget thought, development often looks more gradual than his stages, and culture and schooling affect formal reasoning. Some theorists add a postformal stage in adulthood, when logic is balanced with context.
Vygotsky: learning through others
Lev Vygotsky, a Soviet psychologist who died in 1934 aged 37, emphasised that thinking develops through social interaction and is shaped by culture and language. His central idea is the zone of proximal development (ZPD): the gap between what a child can do alone and what the child can do with help from a more skilled person. Learning works best inside that zone. Later researchers named the support that makes this possible scaffolding: help adjusted to the learner and withdrawn as skill grows. Vygotsky also saw children's private speech, talking themselves through a task, as a tool for guiding their own thinking, which later becomes silent inner speech.
Kohlberg: stages of moral reasoning
Lawrence Kohlberg extended Piaget's approach to morality. He posed dilemmas, most famously whether a man named Heinz should steal an overpriced drug to save his dying wife, and scored the reasoning, not the yes-or-no answer. He described three levels, each with two stages. Preconventional reasoning, typical of young children, judges actions by punishment and personal gain. Conventional reasoning, common from adolescence, judges by social approval, rules and laws. Postconventional reasoning, reached by relatively few adults, judges by agreed rights and universal ethical principles, even when they conflict with the law.
Questioning Kohlberg
Carol Gilligan (1982) argued that Kohlberg's theory, built largely on interviews with boys and men, undervalued an ethic of care, centred on relationships and responsibilities, and so misjudged many women. Later reviews found only small differences between men's and women's moral reasoning once education and occupation were taken into account, but her care perspective broadened the field. Other critics note cultural bias: postconventional reasoning reflects individualist Western values. Jonathan Haidt's research suggests that many moral judgements come from fast intuitions, with reasons supplied afterwards. And reasoning well about morality does not guarantee acting well.
Worked example: scoring Heinz
Score three students' reasoning, not their answers. 1. Mia: "He shouldn't steal, because he'd go to prison." Avoiding punishment is preconventional. 2. Tom: "He should steal, because a good husband looks after his wife, and people would think badly of him otherwise." Approval and social roles are conventional. 3. Ines: "He should steal, because a human life is worth more than a shop's profit, whatever the law says." A universal principle placed above the law is postconventional. 4. Check: someone saying "he shouldn't steal, because the law must apply to everyone" reaches the opposite answer at a conventional level. The answer itself does not decide the level.
Worked example: a lesson in conservation
Five-year-old Leo watches his father spread out a row of 6 coins so it is longer than his own row of 6. Leo says his father now has more. 1. Stage: judging by the row's length, not the number, means Leo lacks conservation, typical of the preoperational stage. 2. Contrast: his 9-year-old sister says the number is the same "because you could push them back together": reversibility, a concrete operational skill. 3. Vygotsky's lens: Leo cannot solve this alone, but he can count both rows with help, so the task sits in his ZPD. 4. Scaffolding: his father asks him to count each row, then fades his prompts. 5. Check: Piaget describes Leo's level; Vygotsky shows how help can move him on.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating stage ages as fixed: they are rough averages, and children vary. Second, mixing up assimilation, fitting experience into an existing schema, with accommodation, changing the schema. Third, scoring Kohlberg's dilemmas by the answer rather than the reasoning. Fourth, crediting Vygotsky with the word "scaffolding": the idea follows from his work, but later researchers coined the term. Fifth, presenting Freud's psychosexual stages as established findings. Sixth, assuming Piaget was simply wrong: his sequence largely holds, while his timing underestimated infants.
Key takeaways
Freud's psychosexual stages have little research support, but his claim that childhood shapes adulthood endured. Erikson described eight psychosocial conflicts, from trust versus mistrust to integrity versus despair. Piaget saw children building schemas through assimilation and accommodation across four stages: sensorimotor (object permanence), preoperational (egocentrism, no conservation), concrete operational (conservation, reversibility) and formal operational (abstract thought); infants know more, earlier, than he thought. Vygotsky stressed social learning, the zone of proximal development and private speech. Kohlberg's preconventional, conventional and postconventional levels score moral reasoning; Gilligan's ethic of care, cultural critiques and Haidt's intuition research challenge it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Freud: oral, anal, phallic, latency, genital
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Asked about the Heinz dilemma, a child says: "He shouldn't steal the drug, because he'd get caught and be punished." Which Kohlberg level does this reasoning show?
Question 2 of 5
A child insists that a ball of clay rolled into a long sausage now contains more clay. According to Piaget, this child is most likely in which stage?
Question 3 of 5
A 16-year-old tries out different styles, friendships and career ideas while asking "Who am I really?" In Erikson's theory, this is the conflict of:
Question 4 of 5
Which statement best describes Vygotsky's zone of proximal development?
Question 5 of 5
A toddler who knows dogs calls a cat a "dog". After her parent explains the difference, she starts using the word "cat". The change in her thinking is:
