Psychology › Section O · Psychological disorders › Topic O.3

Perspectives on psychological disorders

How a society explains psychological disorders decides how it treats the people who have them, from exorcism and chains to medication and therapy. This topic is for education only, not for diagnosing yourself or anyone else; if you are worried about your mental health, see a qualified professional.

Why the explanation matters

Every perspective on psychological disorders makes a claim about their causes, and each claim points to a different response. If a disorder is caused by evil spirits, the remedy is ritual; if by a brain disease, medicine; if by faulty learning, retraining; if by poverty and discrimination, social change. Over history, explanations have shifted from the supernatural to the natural, and within modern psychology several perspectives now compete and combine.

Supernatural explanations

For much of recorded history, many societies explained disordered behaviour as possession by spirits, punishment by gods or the result of witchcraft. Responses followed from the belief: prayer, exorcism, and at times confinement, torture or execution. Some scholars have suggested that holes found in prehistoric skulls, a practice called trephination, may have been meant to release spirits, though their purpose is debated. Mainly between the 14th and 17th centuries, outbreaks of dancing mania swept parts of Europe, with groups dancing for days. Historian John Waller argues that extreme distress from famine and disease, combined with belief in a dancing curse, produced trance states that spread socially. Supernatural beliefs about mental illness persist in some communities today.

Natural causes and humane reform

Natural explanations are also ancient. Around 400 BCE the Greek physician Hippocrates argued that disorders arise from imbalances in the body's fluids, or humours, not from gods; an excess of black bile, he thought, caused melancholia. His specific theory was wrong, but the idea of a bodily cause endured. From the late 1790s the hospital superintendent Jean-Baptiste Pussin and the French physician Philippe Pinel removed chains from patients in Paris hospitals, first at the Bicêtre in 1797 and then at the Salpêtrière around 1800, and Pinel promoted "moral treatment": kindness, routine and purposeful activity. In the 1840s the American reformer Dorothea Dix campaigned for state hospitals to replace jails and poorhouses as places of care. Reform changed treatment before science had explained causes.

The biological perspective

The biological perspective, often called the medical model, treats disorders as illnesses with physical causes. A landmark came with general paresis, a devastating mental and physical decline; in 1913 researchers found the syphilis bacterium in the brains of people who had died of it, showing that a condition with psychological symptoms could have a physical cause. Modern biological research examines genes, neurotransmitters, hormones and brain structure. Heritability differs widely between disorders: roughly 80% for schizophrenia and autism, 70% to 80% for ADHD, and high for bipolar disorder, but about 35% to 40% for major depression and roughly 30% to 50% for many anxiety disorders.

Worked example: reading a heritability figure

Twin studies estimate the heritability of schizophrenia at about 80%. Work out what that does and does not mean. 1. Definition: heritability is the share of the variation in a trait across a population that is linked to genetic differences, in that population and environment. 2. It does not mean 80% of a relative's chance: an identical twin of someone with schizophrenia has a lifetime risk of roughly a third to a half, depending on the study, not 80% or 100%. 3. It does not describe one person: it is meaningless to say that 80% of an individual's illness is genetic. 4. It does not rule out environment: high heritability is compatible with strong environmental effects. Conclusion: heritability describes populations, not destinies.

Psychological perspectives

Psychological perspectives look for causes in the mind and in experience, drawing on theories from the personality and learning sections. The psychodynamic perspective, rooted in Sigmund Freud's work, traces symptoms to unconscious conflicts, often from childhood. The behavioural perspective sees disordered behaviour as learned through classical and operant conditioning and observation, and therefore open to relearning. The cognitive perspective focuses on distorted patterns of thinking, such as expecting catastrophe or blaming oneself for every failure. The humanistic perspective, associated with Carl Rogers, sees distress arising when people are blocked from growth and from living in line with their true selves. Each perspective gave rise to its own therapies.

The sociocultural perspective

The sociocultural perspective emphasises the settings people live in. Poverty, unemployment, discrimination, social isolation, family conflict and childhood adversity all raise the risk of many disorders. Culture also shapes how distress is expressed and understood: in some communities psychological suffering is described mainly through bodily symptoms, and the DSM-5-TR's cultural concepts of distress record such patterns. Protective factors matter as much as risks. Supportive relationships, a sense of belonging, coping and problem-solving skills, and access to care all make disorders less likely or less severe.

The diathesis-stress model

The diathesis-stress model, a key idea for later topics, combines vulnerability and experience. A diathesis is a predisposition to a disorder. It is often biological, such as genetic risk, but can be psychological, such as a habit of interpreting setbacks pessimistically. Stress means adverse events or conditions, such as trauma, loss, chronic pressure or maltreatment. The key assumption is that both are needed: a diathesis without enough stress may never produce a disorder, and the same stress affects people differently. The two trade off against each other: the stronger the diathesis, the less stress is needed to trigger a disorder, and the weaker the diathesis, the more stress it takes.

Worked example: applying the diathesis-stress model

Compare two hypothetical people facing the same stressor, a sudden job loss. 1. Person A has a close relative with a history of depression and tends to explain setbacks as permanent personal failures: a strong biological and psychological diathesis. 2. Person B has no known family history and tends to see setbacks as temporary and specific: a weak diathesis. 3. Prediction: the model predicts a higher risk of a depressive episode for A, because less stress is needed to cross the threshold. 4. Limits: the model gives probabilities, not certainties. B could still become depressed under severe or prolonged stress, and A may never do so, especially with strong support. Conclusion: neither factor alone predicts the outcome.

The biopsychosocial approach

Most clinicians and researchers now use a biopsychosocial approach, proposed by the psychiatrist George Engel in 1977. It holds that disorders arise from the interaction of biological factors (genes, brain chemistry and structure, physical health), psychological factors (thinking patterns, learning, coping, trauma) and social factors (relationships, culture, poverty, discrimination). These factors influence one another: chronic stress alters stress hormones, while a supportive family can soften genetic risk. The approach explains why the same disorder can arise by different routes in different people, and why effective care often combines several kinds of treatment.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming a single perspective holds the whole truth; most disorders have several interacting causes. Second, reading heritability as a personal probability or as proof that environment does not matter. Third, thinking a diathesis must be biological, when it can be psychological. Fourth, dismissing historical supernatural beliefs as simple ignorance; they made sense within their cultures and still exist. Fifth, assuming that a biological cause means talking therapy cannot help, or that a psychological cause means medication cannot. Sixth, using risk factors to predict that a particular person will develop a disorder.

Key takeaways

Explanations of disorders shape their treatment. Supernatural views blamed spirits or curses; Hippocrates proposed bodily causes, and Pussin and Pinel (from the late 1790s) and Dix (1840s) championed humane care. The medical model gained strength when syphilis was shown to cause general paresis. Heritability is about 80% for schizophrenia but about 35% to 40% for major depression, and it describes populations, not individuals. Psychodynamic, behavioural, cognitive and humanistic perspectives locate causes in the mind, and the sociocultural perspective in social settings. The diathesis-stress model needs both vulnerability and stress, and the biopsychosocial approach integrates all three kinds of factor.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Supernatural perspective

Explains disorders by spirits, gods or witchcraft

Remedies: ritual and exorcism.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did the finding that syphilis causes general paresis strengthen the medical model?

Question 2 of 5

What is Philippe Pinel best known for?

Question 3 of 5

Twin studies put the heritability of schizophrenia at about 80%. What does this mean?

Question 4 of 5

According to the diathesis-stress model, a person with a strong predisposition to a disorder:

Question 5 of 5

Which explanation of a phobia reflects the behavioural perspective?

← Previous topicNext topic →