Psychology › Section D · States of consciousness › Topic D.6
Hypnosis, meditation, and other states
Consciousness shifts without sleep or drugs: a voice can narrow your attention, a practised breath can steady it, and on a long drive your mind can wander for miles. This topic looks at hypnosis, meditation and everyday altered states, and at which popular claims about them survive careful testing.
Altered states without sleep or drugs
The first topic of this section described consciousness as a continuum rather than a switch. Sleep and psychoactive drugs move us along it, but so do purely psychological techniques. Hypnosis and meditation both change how attention is directed and how experience feels, and both have moved from stage shows and religious practice into laboratories and clinics. Studying them raises a recurring question: is a reported change in experience a genuinely different state, or ordinary attention and expectation at work?
What hypnosis is
Hypnosis is a state of intensely focused attention with reduced awareness of surroundings, in which a person responds more readily to suggestions. That is close to the definition adopted by the American Psychological Association's hypnosis division in 2014. Hypnosis is not sleep: hypnotised people are awake, and their EEG does not show the slow waves of deep sleep. In clinical use, a trained professional works with a consenting client, usually as one part of a wider treatment. Stage hypnosis is different: performers pick the most responsive volunteers, and the setting pushes people to play along, so it misrepresents the clinical technique.
Inducing hypnosis, and who responds
Methods vary, but most inductions share four elements: the person focuses on one thing, such as the hypnotist's voice; is helped to relax; is encouraged to trust the process and let go; and is invited to use their imagination. People differ widely in how strongly they respond, which is measured with standard scales such as the Stanford Hypnotic Susceptibility Scale, a series of graded suggestions. Most people are at least moderately responsive, with smaller groups at the very high and very low ends. Hypnotisability behaves like a stable trait: in one long-term study, scores measured about 25 years apart were still strongly correlated.
Two theories of hypnosis
The dissociation view, developed by Ernest Hilgard, holds that hypnosis splits consciousness into streams: one part follows the suggestion while another part keeps monitoring reality outside awareness, rather as you can drive a familiar route while thinking about something else. The social-cognitive view, associated with Theodore Sarbin and later Nicholas Spanos, holds that hypnotised people are enacting the social role of a hypnotised person, shaped by their expectations of how such a person behaves. This is not the same as faking: people in the role genuinely experience the suggested effects. Brain imaging shows real changes in activity during hypnosis, and many researchers now treat the two views as complementary.
Worked example: the hidden observer, read two ways
In Hilgard's studies, hypnotised volunteers held an arm in ice water after being told they would feel no pain. They reported little pain, yet when asked to let a 'hidden part' of themselves report, that part described much more. 1. Dissociation reading: a hidden observer had registered the pain all along, outside the hypnotised stream of awareness. 2. Social-cognitive reading: the instruction itself told participants a hidden part existed, so they reported what the role required. 3. The test: Spanos and colleagues varied the instructions and found hidden-observer reports shifted in the direction the instructions implied. 4. Conclusion: the finding is real but strongly shaped by expectation, so it cannot settle the debate on its own.
What hypnosis can and cannot do
The strongest evidence is for pain: hypnosis added to standard care reliably reduces pain and distress for many patients during medical procedures. It also helps in some cases of irritable bowel syndrome and as an extra element in therapy for anxiety. Evidence for smoking cessation is weaker and inconsistent. Memory is the clearest limit. Hypnosis does not unlock accurate buried memories: it tends to increase the amount people report, true and false together, and makes them more confident. For that reason many courts treat hypnotically refreshed testimony with great caution.
Worked example: a hypnotised witness
After a robbery, a witness cannot recall the getaway car's number plate. A hypnotist helps her 'relive' the scene, and she now states a plate confidently. Evaluate the new memory. 1. Hypnosis raises suggestibility, so cues in the questioning can become part of what she remembers. 2. Hypnosis increases confidence more than accuracy, so her certainty is not evidence that the plate is right. 3. The plate is still useful as a lead to check against independent evidence, such as camera footage or registration records. 4. Conclusion: treat it as a hypothesis, not as a recovered fact.
Meditation
Meditation is the practice of training attention, often by resting it on one anchor, like breathing or a repeated word, to reach relaxed, alert awareness. Unlike hypnosis, it can be practised alone. Techniques differ: focused-attention practice holds attention on one object and returns it when it drifts, while open-monitoring practice observes whatever arises without judging it. Mindfulness meditation, which has roots in Buddhist practice, combines both. It reached Western medicine largely through mindfulness-based stress reduction, an eight-week programme developed by Jon Kabat-Zinn in 1979. EEG recordings during meditation often show more alpha and theta activity, the calm-waking and drowsy rhythms met in the sleep topics.
What the meditation evidence shows
A 2014 meta-analysis of 47 randomised trials (Goyal and colleagues) found moderate evidence that mindfulness programmes produce small improvements in anxiety, depression and pain, but no evidence that they beat other active treatments such as medication or exercise. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy lowers the risk of relapse for people with recurrent depression. Meditation may modestly lower blood pressure, though heart experts treat it as a possible addition to standard care, not a replacement. Some popular claims have not held up: early reports that a few weeks of training thickened brain regions were not confirmed in larger controlled trials. A minority of meditators also report unpleasant experiences, such as heightened anxiety.
Everyday altered states
You do not need a technique to shift consciousness. Mind wandering is the default: in a 2010 smartphone study, Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert found that people's minds were off-task nearly half the time, and that they reported feeling less happy while wandering. Flow, described by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, is the opposite pole: total absorption in a task whose challenge matches your skill, with time seeming to vanish. Highway hypnosis is a third: arriving at a familiar destination with little memory of the drive, because well-practised actions ran automatically while attention was elsewhere.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking hypnosis is a kind of sleep: hypnotised people are awake. Second, judging hypnosis by stage shows, which select and pressure volunteers. Third, believing hypnosis recovers accurate memories: it raises confidence more than accuracy. Fourth, reading the social-cognitive view as saying people are faking: they experience the effects, shaped by role expectations. Fifth, overselling meditation: its benefits are real but usually small, similar to other active treatments. Sixth, assuming any altered state needs special effort: mind wandering fills nearly half of waking life.
Key takeaways
Hypnosis is focused attention with reduced peripheral awareness and heightened response to suggestion; it is not sleep. Inductions use focus, relaxation, trust and imagination, and hypnotisability is a stable trait that varies between people. Dissociation and social-cognitive theories both explain parts of the evidence; the hidden observer is real but shaped by instructions. Hypnosis helps with pain but raises confidence in memories more than accuracy. Meditation trains attention, with small benefits for anxiety, depression and pain; some brain-change claims failed to replicate. Mind wandering, flow and highway hypnosis are everyday shifts in consciousness.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Focused attention, reduced peripheral awareness, heightened response to suggestion
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which description of hypnosis fits the current research definition best?
Question 2 of 5
Hilgard's ice-water studies, in which a 'hidden part' reported pain the hypnotised person denied, were offered as support for:
Question 3 of 5
What does research show about using hypnosis to help witnesses remember?
Question 4 of 5
The 2014 meta-analysis by Goyal and colleagues concluded that mindfulness programmes:
Question 5 of 5
According to the social-cognitive theory, the behaviour of a hypnotised person is best explained as:
