Psychology › Section F · Learning › Topic F.4

Observational learning

Nobody learns to swim, cook or swear entirely by trial and error. Much of what people do was picked up by watching someone else, and this topic explains how that works, what Albert Bandura's famous Bobo doll studies did and did not show, and why learning is more than conditioning.

Learning by watching

Observational learning is learning by watching others, called models, and then imitating them or deliberately not imitating them. It is not limited to humans. In the 1950s researchers on the Japanese island of Koshima saw a young macaque wash sweet potatoes in water before eating them; over the following years the habit spread through her troop, first to her playmates and relatives, which most researchers attribute largely to watching and copying. Unlike conditioning, which needs the learner's own experience, watching lets you learn from consequences that happened to someone else, which is far safer when the lesson is a burn or a bite.

Bandura's social learning theory

Albert Bandura argued that strict behaviourism could not explain how people learn without being reinforced themselves. His social learning theory, later renamed social cognitive theory, added thinking to the picture: observers notice, remember and judge what they see. Bandura described three kinds of model. A live model performs the behaviour in person, as a coach demonstrating a serve. A verbal instructional model describes the behaviour without performing it, as when a recipe tells you what to do. A symbolic model is a real or fictional person shown in films, books, games or online videos.

The Bobo doll study (1961)

Bandura, Dorothea Ross and Sheila Ross tested 72 children aged roughly three to six at a university nursery school. Some watched an adult attack an inflatable clown called Bobo in distinctive ways, hitting it with a mallet and shouting phrases such as "Pow!"; others saw a quiet adult; a third group saw no model. Each child was then mildly frustrated by being denied some attractive toys, and left with toys that included Bobo. Children who had watched the aggressive adult copied many of the exact acts and words, and showed more aggression overall. Boys imitated more physical aggression than girls.

Rewarded and punished models

In a 1965 follow-up, children watched a film in which a model attacked Bobo and was then rewarded, punished or shown no consequence. Children who saw the model punished imitated the least. This is vicarious punishment; seeing a model rewarded, which makes imitation more likely, is vicarious reinforcement. When Bandura then offered every child a reward for showing what the model had done, the differences almost vanished: the punished-model group had learned the behaviour just as well but chosen not to perform it. The study separates learning from performance, the same distinction met earlier in this section.

Four processes in modelling

Bandura identified four processes that must all work for observational learning to show. Attention: the observer has to notice the model, and people attend most to models who are admired, similar to themselves or successful. Retention: the observer must remember what was done, often as images or verbal summaries. Reproduction: the observer must be physically and mentally able to perform it; watching a gymnast does not let you copy a backflip. Motivation: the observer needs a reason to act, which depends on vicarious reinforcement or punishment and on the consequences they expect for themselves.

Worked example: the four processes

Jamal, aged 15, wants to learn a skateboard trick from an online video by a skater he admires. 1. Attention: he watches closely because the model is skilled and admired, slowing the key moment. 2. Retention: he describes the foot positions to himself in words so he can recall them at the park. 3. Reproduction: his first attempts fail for lack of balance, so he practises a simpler version first. 4. Motivation: the skater's large following acts as vicarious reinforcement, and he expects his friends' approval. 5. Check: if any one process fails, the learning may exist but will not show in performance.

Worked example: weighing the Bobo evidence

1. What it shows: children readily copy specific new acts and words from an adult model without being rewarded, an effect repeated many times. 2. Limits: Bobo is a toy designed to be hit and bounce back, so striking it may be play rather than aggression towards a person. 3. The setting was artificial, the model a stranger, and behaviour was measured only minutes later. 4. Children may have guessed what the adults expected. 5. Ethics: researchers deliberately frustrated young children and modelled aggression to them, which would face close review today. 6. Verdict: strong evidence for imitation, much weaker evidence about real-world violence.

Prosocial and antisocial models

Modelling works for good behaviour as well as bad: children whose parents read, volunteer or apologise tend to pick up those habits, and often copy what adults do rather than what they say. Children who see adults use violence to solve problems are more likely to use it themselves, though genes, stress and poverty also contribute. Whether violent films and games increase real aggression is still debated. Many studies find small links with aggressive thoughts and behaviour in the short term; critics such as Christopher Ferguson argue that the effects are tiny and confounded with other risk factors, and the evidence does not show that violent games cause violent crime.

Mirror neurons

In the 1990s Giacomo Rizzolatti and colleagues in Parma found neurons in the frontal lobe of macaque monkeys that fired both when a monkey grasped an object and when it watched a person grasp one. These mirror neurons seemed a possible basis for imitation and for understanding other people's actions. Brain imaging suggests that humans have similar systems, but single-neuron recordings in people are rare, and many researchers think early claims that mirror neurons explain empathy, language or autism went far beyond the evidence. Treat them as one promising mechanism, not as a settled explanation.

Insight, helplessness and self-efficacy

During the 1910s Wolfgang Köhler watched a chimpanzee, Sultan, fail to reach fruit and then, after a pause, join two sticks to rake it in: a sudden solution he called insight. In 1967 Martin Seligman and Steven Maier found that dogs given shocks they could not escape later failed to escape shocks they could; they called this learned helplessness, and linked it to depression in humans, though the theory has since been revised and the use of shock is ethically troubling. Bandura's self-efficacy, a person's belief that they can succeed at a task, grows through mastery, watching similar others succeed, and encouragement.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating observational learning with copying: observers may learn and then choose not to act, as the punished-model children did. Second, thinking a model must be present: symbolic models in videos and books work too. Third, forgetting reproduction: watching a skill does not guarantee the ability to perform it. Fourth, citing the Bobo doll as proof that media cause violence: it showed imitation of acts towards a toy in a short laboratory session. Fifth, treating mirror neurons as a proven explanation of empathy. Sixth, mixing up vicarious reinforcement (a model rewarded) with direct reinforcement (you rewarded).

Key takeaways

Observational learning means learning from models: live, verbal instructional or symbolic. Bandura's 1961 Bobo doll study showed that children copy an adult's specific aggressive acts without being rewarded; his 1965 study showed that a punished model reduces performance but not learning. Modelling needs attention, retention, reproduction and motivation, with vicarious reinforcement and punishment shaping motivation. The imitation findings are robust, but the setting and the toy limit what they say about real violence. Mirror neurons are a contested mechanism. Köhler's insight, Seligman and Maier's learned helplessness and Bandura's self-efficacy show cognition at work in learning.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Observational learning

Learning by watching others and imitating or not imitating them

Also called modelling or social learning.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Bandura's 1965 study, children who saw a model punished imitated least, until they were offered a reward for copying. What did this show?

Question 2 of 5

Ella watches a tutorial on juggling three balls many times but still cannot do it, because her hands are not yet quick enough. Which of Bandura's processes is failing?

Question 3 of 5

Which is a fair criticism of what the 1961 Bobo doll study can tell us?

Question 4 of 5

A teenager tries harder at chess after seeing a classmate of similar ability win a tournament. Which concept best explains the change?

Question 5 of 5

What is the most accurate summary of current evidence on violent media and aggression?

← Previous topicNext topic →