Psychology › Section M · Industrial-organizational psychology › Topic M.3
The social side of work
Two people can do identical jobs and have completely different working lives because of their manager, their team and the unwritten rules of their workplace. Organisational psychology studies that social side of work: satisfaction, stress, leadership, teams and culture.
Work is a social world
The previous topic dealt with matching individuals to jobs. Organisational psychology, the second area of I-O psychology, studies what happens once people are inside an organisation: how they feel about their jobs, how stress and home life interact with work, how managers lead, how teams function and how an organisation's culture shapes behaviour. It also studies harassment and workplace violence. Its roots lie in the Hawthorne studies and Kurt Lewin's work on group dynamics.
Job satisfaction
Edwin Locke (1976) defined job satisfaction as the pleasant emotional state that comes from appraising one's job. It is usually measured with questionnaires covering pay, supervision, co-workers and the work itself. The work itself, meaning its variety, challenge, autonomy and clarity of role, tends to predict overall satisfaction most strongly. Pay is only weakly related to satisfaction, partly because people adapt to a raise. Satisfaction correlates moderately with job performance and with organisational citizenship behaviour, helpful acts beyond formal duties, and low satisfaction goes with absenteeism and intentions to quit. Job and life satisfaction appear to influence each other.
Stress, change and the work-family balance
Job stress arises when people judge that work demands exceed their resources. Common stressors include overload, unclear roles, little control, job insecurity, harassment and bullying. Robert Karasek's demand-control model predicts most strain when high demands meet low control. Prolonged strain can lead to burnout, which Christina Maslach described as exhaustion, cynicism and reduced effectiveness; the World Health Organization lists it as an occupational phenomenon, not a medical condition. Downsizing and mergers add insecurity, even for staff who stay. Work-family conflict runs in both directions; Jeffrey Greenhaus and Nicholas Beutell (1985) traced it to time, spillover strain, and behaviour suited to one role but not the other. A supportive supervisor is one of the strongest buffers.
Theory X and Theory Y
Douglas McGregor (1960) argued that managers' assumptions about people shape how they manage. A Theory X manager assumes that workers dislike work, avoid responsibility and must be directed, watched and controlled with rules and punishments. A Theory Y manager assumes that people can find work satisfying, seek responsibility and perform best when they help set their own goals and methods. Theory X shows up as strict clocking-in rules; Theory Y as teams that decide how to meet a goal, or letting any worker stop a production line to fix a fault. McGregor saw Theory X as the traditional American approach and argued for Theory Y.
Transactional and transformational leaders
Building on James MacGregor Burns, Bernard Bass (1985) contrasted two leadership styles. A transactional leader sets goals and exchanges rewards for performance and corrections for mistakes, keeping things running. A transformational leader inspires followers to go beyond self-interest, through being a trusted role model, communicating an inspiring vision, encouraging new thinking and giving individual consideration to each follower. Research generally finds transformational leadership more effective, although good leaders use both. Meta-analyses by Alice Eagly and colleagues found that women leaders were, on average, slightly more transformational than men, with small differences. Followership research adds that fit matters: independent followers may resent tight structure that others welcome.
Worked example: diagnosing a manager
A new store manager, Dana, requires staff to clock in to the minute, rejects suggestions without discussion and offers a bonus only to whoever sells the most. Morale drops and two good employees resign. Analyse it. 1. Assumptions: close monitoring and ignoring ideas point to Theory X. 2. Leadership style: the reward-for-results bonus is transactional, with no vision or individual consideration. 3. Satisfaction: autonomy and supportive supervision, both linked to satisfaction, have fallen, so lower satisfaction and more quitting are expected. 4. Remedy: invite staff input on goals, recognise individual effort and explain the store's direction, moving towards Theory Y and transformational behaviour. 5. Check: the predicted outcome matches what happened.
Teams
Many organisations now delegate work to teams that combine different skills. Common types include problem-solving teams that tackle one issue, creative teams that develop new products, tactical teams that carry out a well-defined plan, such as an emergency response unit, and virtual teams whose members work apart and communicate digitally. Teams do not automatically outperform individuals. Social loafing lets some members coast on others' effort, pressure to conform can produce poor decisions, and conflict or weak communication wastes time. Clear goals, individual accountability and diverse but well-coordinated skills improve team performance.
Organisational culture
Organisational culture is the shared values, norms and assumptions that shape how an organisation operates and makes decisions. Edgar Schein described three levels. Artefacts are the visible signs: office layout, dress, jargon, rituals and the stories people tell. Espoused values are the stated principles, such as a published commitment to safety. Basic underlying assumptions are unspoken beliefs so taken for granted that no one questions them, and they drive behaviour most powerfully. Departments can develop subcultures. A 2006 meta-analysis by Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp found that contact between groups reduces prejudice, especially with equal status, shared goals, cooperation and support from authorities.
Worked example: reading a culture
A software firm's website says "we value work-life balance". Its offices have nap pods, but managers send emails at midnight, praise people who work weekends and promote the staff who are always online. Analyse it using Schein's levels. 1. Artefacts: the nap pods, the midnight emails and the promotion pattern are all visible. 2. Espoused value: work-life balance, as stated on the website. 3. Basic assumption, inferred from behaviour: real commitment means being available at all times. 4. Conflict: the assumption contradicts the espoused value, and assumptions usually win, so staff will feel pressure to overwork and stress may rise. 5. Check: the deepest level was inferred from what people do, not from what the firm says.
Harassment and workplace violence
In the United States, harassment based on a protected trait such as sex, race or religion is illegal. Sexual harassment takes two main forms. Quid pro quo harassment makes a job benefit, such as a promotion or good review, depend on accepting sexual advances, or threatens a penalty for refusing; it usually involves someone with power over the target. Hostile environment harassment is unwelcome conduct, such as repeated sexual jokes or explicit images, severe or pervasive enough to create an intimidating workplace; a single minor remark usually does not meet that standard. Workplace violence includes threats, intimidation and assault; feeling treated unfairly is a known trigger, and fair procedures help prevent it.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming pay is the main driver of job satisfaction; the work itself matters more. Second, equating transactional leadership with bad leadership: rewards for results are useful, but transformation adds vision and individual care. Third, mixing up Theory X and Theory Y. Fourth, judging culture by espoused values alone; basic assumptions, seen in behaviour, matter most. Fifth, assuming teams always beat individuals. Sixth, managing by generational stereotypes; research finds differences between generations at work are small compared with differences within them. Seventh, confusing quid pro quo harassment with a hostile environment.
Key takeaways
Job satisfaction is driven most by the work itself, weakly by pay, and relates to performance, citizenship behaviour and quitting. Stress grows when demands exceed control, can lead to burnout, and spills between work and family. Theory X assumes people must be controlled; Theory Y that they seek responsibility. Transformational leadership usually outperforms purely transactional leadership. Teams need clear goals and accountability. Schein's culture levels are artefacts, espoused values and basic assumptions. Harassment takes quid pro quo and hostile environment forms.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Studies satisfaction, stress, leadership, teams and culture at work
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
According to research on job satisfaction, which factor usually predicts overall satisfaction most strongly?
Question 2 of 5
A manager lets her team decide how to meet a quarterly goal and regularly asks for their ideas on improving safety. Her assumptions best match:
Question 3 of 5
Which behaviour is most characteristic of a transformational leader?
Question 4 of 5
A supervisor tells an employee that a promotion depends on agreeing to go on dates with him. This is:
Question 5 of 5
At one company everyone assumes, without ever discussing it, that the most senior person must speak first in meetings. In Schein's model this is:
